Visualizing Knowledge Evolution and Hotspots of Rural Environment and Health: A Systematic Review and Research Direction

Gongrang Zhang, Kang Li, Dongxiao Gu, Xiaoyu Wang, Xuejie Yang, Keyu Zhu, Guoqiang LiangIEEE Access 2019 · DOI

Abstract

With global warming, energy scarcity, water shortages, and air, soil, and water pollution, the situation of environments in countries around the world is getting more and more serious and in some countries, rural environmental issues are more prominent. Health problems in rural areas also cannot be ignored, chronic diseases and infectious diseases have become the greatest threat to human life, while good environment and human health are the foundation of social and economic sustainable development. This paper adopts the bibliometrics method to conduct a visual analysis of 6,971 studies in the field of the rural environment and health published on the Web of Science between 2000 and 2017, including time knowledge map analysis, space knowledge map analysis, knowledge base analysis, and research focus analysis. This paper reveals the development status of research in the field of rural environment and health, analyzes, and discusses the research hotspots and future development trends in this field, and provides important knowledge support for researchers to carry out follow-up research.

Introduction

Rural populations worldwide often face a unique "double burden." They are frequently the first to experience the consequences of environmental degradation—such as soil and water contamination from industrial agriculture—while simultaneously grappling with limited healthcare access and disproportionately high rates of chronic disease. Despite a vast body of individual research, the field has historically lacked a high-level, visual synthesis of its progress. This study addresses that gap by mapping the "hotspots," key researchers, and institutional networks that define the discipline, providing a roadmap for future funding and research efforts.

Methodology

To quantify the "state of the art," the authors employed bibliometrics—the statistical analysis of academic publications. By analyzing 6,971 research articles from the Web of Science core collection (2000–2017), the study utilized several specialized visualization tools:

  • CiteSpace: To generate knowledge maps of author and institutional collaborations.
  • HistCite: To identify influential papers through citation frequency analysis.
  • SATI & Ucinet/Netdraw: To perform keyword co-occurrence analysis, revealing the thematic structure of the field.

Temporal Evolution and Growth

The research output in rural health remained relatively moderate during the early 2000s. However, 2009 marked a significant tipping point, after which the field entered a stage of rapid, exponential growth. This surge is attributed to the global acceleration of urbanization and a growing recognition of "environmental inequality" between rural and urban sectors.

Growth in the number of studies published annually on rural environment and health (2000–2017).

Between 2014 and 2015 alone, publication volume increased by 30.7%. This trajectory suggests that rural health has moved from a niche concern to a major global research priority.

Collaborative Dynamics

As the volume of research has grown, so has the complexity of the research teams. The field has become increasingly collaborative, with the average number of co-authors per article reaching 4.74 by the end of the study period.

The rising number of authors contributing to the field, reflecting increased interdisciplinary collaboration.

While the United States (led by the University of North Carolina) remains the dominant institutional force, the research focus is increasingly global. China and India have emerged as critical research areas due to their massive rural populations and the health risks posed by rapid industrialization and intensive agricultural chemical use.

Research Hotspots: From Pollution to Obesity

One of the most significant findings is the thematic shift in the literature. While traditional environmental stressors like arsenic and air pollution remain high-impact topics, the most influential research cluster now centers on rural obesity. Key studies have shifted the conversation toward "food environments," examining how the lack of affordable, healthy food options in rural areas contributes to chronic health crises. Beyond the primary search terms, the most frequent keywords identified were physical activity, obesity, epidemiology, and prevalence.

Future Directions

Despite the high volume of papers, the authors found that a stable "core author group" has not yet fully solidified, suggesting the field is still maturing and attracting diverse new talent. To address remaining gaps, the study proposes four critical research directions:

  1. Nutrition and Growth: Tackling both malnutrition and overnutrition in rural youth.
  2. Medical Infrastructure: Addressing the persistent lack of quality medical services in rural regions.
  3. Public Education: Enhancing health literacy and awareness among rural residents.
  4. Climate Change: Investigating the intersection of shifting weather patterns, agricultural stability, and respiratory health.

Summary updated

Abstract

With global warming, energy scarcity, water shortages, and air, soil, and water pollution, the situation of environments in countries around the world is getting more and more serious and in some countries, rural environmental issues are more prominent. Health problems in rural areas also cannot be ignored, chronic diseases and infectious diseases have become the greatest threat to human life, while good environment and human health are the foundation of social and economic sustainable development. This paper adopts the bibliometrics method to conduct a visual analysis of 6,971 studies in the field of the rural environment and health published on the Web of Science between 2000 and 2017, including time knowledge map analysis, space knowledge map analysis, knowledge base analysis, and research focus analysis. This paper reveals the development status of research in the field of rural environment and health, analyzes, and discusses the research hotspots and future development trends in this field, and provides important knowledge support for researchers to carry out follow-up research.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2019visualizing,
  author = {Gongrang Zhang and Kang Li and Dongxiao Gu and Xiaoyu Wang and Xuejie Yang and Keyu Zhu and Guoqiang Liang},
  title = {{Visualizing Knowledge Evolution and Hotspots of Rural Environment and Health: A Systematic Review and Research Direction}},
  booktitle = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2019.2919549},
}
Figure