TL;DR
This study investigates the volatile characteristics of apatite in dacite from the Eastern Manus Basin, revealing insights into magma evolution and the role of subduction processes. By analyzing apatite composition, researchers determined that the magmas were volatile-undersaturated and influenced by slab-derived fluids, contributing to their high chlorine content and suggesting a shallow magma chamber depth.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The evolutionary behavior of magmatic volatiles in young back-arc basins, like the Eastern Manus Basin, remains poorly understood. Volatiles play a crucial role in magma evolution and eruption processes, influencing everything from mineral stability to melt viscosity. Apatite, a mineral known for its ability to record magmatic volatile information, has become a key tool for studying these processes. However, detailed studies on the volatile composition and its implications for magma genesis in this specific region were lacking. This paper aims to fill that gap by using apatite as a proxy to understand the volatile composition, oxygen fugacity, and petrogenesis of magmas in the Eastern Manus Basin.
Methods
The researchers employed a multi-faceted analytical approach. They analyzed dacite samples collected from the Eastern Manus Basin using:
- Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) and Energy Dispersive Spectrometry (EDS): For preliminary observations and qualitative/semi-quantitative analysis of mineral compositions.
- Electron Probe Microanalyzer (EPMA): For precise quantitative analysis of apatite compositions, including major elements and volatile elements like F, Cl, and SO3.
- X-ray Fluorescence (XRF): To determine SiO2 and P2O5 contents in the whole-rock samples.
They then utilized established models and equations to:
- Calculate Apatite Saturation Temperatures (AST): Using the method proposed by Harrison and Watson [47].
- Estimate Magmatic S Concentrations: Employing semi-quantitative formulas from Peng et al. [29] and Parat et al. [28].
- Determine Oxygen Fugacity (fo₂): By analyzing Mn contents in apatite and using equations from Miles et al. [56] and Myers and Eugster [57].
- Calculate F, Cl, and H₂O contents of Melts: Utilizing a regular ternary solution model for apatite established by Li and Hermann [78] and a thermodynamic model for apatite developed by Li and Costa [75].
Datasets
The study utilized apatite samples from dacite collected from five stations in the Eastern Manus Basin during a 2015 cruise of the R/V Kexue Hao. These samples were prepared into thin sections for analysis. The study also referenced existing datasets and literature for comparative analysis, including data from other subduction-related volcanic rocks in the western Pacific.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Apatite as a Volatile Recorder: The study reinforces the utility of apatite as a reliable recorder of magmatic volatile information, particularly in volatile-undersaturated melts where its composition directly reflects the melt.
- Slab-Derived Fluids are Key: The high Cl/F ratio and elevated H₂O content in the melts strongly indicate the significant input of slab-derived fluids into the mantle source region of the Eastern Manus Basin.
- Dual Source for Chlorine: Chlorine enrichment appears to stem from a combination of subduction-released fluids and potentially Cl-rich seawater-derived components, with subduction fluids contributing an estimated 14-21% of the total Cl.
- Shallow Magma Chamber: The calculated H₂O contents suggest the magma chamber is located at a relatively shallow depth of approximately 2 km below the seafloor.
- Reduced Magmatic Conditions: The presence of magnetite and the low SO₃ content in apatites point to a weakly reduced magmatic environment, likely influenced by the crystallization and separation of magnetite.
Key Results
- Apatite Saturation Temperatures: Ranged from 935 to 952 °C.
- Apatite Composition: Characterized by F (0.87–1.39 wt.%), Cl (1.24–1.70 wt.%), and low SO₃ (≤ 0.06 wt.%).
- Minimum S Concentrations in Melts: Estimated to be between 2–65 ppm or 8–11 ppm.
- Oxygen Fugacity: The host melt was under a reduction condition with a narrow fluctuation range (ΔFMQ = −0.2 ± 0.9).
- Melt F and Cl Contents: Calculated to be 185–448 ppm for F and 1059–1588 ppm for Cl.
- Melt H₂O Contents: Estimated to be 1.4–2.1 wt.% (based on F) and 1.2–1.5 wt.% (based on Cl), with an error of ± 30–40%.
Limitations and Future Work
- Approximation of Melt P₂O₅: The study acknowledges that estimating melt P₂O₅ from whole-rock data introduces some error, though it is considered to have a small effect on the results.
- Minimum S Concentrations: The calculated S concentrations represent minimum values, as reduced sulfur species in the melts were not accounted for.
- Future Work: The paper suggests that further investigation into the specific sources of F-rich components (e.g., F-rich sediments, lawsonite/phengite decomposition) and the precise contribution of seawater-derived components would be beneficial. Understanding the impact of these high halogen concentrations on magma rheology and fluid exsolution also warrants further study.
Summary updated