Wafer-Scale Synthesis of WS 2 Films with In Situ Controllable p-Type Doping by Atomic Layer Deposition

Hanjie Yang, Yang Wang, Xingli Zou, Rongxu Bai, Zecheng Wu, Sheng Han, Tao Chen, Shen Hu, Hao Zhu, Lin Chen, David W. Zhang, Jack C. Lee, Xionggang Lu, Peng Zhou, Qingqing Sun, Edward T. Yu, Deji Akinwande, Ji LiResearch 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a breakthrough in fabricating wafer-scale p-type tungsten disulfide (WS₂) films using atomic layer deposition (ALD) with in-situ niobium (Nb) doping. This controllable doping method is crucial for realizing complementary logic circuits (CMOS) with 2D materials, paving the way for next-generation electronics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The commercialization of 2D transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) like WS₂ in electronics hinges on two major challenges: achieving large-scale, uniform film deposition and enabling controllable p-type doping. While methods like chemical vapor deposition (CVD) can produce high-quality films, they struggle with wafer-scale uniformity. Existing p-type doping techniques for TMDs often rely on surface functionalization or post-deposition treatments, which can be difficult to control precisely and may not be compatible with standard semiconductor manufacturing processes. Furthermore, the thin nature of TMDs makes traditional ion implantation doping impractical. This paper tackles these issues by developing an in-situ, controllable p-type doping method for WS₂ using ALD, a technique well-suited for wafer-scale manufacturing.

Methods

The core of this work lies in the development of an Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD) process for both intrinsic n-type WS₂ and in-situ Nb-doped p-type WS₂ films.

  • ALD for WS₂: The researchers utilized tungsten hexachloride (WCl₆) and hydrogen dimethyl disulfide (HMDST) as precursors for WS₂ growth. This process was optimized for wafer-scale deposition on various substrates, including 8-inch α-Al₂O₃/Si wafers, 2-inch sapphire, and GaN.
  • In-Situ Nb Doping: To achieve p-type doping, niobium pentachloride (NbCl₅) was introduced during the ALD process, alternating with the WS₂ deposition cycles. The concentration of Nb dopants was precisely controlled by adjusting the number of NbCl₅ cycles.
  • Post-Annealing: A crucial step involved annealing the as-deposited films in a sulfur atmosphere at 950°C. This post-treatment was found to be essential for activating the Nb dopants, improving film crystallinity, and achieving effective substitutional doping.
  • Device Fabrication: Standard CMOS-compatible processes were employed to fabricate top-gate transistors (n-FETs and p-FETs) using the synthesized WS₂ and Nb-doped WS₂ films. This included lithography, etching, and metal deposition for source/drain and gate electrodes, with ALD-grown Al₂O₃ serving as the high-k dielectric.
  • Characterization Techniques: A suite of advanced techniques was used to verify the material properties and device performance:
  • X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS): To confirm the chemical states of W, S, and Nb, and to verify the substitutional doping of Nb into the WS₂ lattice.
  • Raman Spectroscopy: To assess the film crystallinity and identify characteristic vibrational modes of WS₂.
  • Hall Effect Measurements: To determine the carrier type (electrons for n-type, holes for p-type), carrier concentration, and mobility of the films.
  • Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM): To analyze the film's layered structure, thickness, and grain size.
  • Energy-Dispersive X-ray Spectroscopy (EDX): For elemental mapping to confirm the presence and distribution of Nb.
  • Time-of-Flight Secondary Ion Mass Spectrometry (TOF-SIMS): To quantify the relative concentration of Nb dopants.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focuses on material synthesis and device characterization rather than training machine learning models on large datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ALD as a Scalable Doping Platform: The paper demonstrates that ALD, known for its precise thickness control and scalability, can be effectively adapted for in-situ, controllable p-type doping of 2D materials, a significant step towards industrial adoption.
  • Nb as an Effective Substitutional Dopant: Niobium (Nb) was successfully incorporated into the WS₂ lattice through ALD and post-annealing, acting as an effective substitutional dopant to create p-type carriers. This is a more robust doping mechanism than surface adsorption.
  • Controllable Doping via Cycle Number: The Nb doping concentration and the resulting p-type behavior were directly tunable by simply varying the number of NbCl₅ precursor cycles during ALD. This offers a straightforward method for precise doping control.
  • Activation via Post-Annealing: The necessity of high-temperature sulfur annealing to activate the Nb dopants and achieve effective substitutional doping was clearly established.
  • Wafer-Scale Uniformity Achieved: The successful deposition of uniform WS₂ films on large-area substrates (8-inch wafers) highlights the scalability of the developed ALD process.
  • Demonstration of Complementary Devices: The fabrication of both n-type WS₂ FETs and Nb-doped p-type WS₂ FETs, along with the demonstration of a WS₂/Nb-doped WS₂ p-n junction, proves the feasibility of creating complementary logic circuits using this material system.

Key Results

  • Wafer-Scale WS₂ Synthesis: Achieved uniform WS₂ films on 8-inch α-Al₂O₃/Si wafers, 2-inch sapphire, and GaN substrates.
  • High-Performance n-FETs: WS₂ n-FETs exhibited an on/off ratio as high as 10⁵ and an electron mobility of up to 6.85 cm²/V·s.
  • Effective p-FETs: Nb-doped WS₂ p-FETs with 15-cycle Nb doping showed an on/off ratio of 10⁴ and a hole mobility of 0.016 cm²/V·s.
  • Controllable Doping: Hall effect measurements confirmed the transition from n-type (undoped WS₂) to p-type (Nb-doped WS₂). TOF-SIMS data showed a clear correlation between Nb doping cycles and increased Nb secondary ion intensity.
  • p-n Junction Performance: A WS₂/Nb-doped WS₂ p-n structure demonstrated a rectifying ratio of over 10⁴, indicating successful heterojunction formation.
  • Film Quality: TEM analysis revealed continuous planar WS₂ films with an average grain size of 55 nm.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Mobility Gap: The hole mobility in the fabricated p-FETs (0.016 cm²/V·s) is significantly lower than the electron mobility in n-FETs (6.85 cm²/V·s). This disparity is attributed to factors like contact resistance and the inherent properties of Nb-doped WS₂.
  • Doping Concentration Quantification: While the controllability of Nb doping was demonstrated, the paper notes that obtaining an accurate quantitative value for Nb concentration was challenging due to limitations in detection accuracy and atom collection efficiency.
  • High-k Dielectric Challenges: The authors acknowledge that depositing high-quality high-k dielectrics on WS₂ can be difficult due to the lack of dangling bonds on the surface, which can affect device reliability.
  • Future Work: The paper explicitly states that the realization of controllable in-situ Nb-doped WS₂ films paves the way for fabricating wafer-scale complementary WS₂ FETs. Future research will likely focus on optimizing p-FET performance, improving the high-k/TMD interface for better reliability, and integrating these n- and p-type devices into functional logic circuits. Further exploration into other dopants and ALD parameters could also be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Wafer-scale synthesis of p-type TMD films is critical for its commercialization in next-generation electro/optoelectronics. In this work, wafer-scale intrinsic n-type WS<sub>2</sub> films and in situ Nb-doped p-type WS<sub>2</sub> films were synthesized through atomic layer deposition (ALD) on 8-inch <i>α</i>-Al<sub>2</sub>O<sub>3</sub>/Si wafers, 2-inch sapphire, and 1 cm<sup>2</sup> GaN substrate pieces. The Nb doping concentration was precisely controlled by altering cycle number of Nb precursor and activated by postannealing. WS<sub>2</sub> n-FETs and Nb-doped p-FETs with different Nb concentrations have been fabricated using CMOS-compatible processes. X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, Raman spectroscopy, and Hall measurements confirmed the effective substitutional doping with Nb. The on/off ratio and electron mobility of WS<sub>2</sub> n-FET are as high as 10<sup>5</sup> and 6.85 cm<sup>2</sup> V<sup>-1</sup> s<sup>-1</sup>, respectively. In WS<sub>2</sub> p-FET with 15-cycle Nb doping, the on/off ratio and hole mobility are 10 and 0.016 cm<sup>2</sup> V<sup>-1</sup> s<sup>-1</sup>, respectively. The p-n structure based on n- and p- type WS<sub>2</sub> films was proved with a 10<sup>4</sup> rectifying ratio. The realization of controllable <i>in situ</i> Nb-doped WS<sub>2</sub> films paved a way for fabricating wafer-scale complementary WS<sub>2</sub> FETs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2021wafer,
  author = {Hanjie Yang and Yang Wang and Xingli Zou and Rongxu Bai and Zecheng Wu and Sheng Han and Tao Chen and Shen Hu and Hao Zhu and Lin Chen and David W. Zhang and Jack C. Lee and Xionggang Lu and Peng Zhou and Qingqing Sun and Edward T. Yu and Deji Akinwande and Ji Li},
  title = {{Wafer-Scale Synthesis of WS <sub>2</sub> Films with In Situ Controllable p-Type Doping by Atomic Layer Deposition}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.34133/2021/9862483},
}
Figure