Wave chaos in a randomly inhomogeneous waveguide: Spectral analysis of the finite-range evolution operator

Денис В. Макаров, L. E. Kon’kov, M. Yu. Uleysky, Pavel S. PetrovPhysical 2013 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: This study investigates sound propagation in randomly inhomogeneous oceanic waveguides, focusing on the Sea of Japan. By analyzing finite-range ray stability and wave dynamics through the Finite-Range Evolution Operator (FREO), the researchers identify domains of stability in phase space. Statistical analysis of the FREO spectrum, including level-spacing statistics via the Berry-Robnik distribution, reveals that near-axial sound propagation can remain stable over hundreds of kilometers due to the presence of a shearless torus.

Introduction

In the deep ocean, sound speed variations create a natural waveguide known as the underwater sound channel. While this allows sound to travel vast distances, random fluctuations caused by internal waves introduce "ray chaos," where sound paths become unpredictable. This paper explores how the wave nature of sound interacts with these fluctuations, identifying "islands of stability" that persist despite the chaotic environment.

The Underwater Sound Channel

The researchers modeled a 350 km track in the Sea of Japan. In this region, the sound speed profile exhibits a minimum at a depth of approximately 250 meters, forming the axis of the waveguide.

Sound speed profile (a) and the first empirical orthogonal function of the sound speed perturbation (b) in the Sea of Japan.

Unlike many other oceanic regions where axial propagation is highly chaotic, the specific geometry of the Sea of Japan's sound channel creates unique conditions for stability. The background profile and its perturbations, modeled using Empirical Orthogonal Functions (EOFs), provide a physically grounded environment for studying these wave dynamics.

The Finite-Range Evolution Operator (FREO)

To quantify wave evolution, the authors introduced the Finite-Range Evolution Operator (FREO). This operator describes the transformation of a wave field as it propagates along a finite segment of the waveguide. By examining the spectral properties of the FREO, the researchers could distinguish between regular (predictable) and chaotic sound propagation without needing to assume infinite propagation distances.

Spectral Analysis and Level Spacing

A key method for identifying chaos in wave systems is the analysis of eigenvalue spacing. In a perfectly regular system, these spacings follow a Poisson distribution, while a fully chaotic system follows a Wigner-Dyson distribution. The authors utilized the Berry-Robnik distribution to estimate the "regular fraction" ($v_r$) of the wave dynamics, representing the mix between these two states.

The Berry-Robnik distribution $\rho(s)$ for different values of the regular phase space fraction $v_r$.

As shown in the figure above, the shape of the distribution $\rho(s)$ shifts significantly as the system transitions from regular ($v_r \approx 1$) to chaotic ($v_r \approx 0$). This statistical approach allows for a precise estimation of how much of the phase space remains stable over a given distance.

Key Insights: The Shearless Torus and Wave Robustness

The most significant discovery is the existence of a "shearless torus" in the classical phase space of the Sea of Japan. This structure acts as a barrier to chaos, allowing near-axial sound waves to remain stable over distances exceeding 300 km. Furthermore, the study found that lower-frequency waves are more robust against scattering—a phenomenon known as dynamical localization—where the wave's long wavelength effectively "smooths" the random perturbations of the ocean.

Conclusion

By bridging classical ray theory and wave mechanics, this research provides a deeper understanding of how sound behaves in complex underwater environments. The FREO approach and eigenfunction analysis offer powerful tools for predicting sound stability, with potential applications ranging from ocean acoustic tomography to the study of decoherence in quantum systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

The problem of sound propagation in a randomly inhomogeneous oceanic waveguide is considered. An underwater sound channel in the Sea of Japan is taken as an example. Our attention is concentrated on the domains of finite-range ray stability in phase space and their influence on wave dynamics. These domains can be found by means of the one-step Poincare map. To study manifestations of finite-range ray stability, we introduce the finite-range evolution operator (FREO) describing transformation of a wave field in the course of propagation along a finite segment of a waveguide. Carrying out statistical analysis of the FREO spectrum, we estimate the contribution of regular domains and explore their evanescence with increasing length of the segment. We utilize several methods of spectral analysis: analysis of eigenfunctions by expanding them over modes of the unperturbed waveguide, approximation of level-spacing statistics by means of the Berry-Robnik distribution, and the procedure used by A. Relano and coworkers [Relano et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 244102 (2002); Relano, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 224101 (2008)]. Comparing the results obtained with different methods, we find that the method based on the statistical analysis of FREO eigenfunctions is the most favorable for estimating the contribution of regular domains. It allows one to find directly the waveguide modes whose refraction is regular despite the random inhomogeneity. For example, it is found that near-axial sound propagation in the Sea of Japan preserves stability even over distances of hundreds of kilometers due to the presence of a shearless torus in the classical phase space. Increasing the acoustic wavelength degrades scattering, resulting in recovery of eigenfunction localization near periodic orbits of the one-step Poincaré map.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{2013wave,
  author = {Денис В. Макаров and L. E. Kon’kov and M. Yu. Uleysky and Pavel S. Petrov},
  title = {{Wave chaos in a randomly inhomogeneous waveguide: Spectral analysis of the finite-range evolution operator}},
  booktitle = {Physical},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1103/physreve.87.012911},
}
Figure