Virtual meetings promise to eliminate the geographical and administrative barriers and increase accessibility, diversity, and inclusivity

Juncheng Wu, Anushka Rajesh, Yu-Ning Huang, Karishma Chhugani, Rajesh Acharya, Kerui Peng, Ruth Johnson, Andrada Fiscutean, Carla Daniela Robles‐Espinoza, Francisco M. De La Vega, Riyue Bao, Serghei MangulbioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

The COVID-19 pandemic forced a rapid shift to virtual academic conferences, and this study investigates its impact. The findings show that virtual formats significantly increased participation from underrepresented groups and expanded geographic reach, but also highlighted challenges in social engagement and networking. The authors advocate for hybrid formats as the way forward.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Academic conferences have traditionally been crucial for scientific exchange, collaboration, and career advancement. However, they often present significant geographical, financial, and administrative barriers, limiting participation for many researchers, particularly those from underrepresented backgrounds or developing countries. The COVID-19 pandemic created an urgent need to explore alternative formats, leading to the widespread adoption of virtual conferences. This paper addresses the question of whether these virtual formats effectively overcome the limitations of in-person conferences and what new challenges they introduce.

Methods

The researchers conducted a systematic analysis of 24 academic conferences held between January and August 2020. They compared data from these virtual conferences with historical data from in-person formats for four specific conferences (BCC, BIOC, ISMB, RECOMB). To assess participation, they collected registration data and analyzed attendee demographics (gender, ethnicity, country of affiliation) using machine learning techniques for name-based prediction. Social media engagement was measured by analyzing Twitter activity related to the conferences.

Datasets

The study utilized data from the registration systems of 24 academic conferences. For in-depth analysis, they focused on four specific conferences:

  • Bioinformatics Community Conference (BCC)
  • BioConductor Annual Meeting (BIOC)
  • Intelligent Systems for Molecular Biology (ISMB)
  • Research in Computational Molecular Biology (RECOMB)

They also collected and analyzed Twitter data related to these conferences over several years to assess social media engagement.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Democratization of Access: Virtual conferences have the potential to be far more inclusive, breaking down geographical barriers and reducing the financial burden associated with travel and registration.
  • Surprising Lack of Social Media Engagement: Despite a significant increase in the number of participants in virtual conferences, the study found a surprising decrease in social media engagement (measured by tweets) compared to in-person events. This suggests that simply increasing attendance doesn't automatically translate to increased online interaction.
  • Hybrid is the Future: The findings strongly suggest that a hybrid model, combining the strengths of both in-person and virtual formats, is the most promising approach for future academic conferences to maximize accessibility, diversity, and engagement.

Key Results

  • Massive Increase in Participation: For the RECOMB conference, participant numbers surged by 900% from 374 in 2019 (in-person) to 3913 in 2020 (virtual).
  • Broader Geographic Reach: The number of participating countries increased dramatically, with virtual conferences drawing attendees from a much wider range of regions, including developing nations.
  • Improved Representation: Virtual formats led to a substantial increase in participants from underrepresented minority groups (e.g., African Americans and Latinos), though their overall proportion remained relatively low, suggesting persistent barriers.
  • Gender Parity Maintained: The percentage of female participants remained similar between virtual and in-person formats.
  • Reduced Social Media Buzz: Tweet activity around conferences generally declined in 2020 compared to previous years, even with higher attendance.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Social Media Proxy: Twitter activity is used as a proxy for social engagement, which may not capture all forms of online interaction or communication that occur on other platforms.
  • Name-Based Prediction: Predicting gender and ethnicity from names can have inherent inaccuracies.
  • Engagement Nuances: The study notes that increased participation doesn't necessarily mean maximum engagement, as attendees might focus on specific talks rather than the entire conference.

Future work should continue to evaluate the impact of different conference formats (in-person, virtual, hybrid) on accessibility, inclusion, and diversity. The authors strongly advocate for the adoption of hybrid models to leverage the benefits of both approaches and address the identified challenges. They also suggest exploring ways to enhance social interaction and networking within virtual and hybrid environments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The COVID-19 pandemic brought a new set of unprecedented challenges not only for healthcare, education, and everyday jobs but also in terms of academic conferences. In this study, we investigate the effect of the broad adoption of virtual platforms for academic conferences as a response to COVID-19 restrictions. We show that virtual platforms enable higher participation from underrepresented minority groups, increased inclusion, and broader geographic distribution. We also discuss emerging challenges associated with the virtual conference format resulting in a decreased engagement of social activities, limited possibilities of cross-fertilization between participants, and reduced peer-to-peer interactions. Lastly, we conclude that a novel comprehensive approach needs to be adopted by the conference organizers to ensure increased accessibility, diversity, and inclusivity of post-pandemic conferences. Our findings provide evidence favoring a hybrid format for future conferences, marrying the strength of both in-person and virtual platforms.
BibTeX
@misc{wu2021virtual,
  author = {Juncheng Wu and Anushka Rajesh and Yu-Ning Huang and Karishma Chhugani and Rajesh Acharya and Kerui Peng and Ruth Johnson and Andrada Fiscutean and Carla Daniela Robles‐Espinoza and Francisco M. De La Vega and Riyue Bao and Serghei Mangul},
  title = {{Virtual meetings promise to eliminate the geographical and administrative barriers and increase accessibility, diversity, and inclusivity}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.07.07.451408},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure