Visibility and its dynamics in a PDE based implicit framework

Y. Tsai, L.-t. Cheng, Stanley Osher, Paul Burchard, Guillermo SapiroJournal of Computational Physics 2004 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel implicit framework for computing visibility, representing objects and visibility regions using level set functions. This approach elegantly handles complex object shapes and dynamic scenarios (moving observers or objects) by formulating visibility as a partial differential equation (PDE), offering a unified and efficient solution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Determining visibility – what parts of a scene are visible from a given viewpoint – is a fundamental problem in computer graphics, robotics, and computer vision. Traditional methods often rely on explicit representations of objects (like triangulated meshes), which can be computationally expensive to convert from implicit data and struggle with topological changes (objects merging or breaking apart). Furthermore, handling dynamic scenes where either the observer or the objects are moving adds significant complexity. This paper aims to provide a unified, efficient, and robust framework for both static and dynamic visibility problems, working directly with implicit representations of objects.

Methods

The core of the paper's contribution lies in its implicit framework using level set methods.

  • Implicit Representation: Objects (occluders) are represented by a level set function $\phi$, where the zero level set defines the object's surface.
  • PDE Formulation: The visibility problem is reformulated as a boundary value problem for a first-order partial differential equation (PDE). The solution to this PDE, denoted by $\psi$, represents the visibility map. This PDE captures the "causality" of visibility: if a point is occluded, all points further away along the same ray are also occluded.
  • Implicit Ray Tracing: Instead of explicit ray casting, the authors develop an "implicit ray tracing" algorithm that propagates visibility information along characteristic curves of the PDE. This is achieved through a "star-shaped" updating sequence on the grid.
  • Multi-level Algorithm: To improve efficiency, a multi-resolution algorithm is proposed. This involves an initial coarse grid pass, followed by adaptive refinement in regions where visibility is uncertain.
  • Dynamic Visibility: The framework is extended to dynamic scenarios by deriving motion laws for "horizons" (boundaries of visible regions on surfaces) and "terminators" (boundaries of shadow regions). These dynamics are also handled using level set evolution.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on developing a general framework and demonstrates its application with synthetic examples and a "city model" and "Grand Canyon" elevation data.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Unified Framework: Representing visibility as a PDE solution within a level set framework provides a single, elegant approach for both static and dynamic scenes, and for complex object topologies.
  • Implicit Ray Tracing Efficiency: Propagating visibility information implicitly via PDE characteristics is more efficient than traditional explicit ray casting, especially for complex scenes.
  • Dynamic Visibility as PDE Evolution: The dynamics of shadow boundaries (horizons and terminators) can be naturally described and computed by evolving level set functions, mirroring the static visibility computation.
  • Emergence Time Estimation: The framework allows for estimating when a hidden object will become visible, a crucial feature for applications like surveillance or navigation.

Key Results

  • The paper presents a fast implicit ray tracing algorithm that is independent of grid geometry and easily parallelizable.
  • A multi-resolution extension of this algorithm is developed for near-optimal efficiency.
  • The framework accurately captures shadow boundaries, including horizons and terminators.
  • Explicit formulas are derived for the motion of horizons and terminators, revealing relationships between motion and local/global geometry.
  • The method is demonstrated to handle complex scenarios, including nonconvex objects and moving vantage points, with visual examples provided.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Discontinuous Coefficients: The paper notes that much study is needed for PDEs with discontinuous coefficients, which can arise in visibility problems.
  • Computational Cost for High Resolution: While multi-resolution improves efficiency, achieving very high resolutions might still be computationally intensive.
  • Error Estimation: The multi-resolution approach requires a priori or a posteriori error estimates, which are mentioned as a topic for future work.
  • Non-uniform Media: The authors are currently working on extending their solutions to non-uniform media and occluders that change shapes over time.
  • Navigation and Robotics: Applications in navigation and robotics, particularly "pursuer-evader" problems, are identified as future research directions.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{tsai2004visibility,
  author = {Y. Tsai and L.-T. Cheng and Stanley Osher and Paul Burchard and Guillermo Sapiro},
  title = {{Visibility and its dynamics in a PDE based implicit framework}},
  journal = {Journal of Computational Physics},
  year = {2004},
  doi = {10.1016/j.jcp.2004.02.015},
}
Figure