Visualizing Current Flow at the Mesoscale in Disordered Assemblies of Touching Semiconductor Nanocrystals

Qinyi Chen, Jeffrey R. Guest, Elijah ThimsenThe Journal of Physical Chemistry C 2017 · DOI

Abstract

The transport of electrons through assemblies of nanocrystals is critical for the performance of optoelectronic materials. While previous research has focused on single nanocrystals or pairs, there is a significant gap in understanding the collective behavior of large assemblies at the mesoscale. This study investigates variable range hopping (VRH) transport in disordered assemblies of touching, heavily doped ZnO nanocrystals. Using the Skinner, Chen, and Shklovskii (SCS) model alongside experimental conductive atomic force microscopy (CAFM) on ultrathin films, the researchers visualized current flow as a function of temperature. While experimental results largely aligned with the SCS model's prediction of a dominant "optimum band" for conduction, CAFM revealed additional dynamic subnetworks. These subnetworks connect and disconnect over time, representing a mesoscale manifestation of the "blinking" phenomenon.

Introduction: The Challenge of Collective Transport

Semiconductor nanocrystals (NCs) are foundational to next-generation technologies like solar cells and LEDs. However, bridging the gap between the physics of a single nanocrystal and the bulk properties of a material remains a challenge. In disordered assemblies, charge transport typically occurs via Efros-Shklovskii Variable Range Hopping (ES-VRH), where electrons "hop" between sites of varying energy and distance. Due to the structural randomness of these "piles" of particles, predicting and visualizing the actual pathways current takes is difficult. This work aims to map these pathways at the mesoscale—the intermediate regime where thousands of disordered particles interact.

High-resolution imaging of the ZnO nanocrystal assembly at both the mesoscale (left) and the atomic scale (right), showing the disordered yet touching nature of the particles.

Methods and Experimental Design

The researchers utilized a multi-pronged approach to study transport:

  1. Synthesis: ZnO nanocrystals were synthesized via plasma and deposited using supersonic impact to create dense, ultrathin films only a few particle layers thick.
  2. Control: Atomic Layer Deposition (ALD) was used to coat NCs with ZnO or $Al_2O_3$, allowing precise tuning of the contact radius and carrier concentration.
  3. Modeling: A 1000-particle assembly was simulated using Brownian dynamics and treated as a resistor network based on the SCS model.
  4. Visualization: Conductive Atomic Force Microscopy (CAFM) mapped local resistance and current flow from 38 K to 296 K with nanometer precision.
Cross-sectional view of the ultrathin ZnO nanocrystal film, illustrating the dense packing of the assembly used for transport measurements.

Key Insights: The "Blinking" Backbone

The study yielded several critical findings regarding how current traverses disordered networks:

  • Beyond the Optimum Band: The SCS model predicts conduction is dominated by a single "optimum band" or backbone of low-resistance sites. Experiments confirmed this but also identified "subnetworks"—secondary peaks in resistance histograms representing higher-resistance regions that still contribute to flow.
  • Mesoscale Blinking: A surprising discovery was the temporal instability of these subnetworks. Large regions of the film were observed joining and disconnecting from the main conduction network. This dynamic behavior is a collective, mesoscale version of the "blinking" often seen in individual quantum dots.
  • Tunable Transport Regimes: By adding just a few cycles of ALD ZnO, the researchers could transition the material from an insulator-like hopping regime to a metallic-like transport regime, demonstrating significant control over electrical properties.

Results and Quantitative Agreement

The experimental data showed strong quantitative agreement with theory. The temperature dependence of the peak resistance in CAFM maps (slope = 10.6) closely matched the SCS model's prediction (slope = 13.9). Furthermore, the CAFM maps successfully visualized the "percolation pathways," providing a direct look at how charge navigates the disordered maze of particles.

Conclusion and Future Directions

While the SCS model provides an excellent framework for understanding mesoscale transport, it does not currently account for the dynamic "blinking" of subnetworks. These tenuous, high-resistance connections are highly sensitive to environmental changes or charge states. Future work will focus on incorporating these temporal dynamics into transport models. Understanding these shifting connections could pave the way for more stable nanocrystal devices or even neuromorphic hardware that mimics biological neural networks.

Summary updated

Abstract

The transport of electrons through assemblies of nanocrystals is important to performance in optoelectronic applications for these materials. Previous work has primarily focused on single nanocrystals or transitions between pairs of nanocrystals. There is a gap in knowledge of how large numbers of nanocrystals in an assembly behave collectively and how this collective behavior manifests at the mesoscale. In this work, the variable range hopping (VRH) transport of electrons in disordered assemblies of touching, heavily doped ZnO nanocrystals was visualized at the mesoscale as a function of temperature both theoretically, using the model of Skinner, Chen, and Shklovskii (SCS), and experimentally, with conductive atomic force microscopy on ultrathin films only a few particle layers thick. Agreement was obtained between the model and experiments, with a few notable exceptions. The SCS model predicts that a single network within the nanocrystal assembly, composed of sites connected by small resistances, dominates conduction, namely, the optimum band from variable range hopping theory. However, our experiments revealed that in addition to the optimum band there are subnetworks that appear as additional peaks in the resistance histogram of conductive atomic force microscopy (CAFM) maps. Furthermore, the connections of these subnetworks to the optimum band change in time, such that some subnetworks become connected to the optimum band while others become disconnected and isolated from the optimum band; this observation appears to be an experimental manifestation of the “blinking” phenomenon in our images of mesoscale transport.
BibTeX
@article{chen2017visualizing,
  author = {Qinyi Chen and Jeffrey R. Guest and Elijah Thimsen},
  title = {{Visualizing Current Flow at the Mesoscale in Disordered Assemblies of Touching Semiconductor Nanocrystals}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physical Chemistry C},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1021/acs.jpcc.7b04949},
}
Figure