Vulnerability of Global Afforestation Projects to a Polyphagous Invasive Fall Webworm

Lilin Zhao, Jing Ning, Jingjing Du, Deliang Lu, Jiquan Chen, Hui Wang, Dejun Hao, Jianting Fan, Lei Guo, Wei SongResearch Square 2025 · DOI

Global efforts to restore forests and sequester carbon are currently facing an unforeseen challenge. While afforestation—the planting of trees on land not recently forested—is a cornerstone of climate strategy, a recent study published in Research Square reveals a critical "double-edged sword." These massive ecological projects have unintentionally facilitated the rapid global spread of the fall webworm (Hyphantria cunea), one of the world’s most destructive invasive insects.

The Rise of the Fall Webworm

The fall webworm is a highly adaptable defoliator known for building massive web-like nests and stripping trees of their foliage. Since 1940, this polyphagous pest has spread from its native North America to 40 countries across Europe and Asia. Researchers found that this expansion follows a classic S-curve pattern, with the number of invaded countries expected to reach saturation by 2050.

Figure 1: Global invasion dynamics of the fall webworm, showing its spread since 1940, the correlation with afforestation rates, and the dramatic expansion of its host plant range.

The Afforestation-Invasion Nexus

The study identifies a direct quantitative link between human-driven landscape changes and the proliferation of this pest. For every 1% increase in the proportion of planted forests, the area affected by the fall webworm increases by an average of 0.49%. This suggests that the "afforestation boom" of the last 80 years has provided the perfect habitat and corridors for invasive outbreaks.

China currently stands at the epicenter of this crisis. Due to its massive scale of artificial forestation, it faces the highest Comprehensive Threat Index (CTI)—a metric developed by the researchers to rank risk based on host tree proportion, spatial correlation, and project area.

Host Expansion and Adaptation

One of the most alarming findings is the pest's ability to adapt to new environments. In its native North America, the fall webworm has roughly 121 host species. However, in invaded regions like China, that number has exploded to 400. The pest is not just spreading; it is expanding its diet, shifting from its traditional preference for hardwoods to include coniferous trees.

Notably, two-thirds of the 606 total host plants identified globally are tree species commonly utilized for afforestation. Major global ecological initiatives, including the Bonn Challenge and the Great Green Wall, heavily utilize the webworm’s preferred genera, such as Acer (maple), Populus (poplar), and Quercus (oak).

Future Vulnerability and Climate Synergy

The threat is projected to intensify as the climate changes. The "black-headed" variant of the larvae is adapting to higher latitudes and drier winters, allowing the species to move further north into previously "safe" zones in Europe and Asia.

Currently, 45.7% of global plantation forests are located in suitable habitats for the webworm. Under projected climate change scenarios (SSP5-8.5), this vulnerability is expected to rise to 65.8% by 2070. In some specific initiatives, such as the Prairie States Forestry Project in the U.S. or Japan’s Mountain Renovating Plan, 100% of the primary tree species used are known hosts for the pest.

Moving Toward Sustainable Restoration

The findings underscore the need for a radical shift in how we approach ecological restoration. Relying on a narrow selection of fast-growing, susceptible species creates a "biological disaster" waiting to happen. To achieve sustainable ecological goals, future projects must prioritize strategic tree species selection and functional diversity.

While "ecological regulation"—such as reducing pesticide use to promote natural predators—is a potential solution, the study highlights that the primary defense must be the creation of resilient, mixed-species plantations that can act as a biological shield against polyphagous pests.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Global plantations, crucial for restoring degraded landscapes, face rising invasive pest threats, in recent decades. This study highlights that the invasion and proliferation of the fall webworm have been facilitated by the global afforestation boom in the last 80 years and could pose a threat to all global ecological projects until 2050. Since 1940, this polyphagous pest has spread to 40 countries, following an <italic>S-</italic>curve pattern. The distribution of the fall webworm is positively correlated with the expansion rates of afforestation and host tree plantation areas. China is now the most affected country by the fall webworm, with the highest comprehensive threat index (CTI). The number of host species has risen from 121 in the U.S. to 400 in China, and the host range has expanded from hardwoods to include coniferous trees. Notably, two-thirds of the total 600 host plants are tree species utilized for afforestation purposes. The preferred host species, <italic>Acer</italic>, <italic>Quercus</italic>, and <italic>Populus</italic>, are predominant in eight major global ecological projects. Additionally, hydroclimate extremes are projected to increase threats to 65.8% of afforestation zones by 2070, highlighting the need for strategic tree species selection to achieve sustainable ecological goals of global ecological projects, and protect against pests.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2025vulnerability,
  author = {Lilin Zhao and Jing Ning and Jingjing Du and Deliang Lu and Jiquan Chen and Hui Wang and Dejun Hao and Jianting Fan and Lei Guo and Wei Song},
  title = {{Vulnerability of Global Afforestation Projects to a Polyphagous Invasive Fall Webworm}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-5939468/v1},
}
Figure