Abstract
This paper presents a proactive methodology for factory design by integrating ergonomic evaluation into virtual production line simulations. Utilizing the Siemens Tecnomatix platform and ergonomic theories like OWAS and BSHA, the study demonstrates how to identify and mitigate musculoskeletal disorder (MSD) risks during the planning phase. By simulating human movements and physical stress levels before physical installation, manufacturers can optimize both worker safety and production efficiency.
Introduction
In traditional manufacturing, ergonomic issues are often discovered only after a production line is operational. When workers suffer from musculoskeletal disorders (MSDs) due to poor workstation design, companies face high costs from sick leave, staff turnover, and reduced product quality. Fixing these problems post-hoc is expensive and disruptive.
The authors address the challenge of "ergonomic-blind" digital planning. While engineers are proficient at optimizing for machine efficiency and throughput, they often lack the tools to evaluate the "human element" in the same virtual environment. This paper seeks to bridge that gap by providing a methodology to simulate human movements and calculate physical stress levels during the design stage.
Methodology
The researchers utilized the Siemens Tecnomatix platform (specifically Process Designer and Process Simulate) to build a virtual twin of a U-shaped production line. Their evaluation methodology relies on two core ergonomic theories:
- OWAS (Ovako Working Posture Analysis System): A system that categorizes the "fatigue grade" of a posture (from 1 to 4) based on the positions of the back, arms, legs, and the weight being handled. Grade 1 represents a normal posture, while Grade 4 indicates a high risk of serious injury.
- BSHA (Burandt-Schultetus Hand-Arm Force Analysis): A quantitative method to calculate the maximum permissible load ($F_{per}$) for a worker. It factors in gender, age, training level, and specific arm angles to determine if a manual task is safe.
The workflow involves creating 3D models of the environment, defining the "human" movements (using "Auto Grasp" and path editing), running the simulation, and then generating automated OWAS and BSHA reports to flag "hot spots" of physical strain. The study utilized standard anthropometric models and a custom dataset of operating times for five specific workstations.
Key Insights and Results
A central finding of the study is that the "digital human" should be treated as a primary design constraint, alongside cycle time and cost. The simulation revealed that "Operator 1" in the original design had a posture grade of 3, indicating a significant risk of injury. Furthermore, BSHA reports showed that the ratio of actual load to maximum permissible load reached 70% during certain operations.
By utilizing the simulation to test small changes, the researchers found that a simple 50 cm increase in the height of a storage point and workstation could move a worker from a high-risk posture to a safe one. These optimizations were successfully integrated into the overall production timing, proving that safety and efficiency can be optimized simultaneously.
Conclusion
While the virtual simulation approach offers a powerful tool for proactive ergonomic design, the authors identify several areas for improvement. Current human models in standard software are often based on Western populations, which may lead to inaccuracies for other global populations, such as Chinese workers. Additionally, the process of manual posture correction remains labor-intensive. Future work should focus on establishing localized body posture resource bases and developing automated posture correction algorithms to further streamline the digital manufacturing workflow.
Summary updated