TL;DR
This paper utilizes bibliometric tools and knowledge graphs to map the sprawling landscape of Intangible Cultural Heritage (ICH) research. By analyzing over 86,000 papers from Chinese and international databases, the authors identify a shift from basic preservation to complex "living" inheritance, while highlighting a significant divide between China’s qualitative, policy-driven focus and the international community’s emphasis on design and quantitative modeling.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
Intangible Cultural Heritage (ICH)—the traditions, performing arts, and rituals that define a culture—is notoriously difficult to study because it is "living" and interdisciplinary. Since UNESCO’s 2003 Convention, research has exploded across history, geography, tourism, and anthropology.
However, this rapid growth has created a "data deluge." Traditional literature reviews struggle to synthesize tens of thousands of papers, leaving researchers in the dark about global trends, emerging hotspots, or gaps in the field. This paper seeks to clear that fog by providing a visual, data-driven "birds-eye view" of how ICH research has evolved and where it is heading.
Methods
The authors employ a mixed-method approach combining bibliometrics (the statistical analysis of books and articles) and content analysis. They use two primary visualization tools to construct knowledge graphs:
- CiteSpace: Used for the Chinese dataset to analyze "Time Zone" views, which show how keywords emerge and cluster over time.
- VOSviewer: Used for the international dataset to generate keyword density and co-occurrence maps, highlighting the "centrality" or importance of specific research nodes.
This approach allows the authors to move beyond simple citation counts to see the relationships between concepts, such as how "rural revitalization" connects to "heritage protection."
Datasets
The study draws from two massive academic repositories:
- CNKI (China National Knowledge Infrastructure): 81,426 documents (1997–2023). This represents the largest dataset of Chinese-language academic output.
- Scopus: 5,041 documents (up to December 2023). This provides the international context for ICH research.
Key Insights and Ideas
- The Three Stages of Chinese Research: The authors identify a clear trajectory in China: a "Slow Start" (1997–2004), "Rapid Growth" (2004–2010) following the UNESCO convention, and "Stable Development" (2010–Present) where the focus has shifted toward systematic improvement.
- Protection vs. Design: A major "aha moment" is the divergence in research priorities. In China, the dominant theme is Protection (24.03%), often linked to government-led initiatives like "Rural Revitalization." Internationally, however, there is a much stronger emphasis on Design and Community, treating ICH as a resource for modern creative industries rather than just a relic to be guarded.
- The "Living" Shift: Recent research (2020–2023) shows a move toward "Active Inheritance." Instead of just archiving traditions in museums, scholars are exploring "Short Videos," "Digital Protection," and "New Media" to keep these traditions relevant to younger generations.
- Global Synchronicity: Despite different focuses, international research trends in China closely align with those in European countries (Italy, UK, Spain), reflecting a high degree of synchronization in the global academic discourse on heritage.
Key Results
- China Leads in Volume: On the international Scopus database, China is the most prolific contributor, accounting for 20.47% of all ICH publications, followed by Italy (8.63%) and the UK (7.48%).
- Hotspot Distribution: In the Chinese (CNKI) dataset, the top research areas are Intangible Heritage Protection (24.03%), Rural Revitalization (10.71%), and Visual Symbols (10.29%).
- Methodological Divide: The study finds that Chinese research remains heavily qualitative and applied, whereas international research is increasingly quantitative and innovative in its modeling of heritage data.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors acknowledge several hurdles for the field:
- Weak International Cooperation: There is a lack of deep collaboration between domestic (Chinese) and foreign institutions. Academic exchanges need to move beyond citation to active joint research.
- Gaps in Application: While there is plenty of theory, there is a shortage of in-depth case studies on "innovative communication" and "design application"—essentially, how to actually sell or brand ICH in a modern market without losing its soul.
- Need for Quantitative Rigor: The authors suggest that Chinese researchers need to adopt more quantitative methods to match international standards of innovation.
Summary updated