Volumes of Hyperbolic Three-Manifolds Associated with Modular Links

Alex Brandts, Tali Pinsky, Lior SilbermanSymmetry 2019 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper explores the relationship between the volume of hyperbolic 3-manifolds and the "complexity" (total length) of specific links derived from periodic geodesics on the modular surface. They provide strong numerical evidence that for links associated with real quadratic fields, this volume grows linearly with length, a behavior not observed for general sets of geodesics. This suggests a deep connection between number theory and the geometry of 3-manifolds.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper investigates the geometric properties of 3-manifolds that arise as complements of links. Specifically, they consider links formed by lifting periodic geodesics from the modular surface (a fundamental object in number theory and geometry) to its unit tangent bundle. The complement of such a link is guaranteed to be a hyperbolic 3-manifold, which has a well-defined volume. The central question is how this volume relates to the "size" or "complexity" of the link, measured by the total length of the constituent geodesics. While previous work established upper bounds for these volumes, this paper focuses on whether a linear relationship exists between volume and length for specific, number-theoretically significant families of geodesics. This is motivated by the idea that number-theoretic structures might impose a particular geometric regularity.

Methods

The authors employ a multi-faceted approach combining number theory, geometry, and computational topology:

  • Modular Surface and Geodesics: They start with the modular surface, a quotient of the hyperbolic plane by the modular group PSL₂(Z). Periodic geodesics on this surface are identified with conjugacy classes of hyperbolic elements in PSL₂(Z).
  • Lifting to Unit Tangent Bundle: These geodesics are lifted to the unit tangent bundle of the modular surface, which is a 3-manifold. A collection of these lifted geodesics forms a link in this 3-manifold.
  • Hyperbolic Structure: The complement of these links is shown to possess a hyperbolic 3-manifold structure, a key property that allows for the computation of volume.
  • Number-Theoretic Connection: The core of the paper lies in selecting specific sets of geodesics. They focus on geodesics corresponding to the ideal classes in the ring of integers of real quadratic fields Q(√d). This connection is established through integral binary quadratic forms, which are known to be in bijection with these ideal classes and, in turn, with periodic geodesics on the modular surface.
  • Computational Approach: To obtain the volumes, they use a computational pipeline:
  • Matrix Representation: Quadratic forms are converted into matrices in PSL₂(Z).
  • Word Decomposition: These matrices are decomposed into words in the generators X and Y of PSL₂(Z).
  • Template and DT-Code: A "template" (a branched surface with a semi-flow) is used to represent the geodesic flow. The words are translated into a "DT-code," a combinatorial description of the link.
  • Volume Calculation: The DT-code is fed into the computational topology software SnapPy to estimate the volume of the manifold complement.
  • Length Calculation: The sum of the geometric lengths of the geodesics is computed using number-theoretic quantities related to the quadratic fields (regulator and class number).

Datasets

The paper does not introduce new datasets in the traditional machine learning sense. Instead, it uses a systematically generated set of "datasets" derived from number theory:

  • Quadratic Fields: The primary "dataset" consists of families of real quadratic fields Q(√d) where 'd' ranges over square-free positive integers.
  • Discriminants: For these fields, they consider discriminants up to 3992, which corresponds to square-free integers up to 1000. This systematic generation allows for numerical exploration of the relationship between volume and length across a significant range of number-theoretic objects.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Number Theory Dictates Geometry: The paper strongly suggests that number-theoretic properties (specifically, the structure of ideal class groups of real quadratic fields) impose a regularity on the geometry of associated hyperbolic 3-manifolds, leading to a linear relationship between volume and geodesic length.
  • Linear Growth as a Special Property: The finding that volume grows linearly with length for these number-theoretically defined links is presented as a significant and perhaps surprising result. This contrasts with general sets of geodesics where such a simple relationship is not expected.
  • Bridging Dynamics and Topology: The use of Ghys's template and symbolic dynamics to connect the abstract concept of periodic geodesics to concrete knot and link structures is a powerful methodological insight.
  • Computational Power: The paper highlights the effectiveness of computational tools like SnapPy in exploring complex geometric and topological questions that are intractable analytically.

Key Results

  • Numerical Evidence for Linear Growth: For families of links derived from the ideal classes of real quadratic fields Q(√d) (with d up to 1000), the paper presents strong numerical evidence that the volume of the complement grows linearly with the total length of the geodesics.
  • Best-Fit Line: The observed relationship is approximated by the line: volume ≈ 3.24 * length + 0.01.
  • Contrast with General Cases: The authors explicitly state that this linear growth is not the case for general sets of geodesics, implying that the number-theoretic selection criterion is crucial.
  • Examples of Bounded Volume: The paper also provides examples of geodesic families where the length tends to infinity, but the volume remains bounded, illustrating that linear growth is not a universal phenomenon.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Numerical Evidence: The results are based on strong numerical evidence. While compelling, they are not formal proofs of linear growth for all such families. The authors acknowledge this by stating "we find that the growth is linear" and "volumes seem to lie very close to the best-fit line."
  • Generalization: The paper focuses on specific families of geodesics related to real quadratic fields. It would be interesting to explore other number-theoretic constructions or different types of hyperbolic surfaces.
  • Theoretical Explanation: While the numerical results are striking, a deeper theoretical explanation for why this linear relationship emerges for these specific families is a natural direction for future work. The authors mention that they have not been able to find other families exhibiting linear growth without relying on class fields, underscoring the importance of this connection.
  • Upper Bounds: The paper references prior work establishing upper bounds for volumes. Future research could aim to tighten these bounds or prove matching lower bounds for the specific cases exhibiting linear growth.

Summary updated

Abstract

Periodic geodesics on the modular surface correspond to periodic orbits of the geodesic flow in its unit tangent bundle PSL 2 ( Z ) ∖ PSL 2 ( R ) . A finite collection of such orbits is a collection of disjoint closed curves in a 3-manifold, in other words a link. The complement of those links is always a hyperbolic 3-manifold, and hence has a well-defined volume. We present strong numerical evidence that, in the case of the set of geodesics corresponding to the ideal class group of a real quadratic field, the volume has linear asymptotics in terms of the total length of the geodesics. This is not the case for general sets of geodesics.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{brandts2019volumes,
  author = {Alex Brandts and Tali Pinsky and Lior Silberman},
  title = {{Volumes of Hyperbolic Three-Manifolds Associated with Modular Links}},
  booktitle = {Symmetry},
  year = {2019},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=x8o9SSvNeWO},
}
Figure