Video-based operational modal analysis of slender mechanical structures with neutral axis estimation via barycenter calculation

Jimmy Touzet, Olivier Alata, Frédéric Bonnardot, Simon Chesné, Hugo AndréMechanics 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, non-contact method for Operational Modal Analysis (OMA) using high-speed video to estimate the dynamic properties of slender mechanical structures. By employing a barycenter calculation on video frames, the technique accurately identifies natural frequencies, damping ratios, and mode shapes, offering a more accessible and efficient alternative to traditional methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional Operational Modal Analysis (OMA) methods for understanding structural vibrations often rely on accelerometers or Laser Doppler Vibrometry (LDV). Accelerometers can alter the structure's mass, while LDV, though precise, is costly and requires sequential measurements. This creates a need for non-contact, efficient, and potentially more accessible OMA techniques. The challenge lies in extracting precise dynamic information from video data, which is sensitive to lighting, noise, and requires sophisticated image processing to translate pixel intensity variations into physical motion. This paper specifically targets slender mechanical structures, where subtle deformations are crucial to capture.

Methods

The core of this work is a video-based OMA methodology that leverages a "barycenter calculation" for neutral axis estimation. The process involves several key steps:

  • Image Preprocessing: This includes cropping to isolate the beam, mean filtering for smoothing, contrast enhancement to ensure a high-contrast environment (essential for the barycenter method), and erosion/dilation to refine the beam's outline.
  • Neutral Axis Estimation: For each frame, the method calculates the barycenter of the beam's intensity profile across its width. This barycenter's position over time provides a subpixel-accurate measure of the beam's displacement.
  • Modal Property Extraction:
    • Natural Frequencies: Calculated by taking the mean spectrum of the barycenter signals and applying a peak-picking method.
  • Damping Ratios: Estimated using the Natural Excitation Technique (NEXT), which involves calculating the impulse response of each mode and fitting its envelope to a decaying exponential.
  • Modal Shapes: Reconstructed using a formula derived from the barycenter data, representing the spatial displacement of the beam for each mode.
  • Validation: The video-based results are rigorously compared against measurements from a Laser Doppler Vibrometer (LDV), a well-established high-precision technique. Metrics like the Modal Assurance Criterion (MAC) and crossMAC are used to assess the agreement between the two methods.
  • Noise and Computation Analysis: The paper also investigates the impact of noise on the method's accuracy and analyzes the computational complexity of the algorithm.

Datasets

The study utilizes a cantilever steel beam as a test case. This beam was subjected to white Gaussian noise excitation. The experiment involved capturing high-speed video of the beam at 2048 frames per second. For validation, Laser Doppler Vibrometry (LDV) measurements were performed on the same beam. The paper also describes the creation of synthetic images to simulate various noise conditions for numerical validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Barycenter as a Subpixel Displacement Indicator: The core innovation is using the barycenter of pixel intensity as a proxy for subpixel displacement. This is particularly effective for slender structures where the neutral axis's movement is indicative of the overall dynamic response.
  • High-Contrast Imaging is Crucial: The method's success hinges on a clear distinction between the beam and its background. This highlights the importance of controlled lighting and object preparation (painting the beam white against a black background).
  • Video OMA as a Viable Alternative: The study demonstrates that video-based OMA can achieve accuracy comparable to LDV for modal parameter estimation, offering a more accessible and less intrusive approach.
  • Noise Can Be a Double-Edged Sword: While excessive noise degrades accuracy, the paper shows that a certain level of noise can actually improve the detectability of small movements by "filling in" quantization gaps, leading to more accurate amplitude estimation up to a point.
  • Computational Efficiency: The algorithm's complexity is analyzed and found to be manageable, suggesting potential for real-time applications.

Key Results

  • Accurate Modal Parameter Extraction: The video-based OMA method accurately identified natural frequencies and damping ratios, with absolute differences from LDV measurements below 0.5 Hz for frequencies and 0.1% for damping ratios.
  • High Correlation with LDV: The crossMAC values between video and LDV modal shapes consistently exceeded a threshold of 0.8, indicating a strong correlation and reliable reconstruction of modal shapes.
  • Robustness to Noise: The method demonstrated good performance even with varying noise levels, with the ability to accurately detect and estimate modes when their amplitudes were significantly above the noise floor.
  • Computational Complexity: The complexity was found to be O(I × J × N), where I and J are image dimensions and N is the number of frames, indicating a linear relationship with data size.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Slender Structures: The method is primarily applicable to slender mechanical structures.
  • High-Contrast Requirement: The reliance on a high-contrast environment (bright object on a dark background) limits its application in scenarios with poor lighting or complex backgrounds.
  • Excitation Method: The use of white Gaussian noise is ideal for exciting all modes and for NEXT-based damping estimation, but this might not always be feasible in all practical applications.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest refining image processing algorithms for more complex environments, expanding the methodology to a wider range of mechanical systems and structures, and exploring real-time applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper presents an innovative adaptation of Operational Modal Analysis (OMA) by employing the concept of the barycenter to analyze dynamic behaviors in mechanical systems through video signal processing. Although this method is framed as a new contribution to the field of modal analysis, it is essential to recognize that its applicability is primarily confined to slender structures. Unlike conventional OMA methods reliant on numerical simulations or accelerometer measurements, this technique presents a non-contact, non-invasive measurement approach. It simultaneously captures multiple points across a wide field of view, ensuring robust measurements. The methodology was tested on a cantilever beam exposed to white Gaussian noise, with the beam recorded at 2048 frames per second to capture its dynamic response. The high-contrast environment facilitated image processing, while Laser Doppler Vibrometry (LDV) measurements served as a reference for validating the results. The proposed video-based OMA methodology demonstrated promising accuracy in capturing the system's dynamic behaviour by providing a more accessible and efficient alternative to traditional OMA techniques. Additionally, an analysis of the robustness of results concerning lighting conditions and video noise is conducted, along with a discussion on algorithmic complexity. Refinement of image processing algorithms and a broader application of this methodology to various mechanical systems and structures are proposed as important future objectives.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{touzet2025video,
  author = {Jimmy Touzet and Olivier Alata and Frédéric Bonnardot and Simon Chesné and Hugo André},
  title = {{Video-based operational modal analysis of slender mechanical structures with neutral axis estimation via barycenter calculation}},
  booktitle = {Mechanics},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1051/meca/2025012},
}
Figure