VIÉS DE TEMPO, PESSOA E LUGAR: Ampliando o olhar através da Teoria dos Pressupostos da Qualidade Científica

Breno Augusto Bormann de Souza Filho, Érika Fernandes Tritany, Claúdio J. StruchinerPsicologia 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The literature presents several classifications for methodological biases, yet little discussion exists regarding biases related to the theoretical foundations of research. Based on the Theory of Assumptions of Scientific Quality, this paper presents conceptual expansions related to theoretical-methodological biases. Through a critical-reflective narrative review, the authors describe the importance of explicating theoretical foundations and identifying biases related to the central dimensions of life: time, person, and place. This framework is particularly relevant for public health research and its intersection with the processes of study development and reporting. By classifying these biases across conceptual and empirical planes, the article aims to encourage the use of adequate theoretical foundations and the transparent reporting of potential biases in scientific work.

Introduction

In the pursuit of scientific rigor, researchers are traditionally trained to identify and mitigate methodological biases—errors in sampling, measurement, or data collection. However, a significant gap remains in the discourse regarding the biases inherent in the theoretical foundations of research. This paper, published in Psicologia e Saúde em Debate, challenges the conventional focus on methodology alone. By expanding the "Theory of Assumptions of Scientific Quality," the authors propose a framework that categorizes bias through three fundamental dimensions of human existence: Time, Person, and Place.

The Problem: Beyond Methodological Rigor

In fields such as epidemiology and public health, the term "bias" is often synonymous with technical mistakes like selection bias or information bias. The authors argue that this perspective is dangerously narrow. If a study is built upon a flawed or unexamined theoretical framework, no amount of methodological precision can ensure its validity.

Theoretical-methodological biases are often invisible because they are embedded in the researcher's worldview. The paper addresses the lack of a unified classification for these biases, arguing that scientific quality is determined by an inseparable triad: Theory, Methodology, and Reporting (Relato). A deficiency in any one of these pillars inevitably degrades the others and, by extension, the overall scientific value of the work.

Methodology: A Conceptual Reflection

This study is a critical-reflective work supported by a narrative review. Rather than presenting new empirical data, the authors use deductive reasoning and conceptual analysis to build upon the "Theory of Assumptions of Scientific Quality." To illustrate their points, they employ hypothetical scenarios, such as a study on chronic diseases in rural areas. These examples demonstrate how traditional methodological issues—like sampling difficulties—are often rooted in deeper, unacknowledged biases related to the "Place" (geographic and cultural context) and the "Person" (the subjective motivations of both researcher and participant).

The Three Dimensions of Bias

The authors reclassify bias into three "fundamental aspects of life" that must be accounted for in any high-quality study:

  • Time: This dimension refers to temporality and historical context. The timing of a study or the age of the theoretical framework used can skew results if the evolution of the subject matter is ignored.
  • Person: This encompasses the individual experiences and subjectivity of both the researcher and the participants. It includes the researcher’s background, which dictates their choice of theory, and participant-side factors like "memory bias."
  • Place: This refers to the cultural and geographic specificity of the research. A theory developed in one "place" may carry inherent biases when applied to another without significant contextual adjustment.

The Mathematical-Conceptual Model of Quality

A key contribution of this paper is the proposal of a mathematical model to visualize scientific quality. The authors represent quality as a non-hierarchical triangle (the Quality Triad). Scientific Quality ($QC$) is defined as the area of this "Quality Triangle" ($AT$) minus its intersection with the "Bias Circle" ($AC$):

$QC = AT - (AT ∩ AC)$

This model illustrates that even with perfect methodology and theory, if bias (the circle) overlaps with these pillars, the actual area of scientific quality shrinks. The authors emphasize that since bias can never be entirely eliminated—a concept they link to the "Theory of Uncertainty"—the researcher's primary responsibility is the explicit description of their theoretical foundation and its potential biases. This transparency allows the scientific community to interpret the results with the necessary context.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The proposed framework is an "embryo" intended to spark deeper discussion. While the theory provides a robust conceptual foundation, there is a noted scarcity of practical tools or checklists to help researchers implement this level of theoretical reporting. Future work should focus on developing specific instruments to assist researchers, reviewers, and editors in evaluating the theoretical depth and transparency of scientific publications. Ultimately, scientific quality is inversely proportional to the magnitude of unexamined bias; radical transparency regarding the "why" of research is as essential as the "how."

Summary updated

Abstract

The literature presents several classifications for methodological biases, however little is discussed about the possible biases related to the theoretical foundation adopted in the research. Based on the Theory of Assumptions of Scientific Quality, we present reflections and conceptual expansions related to theoretical-methodological biases in research. A critical-reflective text supported by a narrative review, whose material collection process was carried out in a non-systematic way, chosen exclusively and based on the line of argument and reflection that the authors intend to submit to appreciation and public debate. Describe the importance of explaining the theoretical foundation and possible biases related to central aspects of life, namely, the time, person and place for public health research and its intersection with the process of elaboration, development and reporting in scientific studies. Classify and describe the biased types of time, person and place referring to the conceptual and empirical planes and the important elaboration and description of the combination of both for scientific work. It is hoped that this article will raise discussions and reflections on the current theoretical-methodological process that permeates scientific work and encourages the use and adequate explanation of the foundation and its possible theoretical biases.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{filho2024vies,
  author = {Breno Augusto Bormann de Souza Filho and Érika Fernandes Tritany and Claúdio J. Struchiner},
  title = {{VIÉS DE TEMPO, PESSOA E LUGAR: Ampliando o olhar através da Teoria dos Pressupostos da Qualidade Científica}},
  booktitle = {Psicologia},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.22289/2446-922x.v10n1a54},
}
Figure