TL;DR
This paper investigates the unique vibrato in Noh singing, revealing that it's not just pitch modulation but also involves complex laryngeal and supraglottal constrictions. By using electroglottography (EGG) and acoustic analysis, they demonstrate how these intricate vocal fold and pharyngeal movements contribute to Noh's distinctive, expressive vocal quality.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Noh, a traditional Japanese performing art, is known for its solemn style and a highly distinctive singing voice. While vibrato is a common vocal technique, the specific mechanisms behind the vibrato used in Noh singing remain largely unexplored. Previous research has hinted at a strong interaction between the vocal tract and vocal fold vibration, but a detailed understanding of the laryngeal and supraglottal movements contributing to Noh's unique vibrato quality was lacking. This paper aims to bridge that gap by analyzing the physical production of this specific vocal phenomenon.
Methods
The researchers employed a combination of electroglottography (EGG) and acoustical analysis to study Noh vibrato.
- Electroglottography (EGG): This technique measures the electrical conductivity between the vocal folds to infer their vibratory patterns. They used an EGG system to capture laryngeal movements.
- DEGG Analysis: The derivative of the EGG signal (DEGG) was crucial for precisely identifying glottal closing instances (GCI) and glottal opening instances (GOI). Novel analysis methods were developed to extract parameters like
to,t1, andt2from multiple GCIs within a single glottal cycle. These parameters help characterize complex vocal fold closure patterns. - Acoustical Analysis: Standard audio recording and analysis techniques were used to capture the sound. This included analyzing formant frequencies (F1, F2) and intensity contours.
- Parameter Calculation: Key EGG-based parameters like F0 (fundamental frequency), OQegg (degree of vocal fold contact), and SQegg (ratio of de-contacting to contacting phases) were calculated. Phase differences between consecutive GCIs (GCI2, GCI3) were also analyzed to understand the timing of vocal fold and supraglottal events.
Datasets
The study utilized audio and EGG recordings of a Noh play titled "Tsurukame," sung by a successor of Yoshio Hosho, a recognized national treasure. The recordings were made at the Nohgaku stage in Tokyo. The specific vocal samples analyzed included the vowel /o/ from phrases like "kin gin no" and "sikitae no o," and the syllable /ba/ from "haru ni nareba." No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing recordings of a specific Noh performance were used.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Beyond F0 Modulation: Noh vibrato isn't solely achieved by modulating the fundamental frequency (F0). Complex changes in vocal fold constriction and supraglottal structures play a significant role.
- Vocal Fold Constriction and Phonation Types: The EGG analysis revealed period doubling in the EGG waveform, suggesting the alternating use of "pressed voice" and "ventricular-ventricular mode (VVM)" phonation types during vibrato. This indicates dynamic changes in how the vocal folds and surrounding structures are engaged.
- Multiple Glottal Closures (GCIs): The presence of multiple GCIs (GCI2, GCI3) within a single vibrato cycle, particularly at lower F0 regions, points to complex, possibly "double oscillator" behavior of the vocal folds due to extreme constriction.
- Supraglottal Involvement: The study suggests that supraglottal constrictions (involving structures like the ventricular and aryepiglottic folds) are actively manipulated during Noh vibrato. This is hypothesized to change the vocal tract length and resonance.
- Unique Intensity Contours: Noh vibrato exhibits unusual intensity contours, sometimes showing three peaks per cycle, which differ from typical Western operatic vibrato. This is linked to the dynamic interaction between F0 and formant frequencies and the changing vocal tract resonance.
- Slow and Wide Vibrato: The characteristic slow rate and large extent of Noh vibrato are interpreted as reflecting the solemn and deliberate performance style of Noh.
Key Results
- EGG Parameters: OQegg and SQegg showed significant fluctuations (up to 35% and 508% respectively) during vibrato, far exceeding F0 variations (around 70 Hz or ±3 semitones). This highlights the dynamic changes in vocal fold contact.
- Phase Differences: GCI2 appeared with a phase difference of approximately 190° after GCI, and GCI3 appeared at 235° or 302° phases after GCI in certain instances. These are interpreted as indicators of ventricular fold adduction and other complex laryngeal constrictions.
- Formant Frequency Fluctuations: F1 and F2 fluctuated by approximately 200 Hz and 150 Hz, respectively, often in opposite phase to F0. This is attributed to supraglottal constriction and vocal tract length changes.
- Intensity Contour: A novel intensity contour with three peaks per vibrato cycle was observed, suggesting a complex interplay of spectral components.
Limitations and Future Work
- Limited Data: The study was based on recordings from a single performer and a specific Noh play. While insightful, it may not represent all Noh singers or performances.
- Speculative Mechanisms: While strong evidence is presented, the precise anatomical mechanisms of supraglottal constriction and their direct correlation with specific phonation types require further investigation. The exact cause of GCI3 remains speculative.
- Future Work: The authors suggest further research into the precise anatomical mechanisms behind these constrictions and their impact on vocal tract resonance. Comparing Noh vibrato with other vocal traditions that utilize similar constrictive techniques (e.g., Tibetan chants, discussed in related work) could provide broader insights. Investigating the role of the mask worn by Noh performers in shaping the sound is also a potential avenue.
Summary updated