Virtual reality in the management of patients with low back and neck pain: a retrospective analysis of 82 people treated solely in the metaverse

Eran Orr, Tal Arbel, Miki Levy, Yaron Sela, Omer Weissberger, Omer Liran, Jeremy LewisArchives 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This study explores the feasibility and effectiveness of using virtual reality (VR) delivered entirely within the metaverse for managing low back pain (LBP) and neck pain disorders (NPD). The findings suggest this approach is safe, well-tolerated, and can lead to significant improvements in pain and disability, offering a novel avenue for remote healthcare delivery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Low back pain (LBP) and neck pain disorders (NPD) are major global health issues, contributing significantly to years lived with disability. Despite extensive research and established guidelines, disability rates for these conditions have not decreased in decades. Traditional face-to-face physiotherapy is resource-intensive, and while telemedicine has emerged as an alternative, there's a growing interest in more immersive and engaging remote treatment modalities. This paper addresses the challenge of providing accessible, effective, and engaging rehabilitation for LBP and NPD by investigating the potential of virtual reality (VR) delivered exclusively within the metaverse, aiming to reduce the reliance on physical clinics and potentially improve patient adherence and outcomes.

Methods

This study employed a retrospective analysis of health and medical records from 82 participants who received VR rehabilitation for LBP and/or NPD between July 2020 and May 2022. The treatment was delivered entirely within the metaverse by licensed clinicians using VR applications. The researchers collected data on patient-reported outcomes (disability indices) and objective impairment measurements derived from the VR system itself (e.g., range of motion, speed, accuracy). The study aimed to assess the feasibility, safety (presence of side effects or adverse events), completeness of outcome data collection, and early evidence of beneficial effects. Statistical analysis involved paired t-tests to compare pre- and post-treatment scores for various outcome measures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized existing health and medical records from participants treated at XRHealth clinics.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Metaverse as a Viable Healthcare Platform: The study demonstrates that the metaverse can serve as a functional platform for delivering structured rehabilitation, moving beyond simple telemedicine to a more immersive experience.
  • Patient Engagement and Adherence: A significant portion of the VR sessions were conducted independently by participants, suggesting that the technology is accessible and engaging enough to promote self-management and adherence to treatment protocols.
  • Objective Data Collection: The VR system's ability to automatically collect detailed impairment data (e.g., movement quality, speed, accuracy) offers a significant advantage over traditional methods, potentially reducing clinician burden and providing richer insights into patient progress.
  • External Focus in Motor Learning: The paper speculates that VR's inherent external focus (directing attention to the virtual environment or task) might enhance motor learning and automaticity, potentially leading to better outcomes compared to traditional therapy's internal focus.
  • Disrupting Negative Expectations: The authors propose that VR might help disrupt negative pain-related expectations and beliefs by providing novel, engaging experiences that shift attention away from symptoms.

Key Results

  • Safety: No side effects, adverse events, or serious adverse events were reported by the 82 participants during VR treatment.
  • Feasibility and Data Completeness: The study successfully collected a substantial amount of data across multiple outcome measures and time points, indicating that remote data collection in the metaverse is feasible.
  • Patient-Reported Outcomes:
    • Significant reduction in low back pain disability (Modified Oswestry Low Back Pain Disability Index) by 17.8% (p<0.001).
  • Significant reduction in neck pain disability (Neck Disability Index) by 23.2% (p=0.02).
  • A trend towards improvement was observed in nine out of eleven patient-reported outcome measures.
  • Impairment Measurements:
    • Significant improvements were recorded in 13 out of 35 impairment outcome measurements, including lower pain levels, faster arm movement response times, and improved neck rotation range of motion.
  • A significant improvement was noted in the sit-to-stand test (22.8% improvement, p<0.001).
  • While not always statistically significant, the trend across most remaining measures indicated improving health and function.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Retrospective Design: The study's retrospective nature is subject to limitations such as potential selection bias, recall bias, and lack of blinding.
  • No Control Group: The absence of a non-treatment comparison group makes it difficult to definitively attribute improvements solely to the VR intervention, as natural improvement or placebo effects could be contributing factors.
  • Uncontrolled Variables: Factors like age, duration of symptoms, and clinician education were not fully controlled for, potentially influencing outcomes.
  • Clinical Significance: While statistical significance was achieved for some measures, the clinical significance of these changes needs further investigation in future prospective trials.
  • Future Research: The authors emphasize the need for prospective research, including multiple baseline case studies, cohort studies, and randomized clinical trials, to better understand the clinical findings and establish the reliability and validity of VR-based impairment measurements. Further investigation into the role of VR in disrupting negative expectations and its comparison with traditional therapy environments is also recommended.

Summary updated

Abstract

The data suggest that this method of providing exercise therapy was feasible, and safe (no adverse events reported), that complete reports were obtained from a large selection of patients, and that software acquired outcomes were obtainable over a range of time points. Further prospective research is necessary to better understand our clinical findings.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{orr2023virtual,
  author = {Eran Orr and Tal Arbel and Miki Levy and Yaron Sela and Omer Weissberger and Omer Liran and Jeremy Lewis},
  title = {{Virtual reality in the management of patients with low back and neck pain: a retrospective analysis of 82 people treated solely in the metaverse}},
  booktitle = {Archives},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1186/s40945-023-00163-8},
}
Figure