Virtual surgical education for core surgical trainees in the Yorkshire deanery during the COVID-19 pandemic

Ryan Laloo, Andrea Giorga, Andrew Williams, Chandra Shekhar Biyani, Marina YiasemidouScottish 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

The COVID-19 pandemic forced a rapid shift to online surgical education for core trainees. This study found that a fully online program was feasible and well-received, with trainees preferring short, interactive, consultant-led sessions. The findings offer valuable insights for improving future virtual surgical training.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The COVID-19 pandemic presented a significant challenge to traditional surgical training. Social distancing measures and the suspension of non-urgent surgeries led to a reduction in face-to-face lectures, practical teaching, and operative theatre time. This disruption threatened the continuity and quality of surgical education for core surgical trainees (CSTs). The paper addresses the need to adapt surgical training methodologies to an online format, specifically investigating the feasibility and reception of a fully virtual teaching program for CSTs in the Yorkshire deanery.

Methods

The study implemented a fully online teaching program for CSTs, consisting of twenty sessions delivered over seven weeks. These sessions were either conducted live via Zoom or pre-recorded and uploaded to Google Classroom and YouTube. A consultant surgeon or senior surgical registrar supervised most sessions. Feedback was collected through voluntary, anonymized online questionnaires (Google Forms) administered after each session and for the overall program. YouTube Studio analytics were also used to track viewing patterns. The teaching content aligned with the Joint Committee of Surgical Training (JCST) curriculum and MRCS examinations.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study focused on collecting feedback from trainees and analyzing YouTube viewing data, rather than using pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Feasibility and Reception: A fully online surgical education program is not only achievable but also positively received by core surgical trainees, offering a viable alternative during disruptive periods.
  • Preference for Brevity and Interactivity: Trainees strongly favored shorter, weekly sessions (30 minutes to 1 hour) that were interactive and procedure-based, rather than lengthy, infrequent ones.
  • Consultant-Led Content is Key: The presence and involvement of senior surgeons (consultants) were highly valued, contributing to the perceived quality and relevance of the teaching.
  • Recorded Sessions Offer Flexibility: The availability of recorded sessions was a significant advantage, allowing trainees to access content at their convenience, especially when work commitments interfered with live attendance.
  • ISCP Portfolio as a Motivator: The requirement to document reflections on teaching sessions in the ISCP portfolio emerged as a significant motivator for trainee engagement with the program.
  • Peak Viewing Correlates with Deadlines: YouTube analytics revealed a surge in views just before the ISCP portfolio deadline, highlighting the practical, evidence-gathering aspect of the training.

Key Results

  • Overall Satisfaction: 89.9% of trainees were satisfied with the teaching series.
  • Session Usefulness: 85% found each session very useful, and 92% indicated that sessions fulfilled learning objectives.
  • Series Usefulness: 86% found the overall teaching series useful.
  • Platform Satisfaction: 93% of trainees were very satisfied with the platforms used (Google Classroom, Google Forms, YouTube).
  • Session Duration Preference: 79% of trainees preferred short, weekly sessions (30 minutes to 1 hour).
  • YouTube Analytics: The program generated 1100 views and 108.3 hours of total watch time. The highest peak in views (19% of total) occurred the weekend before the ISCP portfolio deadline.
  • Device Usage: The majority of trainees accessed the YouTube channel via computer (59.9%) or mobile phone (30.6%).
  • Content Preferences: Trainees requested more consultant-led, procedure-based sessions and a wider range of surgical specialties beyond General and Plastic Surgery.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Voluntary Participation: The program was voluntary, and while this facilitated learning, it may have led to a lower survey response rate. The ISCP portfolio requirement was a primary motivator, but attendance was not formally recorded.
  • Limited Senior Surgeon Availability: During the peak of the pandemic, there was a challenge in securing the participation of more experienced senior surgeons.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Increasing Engagement: Exploring ways to increase trainee engagement, such as issuing certificates of attendance and formally recording attendance.
  • Expanding Senior Faculty: Engaging more senior speakers through Royal College of Surgeons college tutors to enhance the quality and relevance of sessions.
  • Improving Online Teaching: Utilizing trainee feedback to refine and improve regional and national online surgical teaching programs, aiming to maximize training opportunities lost during the pandemic.
  • Incorporating Practical Skills: Continuing to incorporate designated practical skills sessions and exploring the use of simulation models to bridge the gap left by the lack of hands-on training.

Summary updated

Abstract

An entirely online teaching programme is feasible and well-received by CSTs. Trainees preferred live, interactive, procedure-based, consultant-led sessions lasting approximately thirty minutes to one hour and covering a myriad of surgical specialties. This feedback can be used to improve future online surgical teaching regionally and nationally in order to gain training opportunities lost during the pandemic.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{laloo2020virtual,
  author = {Ryan Laloo and Andrea Giorga and Andrew Williams and Chandra Shekhar Biyani and Marina Yiasemidou},
  title = {{Virtual surgical education for core surgical trainees in the Yorkshire deanery during the COVID-19 pandemic}},
  booktitle = {Scottish},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1177/0036933020951927},
}
Figure