Watching TikTok Live Streaming: A Data Collection for Public Life Study in Hutong

Jinfei Liu, Mohd Hisyam Rasidi, Yoke Lai Lee, Ismail SaidInternational Journal of Sustainable Development and Planning 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores using TikTok live streaming as a remote, low-cost alternative to traditional fieldwork for urban "public life" studies. By comparing "digital strolling" alongside TikTok anchors with physical ethnographic observation in Beijing’s Hutongs, the researchers found that TikTok provides more comprehensive data on resident behavior while significantly reducing the labor and travel requirements of urban research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional public life studies—which investigate how people interact with their built environment—rely heavily on manual "boots on the ground" methods like counting, mapping, and physical observation. These methods are labor-intensive, geographically limited, and were rendered nearly impossible by COVID-19 lockdown policies.

Furthermore, traditional fieldwork often suffers from a "site-boundary" bias: researchers tend to stay within a specific study area (like a single alleyway), potentially missing where residents go next. The authors specifically look at Beijing’s Hutongs (traditional narrow alleys), where previous studies struggled to categorize unique local behaviors like "walking with birds" or "basking in the sun" within standard Western urban design frameworks.

Methods

The researchers conducted a comparative study using two distinct data collection phases:

  1. Traditional Fieldwork (2021): An ethnographic survey in the Nanluogu Xiang area of Beijing. The researcher strolled through the Hutongs across four phases (January, March, May, and July), recording observations via 148 photos and handwritten notes.
  2. TikTok Digital Ethnography (2022): The researcher selected four TikTok "anchors" (content creators) who live in or frequently tour the Hutongs. Over approximately 60 hours of viewing, the researcher collected 510 screenshots of resident activities.

Crucially, the researcher didn't just watch; they used TikTok’s social functions to interact with anchors in real-time, asking questions to clarify whether the people on screen were local residents or tourists. Both datasets were then processed using thematic analysis via NVivo software to categorize behaviors into individual activities, group entertainment, and cultural activities.

Datasets

While the paper does not use a massive pre-existing database, it generates two primary qualitative datasets for comparison:

  • Fieldwork Dataset: 148 photos and associated field notes from physical observations.
  • TikTok Dataset: 510 screenshots captured from live streams hosted by four specific anchors (G, Y, A, and Z), ranging from professional tour guides to 30-year Hutong residents.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Almost Being There" Effect: Live streaming allows researchers to adopt the perspective of a "participant observer" remotely. Because anchors often walk with their cameras at eye level, the researcher experiences the spatial flow of the neighborhood naturally.
  • Anchors as Proxy Observers: Local anchors act as expert intermediaries. They are familiar with the "rules" of the neighborhood and can provide context that a visiting researcher might miss.
  • Breaking the Boundary: Traditional fieldwork is often static. However, TikTok anchors frequently follow residents as they move from the narrow Hutongs into nearby parks and squares. This revealed that Hutong life isn't disappearing; it's simply shifting to larger public spaces with better exercise equipment—a detail missed by previous site-specific studies.
  • Efficiency Gains: The "data collection time" effectively equals "viewing time." Researchers save the hours typically spent commuting to sites and wandering aimlessly, as anchors are incentivized to find and film interesting activity to keep their audience engaged.

Key Results

  • Comprehensiveness: The TikTok method yielded 510 data points compared to the 148 from fieldwork. It captured a wider variety of spontaneous activities, such as singing, shuttlecock playing, and stretching in peripheral parks.
  • Solving the "Missing Children" Mystery: Previous studies suggested children were no longer playing in Hutongs. TikTok footage revealed that parents simply prefer taking children to nearby squares for safety and space, rather than the narrow, tourist-heavy alleys.
  • Reliability: The behaviors observed on TikTok largely mirrored those found in the field (sitting, strolling, chatting), proving the platform is a reliable mirror of reality for urban researchers.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several key limitations:

  • The "Cultural Gap": TikTok streams rarely captured organized community cultural events (like art classes or neighborhood meetings), as these often happen indoors or in private community rooms.
  • Anchor Bias: The data is limited by where the anchor chooses to walk and when they choose to broadcast. If an anchor avoids a certain alley, that area remains a "dark spot" for the researcher.
  • Observation vs. Interview: While observation is successful, the authors suggest future work should test the reliability of conducting formal research interviews via TikTok’s chatting and fan group functions.

Ultimately, the paper suggests that while TikTok cannot yet replace documentation (like reviewing official community schedules), it could eventually replace physical fieldwork for behavioral observation in urban studies.

Summary updated

Abstract

The block policy caused by COVID-19 has made public life researchers cannot conduct their studies. However, in recent years, fewer public life studies have proposed new tools to reduce human job involved in data collection process. Hence, this article has proposed a new way to collect public life studies data: watching TikTok live streaming. This research aims to test the reliability of this new data collection method by comparing the contents of Hutong residents' public lives from field research and TikTok live streaming. The researcher conducted an ethnographic investigation in Hutong. In the field research process, the researcher used observation to collect data and recorded it by taking photos and taking notes. While watching TikTok, the researcher selected four anchors who often conduct live streaming in Hutongs to watch and recorded the data by taking screenshots. Data from two different collection methods was analyzed by thematic analysis separately. Results show that the data obtained by watching TikTok live streaming is more comprehensive than that obtained by field research; besides, using TikTok to collect data can sufficiently reduce the input of human jobs. The researcher thought the social function of TikTok may provide more help for data collection. Hence this study advised future research to test the reliability of conducting interviews using TikTok.
BibTeX
@article{liu2022watching,
  author = {Jinfei Liu and Mohd Hisyam Rasidi and Yoke Lai Lee and Ismail Said},
  title = {{Watching TikTok Live Streaming: A Data Collection for Public Life Study in Hutong}},
  journal = {International Journal of Sustainable Development and Planning},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.18280/ijsdp.170611},
}
Figure