TL;DR
This paper reviews existing experimental data and theoretical models for the transport properties (viscosity, thermal conductivity, and diffusion coefficients) of CO2-mixtures relevant to Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS). It highlights significant gaps in available data, particularly for liquid mixtures and certain gas mixtures under high-pressure conditions, and evaluates the performance of various models, suggesting areas for future research to improve CCS process design and efficiency.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The efficient and safe design of Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS) processes hinges on accurate knowledge of the thermo-physical properties of the fluids involved, especially CO2 and its mixtures with various impurities. These properties, including transport properties like viscosity, thermal conductivity, and diffusion coefficients, are crucial for accurately sizing equipment, optimizing process conditions, and ensuring operational safety. However, the complex mixtures encountered in CCS chains, coupled with the wide range of operating temperatures and pressures, mean that existing data and models are often insufficient. This paper addresses the critical need for a comprehensive review and evaluation of the available knowledge on these transport properties to identify gaps and guide future research efforts.
Methods
This paper is primarily a literature review and critical analysis. The authors systematically surveyed existing research on the transport properties of CO2-mixtures. They evaluated theoretical models based on kinetic gas theory (e.g., Chapman-Enskog theory) and corresponding states principles, as well as empirical correlations. The performance of these models was assessed by comparing their predictions against available experimental data across various temperature, pressure, and composition ranges relevant to CCS. The authors also compiled and summarized experimental data, highlighting the ranges covered and the associated uncertainties.
Datasets
The paper does not introduce new datasets. Instead, it compiles and analyzes data from numerous previously published experimental studies on the transport properties of CO2-mixtures. These datasets span a wide range of binary and multi-component mixtures, temperatures, and pressures. The authors also reference existing databases and compilations of experimental data.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Significant Data Gaps Exist: A major takeaway is the substantial lack of experimental data for many CO2-mixtures, especially for liquid phases and for gas mixtures under high-pressure conditions relevant to CCS.
- Pre-1970 Data May Be Unreliable: The authors emphasize that a significant portion of the available experimental data was collected before 1970, a period when measurement techniques were less accurate. This raises concerns about the reliability of older data and its suitability for calibrating modern models.
- Model Performance Varies Widely: Theoretical models show varying degrees of success. While some models (e.g., based on Rigorous Kinetic Theory) offer better extrapolative capabilities, empirical models often require adaptation to specific experimental ranges.
- Pressure Dependency is Crucial and Understudied: The pressure dependence of transport properties, particularly near the critical point, is significant but has not been extensively studied for many mixtures. This is a critical oversight for CCS applications operating at elevated pressures.
- Impurity Effects are Poorly Understood: The impact of impurities other than water in liquid CO2 on transport properties is largely unknown, posing a challenge for modeling real-world CCS scenarios.
Key Results
- Viscosity: Chapman-Enskog theory generally provides good predictions for gas-phase viscosities at atmospheric pressure (deviations < 2%), but deviations increase with temperature and pressure. Corresponding states methods show promise but require more evaluation for CO2-rich mixtures.
- Thermal Conductivity: Rigorous Kinetic Theory (RKT) and empirical models yield deviations of 2.2-9% at atmospheric pressure and moderate temperatures. Empirical models' predictive ability outside their tested range is questionable.
- Diffusion Coefficients: Empirical models like Fuller-Schettler-Giddings (FSG) show significant inaccuracies (up to 21%) for CO2/H2O, partly due to the age of the underlying data. RKT-based models often predict within experimental uncertainty for many mixtures.
- Liquid Mixtures: Experimental data for liquid mixtures are scarce, with most available data limited to CO2/H2O(/NaCl). The effect of other impurities is largely unknown.
Limitations and Future Work
The authors explicitly identify several limitations and suggest future research directions:
- Experimental Data Scarcity: The most significant limitation is the lack of experimental data for many critical mixtures (e.g., CO2/H2S, CO2/NH3, CO2/COS, and liquid mixtures with impurities other than water) and across wide temperature and pressure ranges.
- Data Reliability: The accuracy of older experimental data (pre-1970) is a concern, necessitating new, high-accuracy measurements.
- Pressure Dependency: More research is needed to understand and model the pressure dependency of transport properties, especially near critical points and at high pressures relevant to CCS.
- Model Evaluation: Further evaluation of corresponding states methods for viscosity and RKT-based models for diffusion coefficients is required.
- Liquid Phase Modeling: Developing accurate models for liquid-phase transport properties, potentially using corresponding states approaches, is crucial, given their importance in pipeline transport and storage.
- Impurity Effects: Investigating the impact of various impurities on liquid CO2 properties is a critical area for future work.
- New Regression for Empirical Models: A new regression of empirical models, like Fuller's equation, using more recent and accurate data could be beneficial.
Summary updated