Visual projections routed to the auditory pathway in ferrets: receptive fields of visual neurons in primary auditory cortex

Anna Wang Roe, Sarah L. Pallas, Young H. Kwon, Mriganka SurJournal of Neuroscience 1992 · DOI

Abstract

How does cortex that normally processes inputs from one sensory modality respond when provided with input from a different modality? We have addressed such a question with an experimental preparation in which retinal input is routed to the auditory pathway in ferrets. Following neonatal surgical manipulations, a specific population of retinal ganglion cells is induced to innervate the auditory thalamus and provides visual input to cells in auditory cortex (A1). We have now examined in detail the visual response properties of single cells in primary auditory cortex (A1) of these rewired animals and compared the responses to those in primary visual cortex (V1) of normal animals. Cells in A1 of rewired animals differed from cells in normal V1: they exhibited larger receptive field sizes and poorer visual responsivity, and responded with longer latencies to electrical stimulation of their inputs. However, striking similarities were also found. Like cells in normal V1, A1 cells in rewired animals exhibited orientation and direction selectivity and had simple and complex receptive field organizations. Furthermore, the degree of orientation and directional selectivity as well as the proportions of simple, complex, and nonoriented cells found in A1 and V1 were very similar. These results have significant implications for possible commonalities in intracortical processing circuits between sensory cortices, and for the role of inputs in specifying intracortical circuitry.

Introduction

The mammalian neocortex is divided into specialized areas for vision, hearing, and touch. A fundamental question in neuroscience is whether these areas are genetically pre-programmed for specific tasks or if they are flexible templates that adapt to sensory experience. This study explores whether the primary auditory cortex (A1), when provided with visual input, can develop the complex functional properties typically reserved for the primary visual cortex (V1).

Methods

The researchers used neonatal ferrets, whose brains exhibit high plasticity at birth. By removing the natural targets of retinal axons (superior colliculus and lateral geniculate nucleus) and denervating the auditory thalamus (medial geniculate nucleus, MGN), they induced retinal axons to innervate the MGN. This "rewiring" forced visual signals to be processed by the auditory pathway. In adulthood, single-unit electrophysiology was used to record from neurons in the rewired A1 and normal V1 during visual stimulation with moving bars of light.

Functional Convergence

The most striking finding was the functional convergence between rewired A1 and normal V1. Rewired A1 neurons developed "Simple" and "Complex" receptive fields, hallmarks of standard visual processing. The proportions of these cell types were remarkably similar: approximately 50% complex, 25% simple, and 25% non-oriented in both A1 and V1. Furthermore, orientation and direction selectivity indices in rewired A1 were statistically indistinguishable from those in normal V1.

Quantitative Differences in Processing

Despite the functional similarities, A1 was not a perfect replica of V1. Significant differences were observed in receptive field (RF) size and response timing.

Figure 3: Distribution of receptive field diameters in normal V1 (white bars) and rewired A1 (black bars).

As shown in Figure 3, the mean diameter of receptive fields in rewired A1 was 10.9°, nearly three times larger than the 3.9° found in normal V1. This suggests that while A1 can process visual information, the spatial resolution is lower, likely due to the specific population of retinal ganglion cells (W-cells) that innervate the MGN.

Figure 6: Latency of visual responses to electrical stimulation. Panel A compares normal V1 (white) to rewired A1 (black).

Temporal processing also differed. A1 neurons responded to electrical stimulation of the optic chiasm with a mean latency of 6.8 ms, significantly slower than the 4.4 ms observed in V1 (Figure 6A). Additionally, A1 neurons generally showed poorer visual responsivity compared to V1.

Conclusion

These results support a "Universal Template" hypothesis for the neocortex. The ability of A1 to develop orientation and direction selectivity suggests that the fundamental processing circuits of the mammalian cortex are similar across modalities and are significantly shaped by the statistical structure of their inputs. The observed limitations in A1—larger RFs and longer latencies—are likely a product of the specific input source (retinal W-cells) rather than an inherent limitation of the auditory cortex itself. This study provides powerful evidence that cortical specialization is a product of sensory experience and input-driven plasticity.

Summary updated

Abstract

How does cortex that normally processes inputs from one sensory modality respond when provided with input from a different modality? We have addressed such a question with an experimental preparation in which retinal input is routed to the auditory pathway in ferrets. Following neonatal surgical manipulations, a specific population of retinal ganglion cells is induced to innervate the auditory thalamus and provides visual input to cells in auditory cortex (Sur et al., 1988). We have now examined in detail the visual response properties of single cells in primary auditory cortex (A1) of these rewired animals and compared the responses to those in primary visual cortex (V1) of normal animals. Cells in A1 of rewired animals differed from cells in normal V1: they exhibited larger receptive field sizes and poorer visual responsivity, and responded with longer latencies to electrical stimulation of their inputs. However, striking similarities were also found. Like cells in normal V1, A1 cells in rewired animals exhibited orientation and direction selectivity and had simple and complex receptive field organizations. Furthermore, the degree of orientation and directional selectivity as well as the proportions of simple, complex, and nonoriented cells found in A1 and V1 were very similar. These results have significant implications for possible commonalities in intracortical processing circuits between sensory cortices, and for the role of inputs in specifying intracortical circuitry.
BibTeX
@article{roe1992visual,
  author = {Anna Wang Roe and Sarah L. Pallas and Young H. Kwon and Mriganka Sur},
  title = {{Visual projections routed to the auditory pathway in ferrets: receptive fields of visual neurons in primary auditory cortex}},
  journal = {Journal of Neuroscience},
  year = {1992},
  doi = {10.1523/jneurosci.12-09-03651.1992},
}
Figure