VP40.10: Systematic review of methodology used in second and third trimester pregnancy dating using ultrasound and symphysio‐fundal height measurements
Lists
Only you see this
Abstract
Accurate assessment of gestational age (GA) is important at both an individual level (to manage pregnancy) and at a population level (to monitor preterm birth rates). Globally, many women don't have access to antenatal ultrasound and some women in high-income settings book late in pregnancy. This review assesses the methodology of studies reporting equations for estimating GA in the 2nd and 3rd trimesters. A search of 4 electronic databases was undertaken to identify studies which included a formula using clinical symphysio-fundal height (SFH)) or ultrasound measures (biometry) to estimate GA after 20 weeks in singleton pregnancies. The methodology of all included studies was reviewed by 2 reviewers and a statistician across 28 criteria in three domains: study design, statistical methods and reporting methods. Each study was awarded an overall quality score according to predefined criteria. A score based on the risk of bias was calculated, expressed as a percentage, with higher scores indicating higher quality (lower risk of bias). The search yielded 3,633 results; 364 papers had a full text review and 78 full text articles were included in the analysis. In total there were 25 different ultrasound parameters proposed to estimate GA, alone or in combination. Overall, mean quality score was 33% with a wide variation (range 11%-93%). Eight papers scored low risk in 17 or more criteria, and these had GA formulae estimated from one, or a combination, of the parameters: BPD, HC, TCD, AC, FL and SFH. The highest risk of bias was identified in the following categories: inclusion and exclusion criteria; neonatal outcomes, truncation of data and presence of systematic quality control measures. A large number of suggested biometric ultrasound variables have been examined in the literature. There is considerable methodological heterogeneity between studies reporting equations for GA estimation. There is also a wide range of parameters used to estimate GA.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{self2020vp,
author = {Alice Self and Lama Daher and Michael Maia Schlüssel and C. Ioannou and Aris T. Papageorghiou},
title = {{VP40.10: Systematic review of methodology used in second and third trimester pregnancy dating using ultrasound and symphysio‐fundal height measurements}},
booktitle = {Ultrasound},
year = {2020},
doi = {10.1002/uog.22948},
}Loading related content...