Waste Cooking Oil Recycling and the Potential Use of Blockchain Technology in the UK

Yu Gong, Heng‐Yi Zhang, Tom Morris, Chen Zhang, Mohammed AlharithiSustainability 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the current landscape of waste cooking oil (WCO) recycling in the UK, identifying seven distinct recycling models. It then investigates the potential of blockchain technology (BCT) to improve transparency and efficiency in this sector, highlighting significant challenges and offering recommendations for its adoption.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing global population and urbanization have led to a surge in waste, particularly waste cooking oil (WCO). Improper disposal of WCO poses environmental hazards, including water pollution and sewer blockages, leading to substantial costs for infrastructure maintenance. While WCO has significant potential as a feedstock for biodiesel production, contributing to sustainable energy goals, its recycling in the UK faces challenges. These include a lack of clear regulations, inefficient collection, and issues with transparency and accountability in the supply chain. The paper aims to bridge this gap by understanding the UK's WCO recycling ecosystem and exploring how blockchain technology, as demonstrated by a project in Southern Europe, could enhance its efficiency and sustainability.

Methods

The study employed a multi-method qualitative approach. This involved:

  • Unstructured and Semi-structured Interviews: Conducted with representatives from "Z company" (involved in a BCT project in Southern Europe) and various restaurants in the UK. This provided in-depth insights into current practices, challenges, and potential solutions.
  • Thematic Analysis: Applied to both primary interview data and secondary archival data (company websites, public databases, government reports) to identify recurring themes and patterns.
  • Technology, Organization, and Environment (TOE) Framework: Used to analyze the challenges and opportunities for BCT adoption in the UK's WCO recycling sector.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The research primarily relies on primary data from interviews and secondary data from publicly available sources.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Diverse UK Recycling Models: The UK's WCO recycling landscape is more complex than previously understood, with seven distinct models identified, ranging from "Supplier and Collector" to "Closed-Loop Collector" types. This diversity reflects varying operational strategies and market dynamics.
  • TPT Dominance: The Third-Party Take-back (TPT) model appears to be more prevalent than the Biodiesel Enterprise Take-back (BET) model in the UK, suggesting a preference for external collection and processing.
  • Lack of Direct Government Incentives: Unlike some other regions, the UK's WCO recycling market is largely driven by competitive dynamics rather than direct government subsidies or clear legislative mandates, creating a unique competitive landscape.
  • Restaurant Drivers: Convenience and a small monetary reward are the primary motivators for restaurants to participate in WCO recycling, with many having limited knowledge of the broader implications or uses of the collected oil.
  • BCT's Potential for Transparency: Blockchain technology holds significant promise for enhancing transparency and traceability in the WCO supply chain, addressing issues like oil theft and inaccurate measurements.
  • Significant Barriers to BCT Adoption: The primary obstacles to BCT adoption in the UK WCO sector are technological complexity and cost, a lack of knowledge and stakeholder recognition, and insufficient legal and regulatory support.
  • Southern Europe Project as a Model: A project by "Z company" in Southern Europe demonstrates how BCT, combined with IoT, can create a unified, transparent, and traceable WCO recycling system, offering valuable lessons for the UK.

Key Results

  • Seven WCO Recycling Models Identified: The study successfully categorized and described seven distinct WCO recycling chain models operating in the UK.
  • Restaurant Satisfaction with Current Process: Interviewed restaurants expressed satisfaction with the current WCO recycling process due to its convenience and the minimal effort required.
  • Limited Knowledge of BCT: A significant finding is the widespread lack of knowledge and understanding of BCT among restaurant stakeholders, leading to skepticism and reluctance to adopt it.
  • Environmental Challenges: The UK faces a lack of explicit legislative support and insufficient governmental regulation for WCO recycling, which hinders its advancement and the adoption of technologies like BCT.
  • Practical Insights from Z Company Project: The Southern Europe project highlighted key insights for BCT adoption, including the importance of identifying stakeholders, leveraging sustainability incentives, and the role of legal and peer pressure.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Geographic Scope: The study's focus on Southampton restaurants may limit the generalizability of findings to the entire UK.
  • Stakeholder Participation: Several key stakeholders declined to participate, potentially impacting the comprehensiveness of the data.
  • Industry Breadth: The focus on restaurants as the primary WCO source might not fully represent the broader industry.
  • Limited Knowledge of Related Fields: The study's comprehensiveness could be affected by the limited knowledge of WCO recycling and related fields.

Future Work Suggestions:

  • Expand interview scope to include participants from various regions and different types of WCO producers.
  • Consult with industry experts and legal professionals to gain deeper insights into BCT application and legal intricacies.
  • Conduct a more comprehensive examination of the identified recycling models to understand their execution conditions and opportunities for BCT integration.
  • Schedule relevant experiments to assess the profitability and feasibility of BCT implementation in WCO recycling projects.
  • Customize BCT frameworks to fit the specific needs of each identified WCO recycling model in the UK.

Summary updated

Abstract

This study explores the recycling of Waste Cooking Oil (WCO) in the UK, analysing the recycling models and practices, and investigating the application of blockchain technology (BCT) from Z company’s Southern European project to UK’s WCO recycling. Employing a multi-method qualitative approach, including unstructured and semi-structured interviews, the research delves into the experiences of current WCO recycling methods in the UK and Z company’s project. Through thematic analysis of both primary data and archival data, the study identifies seven distinct recycling models in the UK and assesses the implementation of BCT using the Technology, Organization, and Environment (TOE) framework. The research underscores the current state of WCO recycling in the UK, highlighting the industry’s challenges and providing recommendations for future implementation. Its significance lies in addressing the academic gap in WCO recycling studies and offering insights into recycling models and BCT application, potentially guiding future commercial endeavours.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gong2024waste,
  author = {Yu Gong and Heng‐Yi Zhang and Tom Morris and Chen Zhang and Mohammed Alharithi},
  title = {{Waste Cooking Oil Recycling and the Potential Use of Blockchain Technology in the UK}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/su16146197},
}
Figure