Water Quality Characteristics and Source Analysis of Pollutants in the Maotiao River Basin (SW China)

Yinjiu Li, Qiuhua Li, Shulin Jiao, Chen Liu, Liuying Yang, Guojia Huang, Si Zhou, Mengshu Han, Anton BranceljWater 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the water quality of the Maotiao River Basin in Southwest China, revealing that agricultural land use is the primary driver of pollution, particularly during dry seasons. By combining a novel fuzzy matter-element-VIKOR model with geodetector analysis, the research provides a comprehensive understanding of water quality dynamics and identifies key factors influencing them, offering crucial insights for targeted environmental management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Rivers are vital ecosystems providing essential services, but they are increasingly threatened by human activities, leading to water pollution. In regions like Southwest China, where water scarcity and intensive development coexist, understanding river water quality and its sources is paramount for effective ecological restoration and management. Traditional methods often struggle to capture the complex interplay of various factors influencing water quality across different spatial and temporal scales. This paper addresses the need for a robust, integrated approach to assess river health and pinpoint pollution sources in a complex, anthropogenically impacted watershed.

Methods

The study employs a two-pronged methodological approach:

  1. Fuzzy Matter-Element-VIKOR Model: This is a sophisticated multi-criteria decision-making (MCDM) technique used for comprehensive water quality evaluation. It combines the strengths of fuzzy set theory (to handle uncertainty), matter-element theory (to represent qualitative and quantitative information), and the VIKOR method (to achieve a compromise solution among conflicting criteria). The authors used an improved analytical hierarchy process (IAHP) and the CRITIC method to determine objective and subjective weights for various water quality indicators, aiming to reduce subjectivity. This model was used to assess the overall water quality status of the river basin.
  2. Geodetector Model: This statistical tool is used to reveal the spatial differentiation of variables and their driving forces. It's particularly useful for identifying the relative importance of different factors (like land use types) and their interactions in explaining spatial patterns. The study utilized factor detectors to assess the influence of individual landscape types and interaction detectors to understand how these factors combine to affect water quality. Pearson correlation analysis was used to determine the direction of influence.

Datasets

The study utilized water quality data collected from 17 sampling locations within the Maotiao River Basin in July, August, and November of 2020. The parameters measured included:

  • Physical Parameters: Dissolved oxygen (DO), electric conductivity (Cond.), oxidation-reduction potential (ORP), water temperature (WT), and pH.
  • Particulate and Dissolved Organic Material: Potassium permanganate index (CODMn) and five-day biological oxygen demand (BOD5).
  • Nutrients: Total nitrogen (TN), total phosphorus (TP), nitrate (NO3⁻), nitrite (NO2⁻), ammonium (NH4⁺-N), and orthophosphate (PO4³⁻).
  • Chlorophyll-a: A proxy for primary productivity.
  • Heavy Metals: Arsenic (As), chromium (Cr), copper (Cu), mercury (Hg), nickel (Ni), and lead (Pb).

Land use data for the Maotiao River Basin was also used, categorized into agricultural, forest, grassland, urban, shrubland, and water bodies.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Seasonal Water Quality Swings: Water quality significantly deteriorates during the dry summer season, especially in reservoirs, but improves during the wet season due to dilution from rainfall. This highlights the critical role of hydrological conditions.
  • Agricultural Dominance: Agricultural land use is identified as the primary driver of water quality degradation across the basin, with its influence being consistently high throughout the sampling periods. This underscores the need for targeted agricultural management practices.
  • Interactions Matter: The combined effect of different land use types (urban, industrial, agricultural, and forested) explains a vast majority of the spatial variation in water quality, emphasizing that a holistic approach is necessary, rather than focusing on single factors.
  • Forests' Complex Role: While forests are often seen as beneficial, the study found a negative relationship between water quality and forested areas within a certain buffer zone. This is attributed to factors like topography, soil characteristics, and the potential for runoff from steep, forested terrain to carry pollutants.
  • Urbanization's Nuanced Impact: Settlements (urban areas) showed a relatively small influence on water quality, likely due to their spatial distribution and the scale of analysis.

Key Results

  • Agricultural Land Influence: The influence of agricultural land use on water quality was substantial, with effect intensity values ranging from 0.60 to 0.80 across the sampling months.
  • Combined Land Use Impact: Interactions among urban, industrial, agricultural, and forested areas explained a remarkable 83.2% to 99.9% of the spatial differentiation in water quality.
  • Water Quality Decline Downstream: Water quality generally decreased from upstream to downstream sections of the river.
  • Heavy Metal Concerns: Chromium (Cr) and Nickel (Ni) were identified as the dominating heavy metal pollutants in the basin.
  • Model Stability: The fuzzy matter-element-VIKOR model demonstrated stability across different decision-making coefficients, correlating highly with other established water quality assessment models.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that river water quality is a dynamic process, and their study, while comprehensive, was conducted over a limited period (three months in 2020). They suggest that long-term series studies would be more effective in fully explaining the sources of pollutants in water bodies. Additionally, while the study identified agricultural land use as a major factor, further research could delve deeper into specific agricultural practices and their precise contributions to pollution. The negative correlation with forested areas also warrants further investigation into the specific mechanisms at play in this karst landscape.

Summary updated

Abstract

Rivers are an important mediator between human activities and the natural environment. They provide multiple functions, including irrigation, transportation, food supply, recreation, and water supply. Therefore, evaluations of water quality and pollution sources are of great significance for ecological restoration and management of rivers. In this study, the improved “vušekriterijumska optimizacija i kompromisno rješenje” (VIKOR in Serbian; in English: Multicriteria Optimization and Compromise Solution), and a geodetector were used to analyze the water quality characteristics and pollution sources of the Maotiao River Basin (Gizhou province, SW China). The results showed that the water quality of the Maotiao River Basin deteriorated significantly during the summer drought period, as was evident in the reservoirs and lakes. It improved in the wet season (i.e., during the summer period) due to runoff dilution. Water quality decreased along the river’s course, from upstream to downstream sections. The results of the geographic detector analysis showed that agricultural areas were the primary factor affecting the spatial distribution of water quality in the river basin. In July, August, and November 2020, the influence of agricultural land was 0.72, 0.60, or 0.80, respectively, and the interactions among urban, industrial, agricultural, and forested areas explained 99.2%, 83.2%, or 99.9% of the spatial differentiation of water quality, respectively. Due to the influence of spatial scale, settlements have a small influence on the spatial distribution of water quality. Their impact factors were 0.38, −0.24, and −0.05, respectively. Notably, the negative relationship of water quality and forested areas reflects that topography, types of landscapes, and soil thickness have considerable influences on the Maotiao River Basin’s water quality. Based on the findings, we infer that good farmland water conservancy projects and comprehensive management of different types of landscapes, such as forests, agriculture, and urban area and water bodies, are of great significance for improving water quality.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2022water,
  author = {Yinjiu Li and Qiuhua Li and Shulin Jiao and Chen Liu and Liuying Yang and Guojia Huang and Si Zhou and Mengshu Han and Anton Brancelj},
  title = {{Water Quality Characteristics and Source Analysis of Pollutants in the Maotiao River Basin (SW China)}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/w14030301},
}
Figure