Virtual environments for access design: Bringing together multidisciplinary teaching and learning for real world outcomes

Catherine Bridge, Tam Nguyen, Jim PlumeUNSWorks 2010 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the use of virtual environments and 3D modeling software in a multidisciplinary design course to teach universal design principles. The goal is to equip future designers with the skills and attitudes needed to create more accessible and equitable built environments, addressing the growing need for inclusive design in response to an aging population and human rights expectations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper addresses a critical gap in design education: the insufficient integration of universal design principles into professional curricula. Despite the increasing recognition of the importance of designing for all users, disability access is often treated as a specialized subdiscipline rather than a core competency. This leads to built environments, particularly housing, that are not inherently accessible, forcing costly and often aesthetically unappealing retrofits later. The authors highlight that traditional design education often overlooks the diverse needs of users throughout their lifespan, contributing to a built environment that can hinder independence and autonomy for older adults and people with disabilities.

Methods

The core of the paper describes an innovative 6-unit credit summer course designed to teach universal design principles. The course utilized a multidisciplinary approach, combining established digital modeling applications with cutting-edge virtual technologies. A key component was the use of an open-access home modeling application called "MyVirtualHome," which is described as being similar to computer games like "The Sims," making it accessible to users with limited prior experience. Parametric design was employed to create customizable components that naive users could test within a virtual world to evaluate accessibility solutions. The learning process also focused on addressing attitudinal barriers, with student learning outcomes captured through a dedicated learning wiki and student satisfaction scores. The evaluation method was action-based, drawing on various forms of evidence.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Virtual environments as powerful learning tools: The paper strongly suggests that virtual environments and simulations are highly effective for teaching complex design concepts like universal design. They allow for exploration, communication of ideas, and a more intuitive understanding of how design choices impact usability.
  • Bridging the gap between technical skills and attitudinal change: The course successfully integrated the development of technical skills in digital modeling with a focus on fostering a deeper understanding and appreciation for universal design principles, aiming to address attitudinal barriers.
  • MyVirtualHome as an accessible entry point: The choice of MyVirtualHome as a primary tool democratized the learning process, making advanced 3D modeling and virtual environment exploration accessible to students without extensive prior technical expertise.
  • The value of peer collaboration and feedback: The use of a wiki facilitated student collaboration and the sharing of insights, which contributed to their learning and understanding of universal design.
  • Student engagement and perceived value: The findings indicate that students found the course challenging, interesting, and beneficial, with a significant majority agreeing that it enabled them to learn independently and improve their skills in accessible modeling.

Key Results

  • Students reported a high level of agreement that the course was challenging and interesting (42.9% Strongly Agree, 57.1% Agree).
  • A significant majority of students agreed that the course enabled them to develop their learning independently in the future (66.7% Strongly Agree, 16.7% Agree, 16.7% Moderately Agree).
  • Students rated the level of improvement in their understanding and skills in accessible modeling very highly (66.7% Strongly Agree, 33.3% Agree).
  • Qualitative feedback from student blogs indicated a greater understanding of universal design and its importance, with some students expressing a desire to use the virtual home tool for future design explorations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Technical difficulties: A key limitation mentioned was the technical difficulties experienced in sharing 3Dmax accessible prototypes via the MyVirtualHome menu system, which hindered student collaboration in this specific aspect.
  • Limited sample size for formal evaluation: While student feedback was positive, it's noted that only 7 out of 35 enrolled students completed the formal CATΕΙ assessment, which could limit the generalizability of the quantitative findings.
  • Future research needed for optimal implementation: The authors conclude that further research is needed to determine the best method for implementing universal design learning within core design units. Their future research will investigate how this could be achieved and implemented effectively.

Summary updated

Abstract

Developing digital design skills appropriate for analysing issues of design accessibility is critical to better housing, interior and landscape architecture, industrial design and urban planning. An innovative course was designed and developed as part of a research project to investigate the use of an open access home modelling application known as MyVirtualHome. As well as learning technical skills, students’ learning addressed attitudinal barriers. The authors reflect on the future potential of other inclusive design collaborations that enhance both teaching and learning outcomes across design disciplines as well as provide real-world outcomes and scholarship in both learning and enabling environments.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bridge2010virtual,
  author = {Catherine Bridge and Tam Nguyen and Jim Plume},
  title = {{Virtual environments for access design: Bringing together multidisciplinary teaching and learning for real world outcomes}},
  booktitle = {UNSWorks},
  year = {2010},
  doi = {10.26190/unsworks/1227},
}
Figure