Weak Galilean invariance as a selection principle for coarse-grained diffusive models

Andrea Cairoli, Rainer Klages, Adrian BauleProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces "weak Galilean invariance" (wGI) as a theoretical principle to select physically consistent coarse-grained stochastic models. By analyzing how Galilean invariance is broken during the coarse-graining process, the authors derive a set of rules that these models must satisfy, offering a crucial a priori check before experimental validation, especially relevant for complex systems like biological ones.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Classical mechanics relies on Galilean invariance (GI), which states that the laws of physics are the same in all inertial reference frames. However, many real-world systems are described by coarse-grained models that incorporate friction and stochastic forces. These models often violate strict GI, leaving researchers without a clear theoretical principle to assess their physical consistency across different moving reference frames. This is particularly problematic when modeling complex phenomena like anomalous diffusion, where microscopic details are often unknown, and numerous phenomenological models exist. The paper aims to fill this gap by proposing a weaker form of invariance that can guide the selection of appropriate stochastic models.

Methods

The authors start with the Kac-Zwanzig Hamiltonian model, a well-established framework for deriving generalized Langevin equations (LEs) from microscopic dynamics. They then systematically analyze how Galilean transformations (GTs) affect these coarse-grained stochastic equations. This involves deriving transformation rules for the position and velocity processes, as well as their probability density functions (PDFs), when moving between inertial frames. The core contribution is the definition of "weak Galilean invariance" (wGI), which encompasses these transformation rules. They then apply this wGI criterion to various known stochastic processes, including normal diffusion, fractional Brownian motion, Lévy flights, Lévy walks, and importantly, the continuous-time random walk (CTRW). For the CTRW, they derive the correct invariant description, highlighting how previous attempts failed to satisfy wGI.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical derivations and model analysis rather than empirical data fitting.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Weak Galilean Invariance (wGI): The central concept is that while strict GI is often broken in coarse-grained models, a weaker form of invariance related to how stochastic equations and their statistical properties transform between inertial frames can be enforced. This provides a powerful theoretical filter.
  • CTRW's Challenge: The continuous-time random walk (CTRW), a popular model for anomalous diffusion, is shown to not inherently satisfy wGI when standard advection terms are naively added. This suggests that many existing CTRW-based models might be physically inconsistent in different reference frames.
  • Theoretical Selection Principle: wGI offers a way to select physically plausible stochastic models before extensive experimental validation, saving time and resources by ruling out inconsistent models early on.
  • Universality of Anomalous Diffusion: The paper suggests that despite differences in microscopic details, anomalous diffusive systems share fundamental similarities in how their dynamics transform between reference frames, particularly concerning the influence of external flows.

Key Results

  • The authors derive the transformation rules for stochastic equations, Fokker-Planck equations, and PDFs under Galilean transformations, defining wGI.
  • They demonstrate that normal diffusion, generalized Langevin equations, fractional Brownian motion, and Lévy walks satisfy wGI.
  • Crucially, they show that a naive application of GTs to the CTRW leads to incorrect descriptions that violate wGI, and they provide the correct, wGI-compliant formulation for the CTRW.
  • The paper provides a theoretical framework that can guide the development and selection of stochastic models for complex systems, particularly in fields like biophysics.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Experimental Validation: While wGI provides a theoretical selection principle, the ultimate validation of any model still requires comparison with experimental data.
  • Stochastic Thermodynamics: The paper notes that the presence of an external flow field, implied by wGI, necessitates modifications to existing theories of stochastic thermodynamics, suggesting future research directions in this area.
  • Generalization: The authors suggest that wGI can be extended to more complex scenarios, including systems with non-Gaussian statistics and higher dimensions, which would be valuable for a wider range of applications.
  • CTRW Complexity: While the paper provides the correct wGI-compliant CTRW description, the underlying mathematical framework involving fractional calculus and special functions is complex, suggesting further work on simplifying and applying these results.

Summary updated

Abstract

How does the mathematical description of a system change in different reference frames? Galilei first addressed this fundamental question by formulating the famous principle of Galilean invariance. It prescribes that the equations of motion of closed systems remain the same in different inertial frames related by Galilean transformations, thus imposing strong constraints on the dynamical rules. However, real world systems are often described by coarse-grained models integrating complex internal and external interactions indistinguishably as friction and stochastic forces. Since Galilean invariance is then violated, there is seemingly no alternative principle to assess a priori the physical consistency of a given stochastic model in different inertial frames. Here, starting from the Kac-Zwanzig Hamiltonian model generating Brownian motion, we show how Galilean invariance is broken during the coarse-graining procedure when deriving stochastic equations. Our analysis leads to a set of rules characterizing systems in different inertial frames that have to be satisfied by general stochastic models, which we call "weak Galilean invariance." Several well-known stochastic processes are invariant in these terms, except the continuous-time random walk for which we derive the correct invariant description. Our results are particularly relevant for the modeling of biological systems, as they provide a theoretical principle to select physically consistent stochastic models before a validation against experimental data.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cairoli2018weak,
  author = {Andrea Cairoli and Rainer Klages and Adrian Baule},
  title = {{Weak Galilean invariance as a selection principle for coarse-grained diffusive models}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1073/pnas.1717292115},
}

Loading related content...

Figure