VISION - Vienna survey in Orion. III. Young stellar objects in Orion A

Josefa E. Großschedl, J. Alves, P. S. Teixeira, H. Bouy, Jan Forbrich, C. J. Lada, Stefan Meingast, A. Hacar, Joana Ascenso, Christine Ackerl, Birgit Hasenberger, R. Köhler, Karolina Kubiak, Irati Larreina, Lorenz Linhardt, M. Lombardi, Torsten MöllerUniversity 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents the most comprehensive catalog of young stellar objects (YSOs) in the Orion A star-forming region to date, combining new VISTA near-infrared data with archival mid- and far-infrared observations. This enhanced catalog refines YSO classifications and reveals that "flat-spectrum" YSOs are likely a distinct, younger evolutionary phase, rather than an artifact of viewing angle or extinction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the early stages of star formation requires accurately identifying and classifying young stellar objects (YSOs) within star-forming regions. However, existing YSO catalogs often suffer from contamination (e.g., background galaxies, nebulosities), incompleteness due to limited survey coverage, and ambiguities in classifying YSOs, particularly the "flat-spectrum" class. The flat-spectrum class, defined by a specific spectral index, has been a subject of debate, with some suggesting it represents a transitional phase between protostars and pre-main-sequence stars with disks, while others propose it could be an artifact of disk inclination or extinction. This paper aims to address these issues by creating a more complete and robust YSO catalog for the nearby Orion A cloud, enabling a better understanding of YSO evolution and the nature of flat-spectrum sources.

Methods

The authors leverage the deep, wide-field VISTA near-infrared survey (VISION) of Orion A, combined with archival data from Spitzer (IRAC, MIPS) and Herschel (PACS), and the all-sky WISE survey. Their approach involves:

  • Refined Source Selection: Using a combination of near- and mid-infrared color-color and color-magnitude diagrams, along with visual inspection and information from literature, they re-evaluate existing YSO catalogs (MGM and FFA16) to identify and remove false positives.
  • New Candidate Identification: They develop and apply new selection criteria using VISTA, Spitzer, and WISE data to identify YSO candidates in regions not previously covered or analyzed with sufficient sensitivity. This includes specific strategies for dealing with WISE data, which is known for its lower resolution and potential for contamination.
  • YSO Classification: YSOs are classified based on de-reddened mid-infrared spectral indices, with careful consideration of multiple spectral index ranges and visual inspection of images to confirm protostellar features like outflows.
  • Spatial Distribution Analysis: They analyze the spatial distribution of the classified YSO classes (protostars, flat-spectrum sources, and disks) relative to regions of high dust column-density (traced by Herschel) to infer evolutionary relationships.

Datasets

The primary datasets used in this study are:

  • VISTA Near-Infrared Survey (VISION): Provides deep J, H, and Ks photometry across a large area of Orion A (~18.3 deg²).
  • Spitzer Space Telescope Data: Archival IRAC (3.6, 4.5, 5.8, 8.0 µm) and MIPS (24 µm) photometry.
  • Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer (WISE): AllWISE data (3.4, 4.6, 12, 22 µm) for extending coverage beyond the Spitzer IRAC region.
  • Herschel Space Observatory Data: PACS photometry (70, 100, 160 µm) and dust column-density maps.
  • Ancillary Data: Optical data from Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) and Pan-STARRS, and X-ray observations from XMM-Newton and Chandra.
  • Existing YSO Catalogs: MGM (Megeath et al. 2012, 2016) and FFA16 (Furlan et al. 2016) are used as a basis for re-evaluation and comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Improved Catalog Completeness and Purity: By combining VISTA's sensitivity and wide coverage with archival data and sophisticated selection methods, the authors have created a significantly more complete and cleaner YSO catalog for Orion A.
  • Debunking the "Viewing Angle" Hypothesis for Flat-Spectrum Sources: The analysis of spatial distribution reveals that flat-spectrum sources are statistically more concentrated in regions of high dust column-density compared to Class II (disk) sources. This strongly suggests they represent a distinct, younger evolutionary phase rather than being simply Class II sources viewed at a particular inclination.
  • WISE Survey's Value in Star-Forming Regions: The study demonstrates the effectiveness of the all-sky WISE survey, when combined with deep near-infrared data, for identifying YSOs, particularly in low-mass star-forming regions like L1641, recovering about 59% of known YSOs.
  • Contamination is a Persistent Challenge: Despite rigorous methods, the paper highlights that even with advanced data and analysis, residual contamination from background galaxies and nebulosities remains a challenge, especially in crowded and bright regions like the ONC.

Key Results

  • New Catalog: The paper presents a new catalog of 2980 YSO candidates in Orion A.
  • New Candidates: 274 new YSO candidates were identified, including 6 protostars, 8 flat-spectrum sources, and 260 pre-main-sequence stars with disks.
  • Classification Breakdown: The final catalog comprises 188 protostars (Class 0/I), 185 flat-spectrum sources, and 2607 disk candidates (Class II/III).
  • Contamination Estimates: False positive rates are estimated at ~6.4% for previously known protostars and ~2.3% for pre-main-sequence stars with disks.
  • Spatial Distribution Findings: Protostars are strongly concentrated in high dust column-density regions, flat-spectrum sources show a significant correlation, and disk sources are more dispersed.
  • WISE Recovery Rate: The VISTA/WISE selection method recovers about 59% of known YSOs in the low-mass star-forming region L1641.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Contamination: While efforts were made to minimize false positives, residual contamination from unresolved galaxies, AGNs, and AGB stars is still possible, particularly for faint or uncertain sources.
  • Class III YSOs: The study primarily focuses on YSOs with IR excess, meaning that the majority of Class III YSOs (those without significant IR excess) are not included.
  • Flat-Spectrum Source Ambiguity: While the spatial distribution strongly supports a distinct evolutionary phase for flat-spectrum sources, detailed SED modeling and follow-up observations are still needed for a definitive conclusion and for all uncertain sources.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that detailed SED modeling and follow-up observations are crucial for a complete understanding of YSO evolution and for clarifying the nature of uncertain candidates. Further investigation into the role of massive stars in dispersing disks and the influence of stellar luminosity on YSO classification is also implied.

Summary updated

Abstract

We have extended and refined the existing young stellar object (YSO) catalogs for the Orion A molecular cloud, the closest massive star-forming region to Earth. This updated catalog is driven by the large spatial coverage (18.3 deg$^2$, $\sim$950 pc$^2$), seeing limited resolution ($\sim$0.7$"$), and sensitivity ($K_s<19$ mag) of the ESO-VISTA near-infrared survey of the Orion A cloud (VISION). Combined with archival mid- to far-infrared data, the VISTA data allow for a refined and more robust source selection. We estimate that among previously known protostars and pre-main-sequence stars with disks, source contamination levels (false positives) are at least $\sim$6.4% and $\sim$2.3%, respectively, mostly due to background galaxies and nebulosities. We identify 274 new YSO candidates using VISTA/Spitzer based selections within previously analyzed regions, and VISTA/WISE based selections to add sources in the surroundings, beyond previously analyzed regions. The WISE selection method recovers about 59% of the known YSOs in Orion A's low-mass star-forming part L1641, which shows what can be achieved by the all-sky WISE survey in combination with deep near-infrared data in regions without the influence of massive stars. The new catalog contains 2980 YSOs, which were classified based on the de-reddened mid-infrared spectral index into 188 protostars, 185 flat-spectrum sources, and 2607 pre-main-sequence stars with circumstellar disks. We find a statistically significant difference in the spatial distribution of the three evolutionary classes with respect to regions of high dust column-density, confirming that flat-spectrum sources are at a younger evolutionary phase compared to Class IIs, and are not a sub-sample seen at particular viewing angles.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{groschedl2018vision,
  author = {Josefa E. Großschedl and J. Alves and P. S. Teixeira and H. Bouy and Jan Forbrich and C. J. Lada and Stefan Meingast and A. Hacar and Joana Ascenso and Christine Ackerl and Birgit Hasenberger and R. Köhler and Karolina Kubiak and Irati Larreina and Lorenz Linhardt and M. Lombardi and Torsten Möller},
  title = {{VISION - Vienna survey in Orion. III. Young stellar objects in Orion A}},
  booktitle = {University},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.48550/arxiv.1810.00878},
}
Figure