Visual servoing with respect to complex objects

Andrew I. Comport, Omar Tahri, Éric Marchand, François Chaumette2004

TL;DR

This paper presents advancements in visual servoing for robots, enabling them to precisely control their movements relative to complex objects. They introduce two main approaches: one for objects with unknown shapes using image moments, and another for known 3D objects using a robust pose estimation and tracking algorithm. These methods allow robots to perform intricate tasks with greater accuracy and resilience to challenging conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Visual servoing is a crucial technique for robots to use camera feedback to guide their movements. Traditionally, visual servoing has been most effective with simple, well-defined objects or features. However, real-world robotic applications often involve complex objects with irregular shapes or objects whose precise 3D models are known but may be challenging to track in dynamic environments. The challenge lies in developing visual servoing strategies that are robust, accurate, and can handle these more complex scenarios, including variations in lighting, partial occlusions, and large initial displacements.

Methods

The paper proposes two primary methods:

  • Image Moments for Unknown Planar Objects: For planar objects where the exact shape isn't known beforehand, the authors leverage image moments. These moments provide a generic and geometrically intuitive representation of any object's shape, regardless of its complexity. By using a carefully selected set of moment invariants, they construct a control law that aims to decouple translational and rotational movements, leading to more stable and predictable behavior. This approach is particularly useful when dealing with objects that can be easily segmented into binary images.
  • Robust Model-Based Tracking for Known 3D Objects: When the 3D model of an object is available, the paper presents a real-time pose estimation and tracking algorithm. This method formulates the pose computation as a non-linear optimization problem, essentially controlling a "virtual camera" to align the projected 3D model with the observed image. Key contributions include:
  • Deriving analytical forms for interaction matrices related to complex visual features (ellipses, cylinders, etc.).
  • Employing robust M-estimation techniques to handle noisy data and outliers, making the tracking resilient to occlusions and lighting changes.
  • Utilizing a low-level contour tracking algorithm (Moving Edges) for efficient feature extraction.

Both approaches are integrated into an "eye-in-hand" robotic system, where the camera is mounted on the robot's end-effector.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments rely on real-world scenarios with objects captured by the robot's camera.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Image Moments as a Generic Feature: The use of image moments offers a powerful way to represent complex object shapes without requiring explicit prior knowledge of their geometry, making visual servoing applicable to a wider range of objects.
  • Decoupling Motion with Moments: By carefully selecting moment invariants, the authors demonstrate a method to achieve a near-decoupled control scheme, which is crucial for stability and avoiding singularities in visual servoing.
  • Robustness Through Model-Based Tracking: For known objects, a model-based approach combined with robust statistics (like M-estimation) significantly enhances resilience to real-world challenges such as occlusions and varying illumination.
  • Virtual Visual Servoing for Tracking: The concept of controlling a virtual camera to match the projected model to the observed image provides a unified framework for robust pose estimation and tracking.
  • Real-Time Performance: The methods are designed to operate at video rates (50Hz), making them suitable for real-time robotic control and augmented reality applications.

Key Results

  • Complex Motion Handling: The image moment-based method successfully controlled a robot through large translations and rotations, achieving fast convergence with minimal oscillations, outperforming traditional 2D visual servoing in terms of trajectory smoothness.
  • Robustness to Calibration Errors and Occlusion: Experiments showed that the image moment method remained stable even with significant errors in camera calibration and partial object occlusion, demonstrating its robustness.
  • Accurate Pose Estimation and Tracking: The model-based tracker demonstrated accurate positioning of objects in highly textured environments, even with temporary occlusions and lighting variations.
  • High-Speed Performance: The tracking algorithm operated below 10ms per frame, and positioning tasks were completed in under a second, with camera velocities reaching up to 23 cm/s and 85 dg/s.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The image moment method is primarily for planar objects.
  • While robust, the model-based tracker's performance can be affected by the quality of the 3D model and the initial pose estimation.
  • The paper mentions that improving the image tracker with sub-pixel accuracy could further enhance performance.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors suggest that improving the image tracker with sub-pixel accuracy could further enhance performance.
  • The paper implicitly points towards extending these robust tracking and servoing techniques to more dynamic and unpredictable environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents new advances in the field of visual servoing. More precisely, we consider the case where complex objects are observed by a camera. In a first part, planar objects of unknown shape are considered using image moments as input of the image-based control law. In the second part, a pose estimation and tracking algorithm is described to deal with real objects whose 3D model is known. For each case, experimental results obtained with an eye-in-hand system are presented.
BibTeX
@misc{comport2004visual,
  author = {Andrew I. Comport and Omar Tahri and Éric Marchand and François Chaumette},
  title = {{Visual servoing with respect to complex objects}},
  year = {2004},
}
Figure