TL;DR
Researchers have developed a novel genetically encoded FRET-based indicator, "ATeam," for real-time visualization of ATP levels within single living cells. This tool reveals surprisingly low ATP concentrations in mitochondria and demonstrates that cells can dynamically switch their primary ATP production pathway between glycolysis and oxidative phosphorylation based on nutrient availability.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP) is the fundamental energy currency of cells, powering countless biological processes. However, precisely measuring ATP levels in real-time within individual living cells, and understanding its distribution across different cellular compartments, has been a significant challenge. Existing methods often rely on cell extracts (providing only averaged data), chemiluminescence (affected by multiple factors beyond ATP), or indirect measurements like ion channel activity, which are limited in scope. This lack of a direct, dynamic, and spatially resolved ATP measurement tool hinders our understanding of cellular energy metabolism, regulation, and response to various stimuli.
Methods
The core innovation is the development of "ATeam" (ATP indicator based on Epsilon subunit for Analytical Measurements). This indicator is built around the $\epsilon$ subunit of the bacterial $F_oF_1$-ATP synthase, a protein known to bind ATP without hydrolyzing it and exhibiting high specificity for ATP. The $\epsilon$ subunit undergoes a conformational change upon ATP binding, which the researchers exploited. They fused this $\epsilon$ subunit between two fluorescent proteins: cyan fluorescent protein (CFP) and yellow fluorescent protein (YFP). When ATP is present, the $\epsilon$ subunit folds, bringing CFP and YFP closer, leading to increased Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (FRET) and a change in the ratio of YFP to CFP fluorescence.
To optimize the indicator, they engineered variants:
- AT1.03: This variant uses a circularly permuted YFP (cp173-mVenus) to achieve a larger dynamic range of FRET signal.
- AT3.10: This variant utilizes the $\epsilon$ subunit from a thermophilic bacterium (Bacillus sp. PS3), which has a higher affinity for ATP, allowing for measurement of lower ATP concentrations.
- AT1.03YEMK and AT3.10MGK: These variants were created by swapping specific amino acid residues to fine-tune the ATP affinity.
- nucAT1.03 and mitAT1.03: These versions incorporate targeting sequences (nuclear localization signal or mitochondrial targeting signal) to direct the indicator to specific subcellular compartments.
- AT1.03R122K/R126K: This mutant was designed to be unresponsive to ATP, serving as a negative control.
The researchers characterized these ATeam variants in vitro for their nucleotide selectivity, pH dependence, and kinetic properties. For in vivo studies, they expressed these indicators in HeLa cells and used wide-field fluorescence microscopy to capture CFP and YFP emission images, calculating the YFP/CFP ratio to represent ATP levels.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Mitochondrial ATP levels are surprisingly low: Contrary to the expectation that mitochondria, as major ATP producers, would have high ATP concentrations, the ATeam indicators revealed significantly lower ATP levels in the mitochondrial matrix compared to the cytoplasm and nucleus. This suggests a complex regulatory mechanism for ATP export or utilization within mitochondria.
- Cellular energy metabolism is highly adaptable: HeLa cells can dynamically shift their primary ATP production strategy. When grown in glucose-rich media, glycolysis is the dominant pathway. However, when switched to galactose medium, oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS) becomes the primary source of ATP. This flexibility is crucial for survival in varying nutrient environments.
- Glycolysis is king in glucose-rich cancer cells: For HeLa cells (a cancer cell line) grown in glucose, inhibiting glycolysis (with 2DG) had a more pronounced effect on ATP levels than inhibiting OXPHOS (with KCN), indicating a strong reliance on glycolysis even under aerobic conditions (the Warburg effect).
- ATeam indicators offer tunable affinity and specificity: The ability to engineer ATeam variants with different affinities (from $\mu$M to mM range) and target them to specific organelles makes this a versatile tool for diverse research questions.
Key Results
- ATeam variants with tunable affinities: The developed ATeam indicators had apparent dissociation constants ($K_a$) for ATP ranging from 7.4 $\mu$M (AT3.10) to 3.3 mM (AT1.03).
- Spatially resolved ATP measurement: The indicators successfully visualized ATP distribution in cytoplasm, nucleus, and mitochondria.
- Mitochondrial ATP deficit: The YFP/CFP ratio (indicating ATP level) was significantly lower in mitochondria (34% lower with AT1.03) compared to cytoplasm and nucleus.
- Metabolic flexibility demonstrated: Inhibiting glycolysis (2DG) in glucose-grown cells caused a significant ATP drop, while inhibiting OXPHOS (KCN) had minimal immediate effect. Conversely, in galactose-grown cells, inhibiting OXPHOS (oligomycin A) led to rapid ATP depletion.
- Real-time ATP dynamics: The indicators allowed for real-time monitoring of ATP depletion and partial recovery upon inhibition of metabolic pathways.
Limitations and Future Work
- Mitochondrial ATP paradox: The low mitochondrial ATP level is an unexpected finding that warrants further investigation into the underlying mechanisms, such as the role of adenine nucleotide translocators or specific mitochondrial ATP utilization.
- Generalizability: While demonstrated in HeLa cells, the applicability and findings in other cell types, especially non-cancerous ones, would be valuable. The paper notes similar low mitochondrial ATP in NIH 3T3 cells, suggesting this might be a broader phenomenon.
- Environmental factors: While the indicators show good pH stability, other subtle environmental factors within organelles could potentially influence FRET signals, though the use of a non-responsive mutant helps address this.
- Future directions: The authors suggest that ATeams can be used to study energy metabolism, mitochondrial function, and evaluate the viability or toxicity of chemicals, opening up broad avenues for biological research. The tunable nature of the indicators also allows for adaptation to specific experimental needs.
Summary updated