Voltage-controlled Cryogenic Boolean Logic Family Based on Ferroelectric SQUID

Shamiul Alam, Md. Shafayat Hossain, Kai Ni, Vijaykrishnan Narayanan, Ahmedullah AzizarXiv 2022 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Superconducting electronics (SCE) offer a promising path toward ultra-low-power, high-speed computing for quantum systems and space exploration. However, the field has long struggled with the lack of voltage-controlled logic and the difficulty of cascading gates (fan-out). This paper presents a novel logic family based on Ferroelectric SQUIDs (FeSQUIDs) integrated with heater cryotrons (hTrons). By utilizing ferroelectric polarization to tune superconducting critical currents and employing hTrons as voltage buffers, the researchers demonstrate a complete, cascadable Boolean logic set—including Copy, NOT, AND, OR, and XOR gates—capable of operating at cryogenic temperatures with non-volatile state retention.

Introduction

As traditional CMOS scaling reaches its physical limits, superconducting electronics have emerged as a leading alternative for specialized high-performance applications. Despite their potential, SCE devices like Josephson Junctions (JJs) are primarily current-controlled, making them difficult to interface with standard voltage-based architectures. Furthermore, the "fan-out" problem—where the output of one gate is insufficient to drive subsequent stages—has historically limited the complexity of superconducting processors.

This research addresses these bottlenecks by introducing a voltage-controlled logic family. The architecture leverages the unique properties of the FeSQUID to provide non-volatile logic states and the hTron to provide the necessary signal amplification for robust cascading.

The FeSQUID: A Voltage-Controlled Superconductor

The core of this logic family is the FeSQUID, a device that integrates a Superconducting Quantum Interference Device (SQUID) with a ferroelectric thin film (such as PZT). Unlike traditional SQUIDs, the FeSQUID allows for electrostatic control of superconductivity.

By applying an external gate voltage, the polarization of the ferroelectric layer is toggled. This change in polarization modifies the carrier density within the superconducting bridge, effectively shifting the device's critical current ($I_C$) between two distinct levels ($2.6 \mu A$ and $4 \mu A$). Because ferroelectric polarization is inherently non-volatile, the logic state is preserved even if the power supply is interrupted, offering a significant advantage for energy-efficient computing.

Overcoming the Fan-out Barrier with hTrons

While the FeSQUID provides the logic mechanism, the voltage levels required to switch ferroelectric materials (typically in the volt range) are much higher than the millivolt signals produced by standard superconducting loops. To bridge this gap and enable cascadability, the researchers integrated "heater cryotrons" (hTrons) as output buffers.

The hTron is a three-terminal superconducting switch. In this architecture, a small output current from the FeSQUID flows through the hTron’s heater, triggering a phase transition in the hTron’s channel from a superconducting state to a resistive state. This transition allows the hTron to act as a level-shifter, producing a standardized $\pm 6V$ output. This output provides the "oomph" necessary to drive the gate of the next FeSQUID in a logic chain, effectively solving the fan-out problem that has hindered previous SCE designs.

Modeling and Logic Verification

To validate the proposed logic family, the team developed a circuit-compatible compact model in Verilog-A. This model incorporates the Preisach model for ferroelectric hysteresis and the Ambegaokar–Baratoff theory for superconducting behavior. The model was calibrated using experimental data from existing literature to ensure physical accuracy.

Using this framework, the researchers successfully simulated a complete set of Boolean operations:

  • Basic Gates: Copy, NOT, AND, and OR gates were verified with clear transitions between logic '0' ($-6V$) and logic '1' ($+6V$).
  • Complex Integration: To demonstrate the scalability of the family, a 2-input XOR gate was constructed by cascading NOT, AND, and OR gates. The simulations confirmed that the hTron buffers successfully maintained signal integrity across multiple stages.

Discussion and Future Outlook

The integration of FeSQUIDs and hTrons suggests a path toward a unified "all-FeSQUID" architecture where the same device type can serve as both logic and non-volatile memory. Such a design could eliminate the "memory wall"—the latency and power bottleneck caused by moving data between separate processor and memory units.

However, several challenges remain before physical implementation:

  1. Voltage Scaling: The current $\pm 6V$ requirement is relatively high for cryogenic systems. Future work will explore thinner ferroelectric layers or alternative materials to reduce the switching voltage.
  2. Thermal Management: Because hTrons rely on thermal switching, managing the heat budget in a large-scale integrated circuit will be critical to maintaining the cryogenic environment.
  3. Fabrication: While the individual components have been demonstrated experimentally, the fabrication of complex, multi-gate cascaded circuits remains the next major milestone for this technology.

Conclusion

This FeSQUID-based logic family represents a significant step forward for superconducting electronics. By combining voltage-controlled non-volatility with hTron-enabled cascadability, the researchers have provided a blueprint for complex, multi-stage cryogenic processors that could one day power the next generation of quantum and high-performance computers.

Summary updated

Abstract

The recent progress in quantum computing and space exploration led to a surge in interest in cryogenic electronics. Superconducting devices such as Josephson junction, Josephson field effect transistor, cryotron, and superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID) are traditionally used to build cryogenic logic gates. However, due to the superconducting nature, gate-voltage-based control of these devices is extremely difficult. Even more challenging is to cascade the logic gates because most of these devices require current bias for their operation. Therefore, these devices are not as convenient as the semiconducting transistors to design logic gates. Here, to overcome these challenges, we propose a ferroelectric SQUID (FeSQUID) based voltage-controlled logic gates. FeSQUID exhibits two different critical current levels for two different voltage-switchable polarization states of the ferroelectric. We utilize the polarization-dependent (hence, voltage-controllable) superconducting to resistive switching of FeSQUID to design Boolean logic gates such as Copy, NOT, AND, and OR gates. The operations of these gates are verified using a Verilog-A-based compact model of FeSQUID. Finally, to demonstrate the fanning out capability of FeSQUID-based logic family, we simulate a 2-input XOR gate using FeSQUID-based NOT, AND, and OR gates. Together with the ongoing progress on FeSQUID-based non-volatile memory, our designed FeSQUID-based logic family will enable all-FeSQUID based cryogenic computer, ensure minimum mismatch between logic and memory blocks in terms of speed, power consumption, and fabrication process.
BibTeX
@misc{alam2022voltage,
  author = {Shamiul Alam and Md. Shafayat Hossain and Kai Ni and Vijaykrishnan Narayanan and Ahmedullah Aziz},
  title = {{Voltage-controlled Cryogenic Boolean Logic Family Based on Ferroelectric SQUID}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2212.08202},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2212.08202},
}
Figure