Abstract
The extracranial carotid artery aneurysm (ECAA) is a rare pathology for which clinical treatment guidelines are lacking. In general, symptoms or growth of the aneurysm sac are thought to indicate intervention. ECAAs may present in a large variety of shapes and sizes, and conventional diameter measurements fail to indicate geometrical differences. Therefore, we propose a protocol to measure ECAA size by 3D volumetric assessment. The volumes of 40 ECAAs in computed tomography angiography (CTA) images were measured through manual segmentation, by two independent operators. Volumes of the entire internal carotid artery (ICA) and the ECAA were measured separately. Excellent inter- and intraoperator reliability was found for both ICA and ECAA volumes, with all intraclass correlation coefficients above 0.94. Bland-Altman analysis revealed normal differences for both inter- and intraoperator agreement. For all volumes, similarity of the segmentations was excellent. Outliers were explained by presence of intraluminal ECAA thrombus, which hampered identification of the aneurysm outer wall. These results implicate robustness of our protocol, which is designed as a step-up towards (semi)automatic volumetric measurements to monitor patients with ECAA. Future (semi)automatic volumetric assessments are recommended and such techniques can be developed and validated using the proposed protocol and manual reference segmentations.
Introduction
Extracranial carotid artery aneurysms (ECAA) are a rare vascular pathology characterized by localized dilation of the carotid artery. Due to their rarity, establishing evidence-based treatment guidelines has been challenging. Currently, clinical decisions regarding intervention—such as surgery or endovascular repair—primarily rely on symptoms or the maximum diameter of the aneurysm sac.
However, 2D diameter measurements provide only a limited "snapshot" of these complex 3D structures. ECAAs can present in various shapes, such as saccular or fusiform, and may grow asymmetrically, making diameter an insufficient metric for capturing total geometrical changes. To address these limitations, this study proposes a standardized protocol for 3D volumetric assessment of ECAAs using Computed Tomography Angiography (CTA).
Methods
The researchers developed a protocol for manual 3D segmentation of CTA images. Two primary volumes were measured: the entire internal carotid artery (ICA) from the bifurcation to the skull base, and the ECAA sac itself.
Segmentation Protocol
Using in-house software (MeVisLab), two independent operators performed manual segmentations. They traced vessel borders (outer wall to outer wall) on axial slices, utilizing sagittal and coronal reconstructions for structural guidance. A key challenge in volumetric analysis is defining the transition from a healthy vessel to an aneurysm. The study established a pragmatic threshold for fusiform aneurysms: segmentation begins where the vessel diameter increases by ≥150% (or ≥125% for more gradual widening).
Reliability Assessment
The protocol's robustness was evaluated through inter-operator and intra-operator reliability tests. Metrics included the Intraclass Correlation Coefficient (ICC) for volume consistency, the Dice Similarity Coefficient (DSC) for spatial overlap, and the modified Hausdorff Distance (HD) for contour proximity.
Datasets
Data were sourced from the Carotid Aneurysm Registry at the University Medical Center Utrecht. The study included 40 CTA scans from 20 patients, with each patient having two scans at different time points between 2008 and 2017.
Results
The volumetric protocol demonstrated excellent reliability and reproducibility:
- Consistency: ICC values were above 0.94 for all volume measurements, indicating high agreement between operators.
- Spatial Overlap: The DSC was generally above 0.88, showing strong spatial agreement in the segmented regions.
- Precision: The median modified HD was less than 1.3 mm.
- Clinical Thresholds: The estimated measurement error was approximately 1–2 mL. This finding suggests that a measured volume increase exceeding 2 mL can be reliably interpreted as true aneurysm growth rather than observer variability.
A significant finding was that the presence of intraluminal thrombus (blood clots) was the primary source of error. Thrombus can obscure the outer vessel wall, making it difficult for operators to consistently define the aneurysm's boundaries.
Discussion and Conclusion
While manual segmentation is highly reliable, it is time-consuming, averaging 49 minutes per scan. This makes it impractical for routine clinical use. However, this manual protocol serves as a vital "gold standard" for the development and validation of future (semi)automatic AI-driven segmentation tools.
Future work should focus on automating these measurements to reduce the clinical burden. Additionally, improving visualization techniques for aneurysms with thrombus and standardizing head positioning during scans will further enhance measurement accuracy. Ultimately, correlating volumetric changes with clinical outcomes like stroke risk will be essential for establishing definitive treatment thresholds.
Summary updated