Vitamin A Status Is More Commonly Associated With Symptoms and Neurodevelopment in Boys With Autism Spectrum Disorders—A Multicenter Study in China

Ting Yang, Li Chen, Ying Dai, Feiyong Jia, Yan Hao, Ling Li, Jie Zhang, Lijie Wu, Xiaoyan Ke, Mingji Yi, Hong Qi, Jinjin Chen, Shuanfeng Fang, Yichao Wang, Qi Wang, Chunhua Jin, Jie Chen, Tingyu LiFrontiers in Nutrition 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This large-scale multicenter study in China reveals that children with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD)—particularly boys—have significantly lower serum Vitamin A (VA) levels than typically developing peers. Crucially, lower VA levels in boys correlate strongly with more severe social impairments and lower neurodevelopmental scores, a relationship that was notably absent or much weaker in girls with ASD.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) is a complex neurodevelopmental condition characterized by social challenges and repetitive behaviors. One of its most striking features is a significant sex bias: it is diagnosed roughly four times more often in boys than in girls. While the exact cause of ASD remains elusive, researchers have long suspected that Vitamin A (VA) plays a role.

VA is metabolized into retinoic acid, a powerful signaling molecule essential for brain patterning, synaptic plasticity, and the regulation of oxytocin—a hormone critical for social bonding. While previous small-scale studies suggested a link between VA deficiency and ASD, they often ignored sex differences. This paper addresses the gap by investigating whether VA status relates differently to the clinical symptoms and developmental progress of boys versus girls with ASD.

Methods

The researchers conducted a nationwide, multicenter cross-sectional study across 13 cities in China. They employed a robust clinical framework:

  • Biochemical Analysis: Serum VA (retinol) levels were measured using High-Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC), the gold standard for accuracy.
  • Symptom Evaluation: Three standardized parent-report and clinician-observed tools were used: the Autism Behavior Checklist (ABC), the Social Responsiveness Scale (SRS), and the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS).
  • Neurodevelopmental Assessment: The researchers used the revised Children Neuropsychological and Behavior Scale (CNBS-R2016) to calculate developmental quotients (DQs) across five domains: Gross Motor, Fine Motor, Adaptive Behavior, Language, and Personal-Social.
  • Statistical Modeling: They used multivariate logistic regression to compare VA levels between groups and multivariate linear regression to analyze the association between VA levels and clinical scores, adjusting for age as a covariate.

Datasets

The study utilized a massive primary dataset consisting of 2,552 children aged 2–7 years:

  • ASD Group: 1,300 children diagnosed via DSM-5 criteria.
  • Control Group: 1,252 typically developing (TD) children. The participants were recruited from five major geographic regions in China (North, East, West, South, and Middle) to ensure a representative sample of the national population.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Male Vulnerability: The most significant "aha moment" is that the association between VA and ASD symptoms is sex-specific. While ASD children generally had lower VA than controls, the boys with ASD had lower levels than the girls with ASD.
  • Symptom Correlation: In boys, VA levels were a predictor of social severity. Lower VA was tied to higher (worse) scores on the SRS and CARS. In girls, VA levels showed almost no correlation with these core social symptoms.
  • Developmental Impact: For boys, VA status was positively associated with nearly all developmental quotients (General, Language, Gross Motor, and Personal-Social). For girls, the only significant association was with "Adaptive Behavior."
  • The RORA Connection: The authors hypothesize that this sex difference might be linked to the RORA gene, which is involved in VA signaling and is differentially regulated by male and female hormones (testosterone vs. estrogen). This suggests that VA deficiency might "hit harder" in the presence of male hormonal profiles.

Key Results

  • Lower VA in ASD: Children with ASD had significantly lower serum VA levels than TD children (Adjusted Odds Ratio = 0.275).
  • Sex Differences in VA: Within the ASD group, boys had a mean VA level of 0.344 mg/L, while girls had 0.360 mg/L (p < 0.004).
  • Negative Correlation with Severity: In boys, VA levels were negatively correlated with SRS total scores ($\beta = -0.090$) and CARS total scores ($\beta = -0.106$).
  • Positive Correlation with Development: In boys, VA levels were positively associated with the General Quotient ($\beta = 0.073$) and Language Quotient ($\beta = 0.080$).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several important caveats:

  1. Causality: As a cross-sectional study, it can show that low VA and ASD symptoms go together, but it cannot prove that low VA causes ASD.
  2. Dietary Data: The study did not collect detailed data on the children's actual food intake, making it unclear if the low VA is due to "picky eating" (common in ASD) or a metabolic issue.
  3. Sample Size for Girls: Because ASD is rarer in females, the female cohort was significantly smaller than the male cohort (242 vs 1,088), which may have limited the statistical power to find correlations in girls.
  4. Future Directions: The researchers call for longitudinal studies and randomized controlled trials (RCTs) to see if VA supplementation can actually improve clinical outcomes, particularly in boys.

Summary updated

Abstract

ASD children, especially boys, have lower serum VA levels than TD children. Moreover, serum VA status is more commonly associated with clinical symptoms and neurodevelopment in boys with ASD.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yang2022vitamin,
  author = {Ting Yang and Li Chen and Ying Dai and Feiyong Jia and Yan Hao and Ling Li and Jie Zhang and Lijie Wu and Xiaoyan Ke and Mingji Yi and Hong Qi and Jinjin Chen and Shuanfeng Fang and Yichao Wang and Qi Wang and Chunhua Jin and Jie Chen and Tingyu Li and Jie Chen and Tingyu Li},
  title = {{Vitamin A Status Is More Commonly Associated With Symptoms and Neurodevelopment in Boys With Autism Spectrum Disorders—A Multicenter Study in China}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Nutrition},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fnut.2022.851980},
}
Figure