Walking in Tandem with the City: Exploring the Influence of Public Art on Encouraging Urban Pedestrianism within the 15-Minute Community Living Circle in Shanghai

Ran Tan, Yu Wu, Suhui ZhangSustainability 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates how public art influences people's willingness to walk in Shanghai's "15-minute community living circles" (CLCs). Using the Stimulus-Organism-Response (SOR) model, the research found that public art positively impacts urban pedestrianism by enhancing perceived benefits like environmental improvement, cultural enrichment, and better services, ultimately encouraging more walking.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As urbanization accelerates, cities face challenges related to transportation, sustainability, and environmental impact. The traditional "car-centric" approach is increasingly seen as unsustainable. In response, the "15-minute city" concept, or Community Living Circle (CLC), has emerged. This model aims to provide residents with access to daily necessities (food, health, education, leisure) within a 15-minute walk or bike ride from their homes, thereby reducing car dependency, emissions, and promoting well-being. While CLCs are being implemented, their effectiveness in encouraging pedestrianism needs further exploration. Specifically, this paper addresses the question of whether public art, often integrated into CLCs to enhance urban spaces, can actively promote walking behavior. The authors aim to bridge a gap in existing research by quantitatively examining the micro-level impact of public art on individual pedestrian choices within the CLC framework.

Methods

The study employs a quantitative approach based on the Stimulus-Organism-Response (SOR) theory. This theory posits that external stimuli (public art) influence an organism's internal psychological processes (perceived benefits), which in turn lead to behavioral responses (walking intention).

The core methodological steps include:

  • Theoretical Framework Development: Building upon the SOR model, the authors developed a framework that links public art (stimulus) to citizen-perceived benefits (organism) and ultimately to willingness to walk (response). Public art was broken down into four dimensions: environmental improvement, cultural shaping, service enhancement, and public interaction. Citizen-perceived benefits were categorized into functional, experiential, and social values.
  • Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA): This statistical technique was used to test the proposed theoretical structure and verify the relationships between the latent variables (constructs) and their observed indicators (survey questions).
  • Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): CFA is a component of SEM, which was used to analyze the complex relationships within the proposed model, including direct and indirect effects.
  • Survey Data Analysis: A five-point Likert scale questionnaire was administered to residents in the study area. Statistical analyses, including descriptive statistics, reliability analysis (Cronbach's alpha), validity analysis (KMO), and correlation analysis, were performed using SPSS and AMOS software.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from an on-site questionnaire survey conducted in the North Suzhou River Community in Shanghai's Jing'an District.

  • Sample Size: 346 questionnaires were distributed, and 315 were deemed valid. This sample size was confirmed to be sufficient for the structural equation model analysis.
  • Data Source: The data were collected from residents within the specific 15-minute CLC area.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Public Art as a Catalyst for Pedestrianism: The study strongly suggests that public art is not merely decorative but a functional element that can actively encourage urban walking.
  • Mediating Role of Perceived Benefits: The positive impact of public art on walking is significantly mediated by how residents perceive the benefits of their environment. Improvements in environmental aesthetics, cultural experiences, and functional services directly influence their willingness to walk.
  • Holistic Approach to Urban Planning: The findings highlight the importance of integrating public art into urban planning strategies for CLCs, moving beyond a purely functional approach to one that considers aesthetic, cultural, and social dimensions.
  • SOR Theory's Applicability: The study successfully demonstrates the utility of the SOR model in understanding the complex interplay between environmental stimuli (public art), individual perceptions, and behavioral outcomes (walking).

Key Results

  • Strong Positive Influence of Public Art: The study found a highly significant positive effect of public art on citizen-perceived benefits (standardized regression coefficient of 1).
  • Significant Impact on Walking Intention: Citizen-perceived benefits, in turn, had a strong positive impact on walking intention (standardized regression coefficient of 0.84).
  • Dimensions of Public Art: Environmental improvement, cultural shaping, service enhancement, and public interaction all showed significant positive influences on citizen-perceived benefits.
  • Model Fit: The structural equation model demonstrated excellent fit with the data, indicating that the proposed relationships are well-supported by the empirical evidence.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The study acknowledges that the current practice of CLCs in Shanghai is still in its early stages, with potential issues like unsystematic management, uneven distribution of public art, low citizen awareness, and weak participation.
  • While the study focuses on a specific area, the generalizability of findings to other contexts might require further investigation.
  • Future Work:
    • Deeper Mechanistic Understanding: Future research should explore how public art influences walking choices, considering factors like design features, placement, and artistic forms.
  • Contextual Differences: Investigating the differential impact of public art across various community environments (considering geography, population structure, cultural atmosphere) is crucial for tailored strategies.
  • Interdisciplinary Collaboration: Encouraging collaboration between art, urban planning, and sociology experts is recommended to advance the integration of public art and sustainable urban development.
  • Policy and Participation: Strengthening policy incentives for public art development and encouraging community participation in its selection, planning, and management are suggested to enhance its attractiveness and impact.

Summary updated

Abstract

As a new urban model, the 15-min city has gradually become a touchstone with which to measure the future sustainability of cities. With a time-limited planning of urban living circles, urban residents can be allowed to access basic daily needs, such as food, health and education, while walking or cycling, thus reducing motor traffic and carbon dioxide emissions and contributing to the improvement of people’s well-being and the environmental climate. Within the temporal and spatial confines of the 15-min living sphere, governmental authorities and community bodies commonly integrate public art installations into public spaces to enrich spatial dynamics, cultivate cultural identities, enhance environmental aesthetics, elevate service quality, and foster communal interactions. This study aims to probe into the impact of public art on encouraging urban pedestrianism within the specific context of the 15-min community living sphere along the Suzhou River in northern Shanghai. Drawing upon Stimulus–Organism–Response (SOR) theory, a theoretical framework is constructed to unravel the mechanisms by which public art influences residents’ propensity for walking, encompassing the attributes of public art, perceived value, and walking intention. Employing Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA), the model is analyzed to scrutinize the proposed hypotheses. Through this research, we establish and substantiate a novel and pertinent theoretical perspective for advancing human-centric and sustainable urban regeneration. The findings underscore that integrating public art within the framework of constructing 15-min community living spheres contributes to catalyzing proactive urban pedestrianism by enhancing its value proposition.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{tan2024walking,
  author = {Ran Tan and Yu Wu and Suhui Zhang},
  title = {{Walking in Tandem with the City: Exploring the Influence of Public Art on Encouraging Urban Pedestrianism within the 15-Minute Community Living Circle in Shanghai}},
  booktitle = {Sustainability},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/su16093839},
}
Figure