Very high-energy $gamma$-ray observations of novae and dwarf novae with the MAGIC telescopes

M. L. Ahnen, S. Ansoldi, L. A. Antonelli, P. Antoranz, A. Babić, B. Banerjee, P. Bangale, U. Barres de Almeida, J. A. Barrio, J. Becerra González, W. Bednarek, E. Bernardini, B. Biasuzzi, A. Biland, O. Blanch, S. Bonnefoy, G. Bonnoli, F. Borracci, T. Bretz, E. Carmona, A. Carosi, A. Chatterjee, R. Clavero, P. Colin, E. Colombo, Juan L. Contreras, J. Cortina, S. Covino, P. Da Vela, F. Dazzi, A. De Angelis, G. De Caneva, B. De Lotto, E. de Oña Wilhelmi, C. Delgado Mendez, F. Di Pierro, D. Dominis Prester, D. Dorner, M. Doro, S. Einecke, D. Glawion, D. Elsäesser, A. Fernández-Barral, D. Fidalgo, M. V. Fonseca, L. Font, K. Frantzen, C. Fruck, D. Galindo, R. J. Garcı́a López, M. Garczarczyk, D. Garrido Terrats, M. Gaug, P. Giammaria, N. Godinović, Alfonso Muñoz, D. Guberman, Y. Hanabata, M. Hayashida, Juan Manuel Herrera, J. Hose, D. Hrupec, G. Hughes, W. Idec, H. Kellermann, K. Kodani, Y. Konno, H. Kubo, J. Kushida, A. La Barbera, N. Lewandowska, E. Lindfors, S. Lombardi, F. Longo, Marcos López, R. López-Coto, A. López-Oramas, E. Lorenz, P. Majumdar, M. Makariev, K. Mallot, G. Maneva, M. Manganaro, K. Mannheim, L. Maraschi, B. Marcote, M. Mariotti, M. Martı́nez, D. Mazin, U. Menzel, J. M. Miranda, R. Mirzoyan, A. Moralejo, D. Nakajima, V. Neustroev, A. Niedźwiecki, M. Nievas Rosillo, K. Nilsson, K. NishijimaDesy 2015

TL;DR

This paper presents the first search for very-high-energy (VHE, >50 GeV) gamma-ray emission from novae using the MAGIC telescopes. While no VHE emission was detected from the observed novae (V339 Del, YY Her, and ASASSN-13ax), the combined GeV data from Fermi-LAT and the VHE upper limits from MAGIC place a strong constraint on the ratio of proton to electron luminosities in these explosive stellar events, suggesting protons are less luminous than electrons.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

For years, astronomers have observed GeV gamma-ray emission from novae, which is thought to originate from electrons accelerated in shock waves within the nova. However, these same shock waves are also expected to accelerate protons to much higher energies. If protons are accelerated to these higher energies, they should produce a distinct, second component of gamma-ray emission in the VHE range (above 50 GeV). This paper aims to bridge the gap between GeV and VHE observations by searching for this predicted VHE emission and using the combined data to understand the particle acceleration processes occurring in novae. Specifically, it seeks to determine if protons are accelerated to the same extent as electrons and what their relative contribution to the energy output might be.

Methods

The study utilizes observations from two powerful instruments:

  • MAGIC Telescopes: These are ground-based Cherenkov telescopes designed to detect VHE gamma rays with energies above ~50 GeV. The analysis involved observing specific nova events and calculating upper limits on any potential gamma-ray flux.
  • Fermi Large Area Telescope (LAT): This space-based telescope detects gamma rays in the GeV energy range (20 MeV to >300 GeV). The paper analyzes contemporaneous Fermi-LAT data for the observed novae to provide a broader spectral context.

The core methodology involves:

  1. Targeted Observations: The MAGIC telescopes observed three specific novae: the classical nova V339 Del (which had a prominent optical and GeV gamma-ray outburst), the symbiotic nova YY Her, and the dwarf nova ASASSN-13ax.
  2. Data Analysis: Standard analysis pipelines were used for both MAGIC and Fermi-LAT data to search for gamma-ray signals.
  3. Upper Limit Calculation: For non-detections, rigorous upper limits on the gamma-ray flux were calculated at a 95% confidence level.
  4. Spectral Modeling: The observed GeV spectra from Fermi-LAT and the VHE upper limits from MAGIC were used to constrain theoretical models of particle acceleration in novae. A modified version of the Sitarek & Bednarek (2012) model was employed, which considers inverse Compton scattering of thermal photons by electrons and proton-proton interactions.

Datasets

  • V339 Del: Optical observations from the AAVSO-LCG service, Fermi-LAT data (energy range 100 MeV – 300 GeV), and MAGIC telescope data (energy range >50 GeV).
  • YY Her: Fermi-LAT data and MAGIC telescope data.
  • ASASSN-13ax: Fermi-LAT data and MAGIC telescope data.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather utilizes existing observational data from established instruments.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • No VHE Emission Detected: The most significant finding is the lack of any detectable VHE gamma-ray emission from the studied novae. This suggests that either protons are not accelerated to the very highest energies, or their emission is suppressed.
  • Protons Less Luminous than Electrons: The combined GeV and VHE upper limits for V339 Del strongly constrain the ratio of proton to electron luminosities ($L_p \le 0.15 L_e$). This implies that electrons are the dominant particle species responsible for the observed gamma-ray emission in novae.
  • Importance of Multi-Wavelength Observations: The study highlights the crucial role of combining data from different energy regimes (GeV and VHE) to probe the complex physics of particle acceleration in astrophysical sources.
  • Novae as Laboratories for Particle Acceleration: Novae, despite their transient nature, are proving to be valuable laboratories for studying extreme particle acceleration processes, offering insights into fundamental physics.

Key Results

  • No significant VHE gamma-ray emission was detected from V339 Del, YY Her, or ASASSN-13ax by the MAGIC telescopes.
  • Upper limits on the VHE gamma-ray flux were computed for these sources, providing constraints on their emission properties.
  • For V339 Del, the combined Fermi-LAT GeV data and MAGIC VHE upper limits limit the ratio of proton to electron luminosities to $L_p \le 0.15 L_e$.
  • The GeV emission from V339 Del is well-explained by inverse Compton scattering of thermal photons from the nova's photosphere by accelerated electrons.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Statistics for VHE: The primary limitation is the lack of VHE detection, which means the constraints are derived from upper limits rather than direct measurements of proton-induced emission. This is partly due to the transient nature of novae and the challenges of observing them with ground-based telescopes, especially during periods of poor weather.
  • Model Dependence: The derived luminosity ratio is dependent on the adopted theoretical model for particle acceleration and emission.
  • Future Observations: The authors express their intention to continue observing promising nova candidates with MAGIC in the future. This ongoing effort aims to increase the chances of detecting VHE emission from other novae and to refine the constraints on particle acceleration processes. Future observations with improved sensitivity and longer observation times could potentially reveal the predicted VHE component or further tighten the limits on proton acceleration.

Summary updated

Abstract

Context. In the last five years the Fermi Large Area Telescope (LAT) instrument detected GeV γ-ray emission from five novae. The GeV emission can be interpreted in terms of an inverse Compton process of electrons accelerated in a shock. In this case it is expected that protons in the same conditions can be accelerated to much higher energies. Consequently they may produce a second component in the γ-ray spectrum at TeV energies.
\nAims. We aim to explore the very-high-energy domain to search for γ-ray emission above 50 GeV and to shed light on the acceleration process of leptons and hadrons in nova explosions.
\nMethods. We have performed observations with the MAGIC telescopes of the classical nova V339 Del shortly after the 2013 outburst, triggered by optical and subsequent GeV γ-ray detections. We also briefly report on VHE observations of the symbiotic nova YY Her and the dwarf nova ASASSN-13ax. We complement the TeV MAGIC observations with the analysis of contemporaneous Fermi-LAT data of the sources. The TeV and GeV observations are compared in order to evaluate the acceleration parameters for leptons and hadrons.
\nResults. No significant TeV emission was found from the studied sources. We computed upper limits on the spectrum and night-bynight flux. The combined GeV and TeV observations of V339 Del limit the ratio of proton to electron luminosities to Lp . 0.15 Le.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ahnen2015very,
  author = {M. L. Ahnen and S. Ansoldi and L. A. Antonelli and P. Antoranz and A. Babić and B. Banerjee and P. Bangale and U. Barres de Almeida and J. A. Barrio and J. Becerra González and W. Bednarek and E. Bernardini and B. Biasuzzi and A. Biland and O. Blanch and S. Bonnefoy and G. Bonnoli and F. Borracci and T. Bretz and E. Carmona and A. Carosi and A. Chatterjee and R. Clavero and P. Colin and E. Colombo and Juan L. Contreras and J. Cortina and S. Covino and P. Da Vela and F. Dazzi and A. De Angelis and G. De Caneva and B. De Lotto and E. de Oña Wilhelmi and C. Delgado Mendez and F. Di Pierro and D. Dominis Prester and D. Dorner and M. Doro and S. Einecke and D. Glawion and D. Elsäesser and A. Fernández-Barral and D. Fidalgo and M. V. Fonseca and L. Font and K. Frantzen and C. Fruck and D. Galindo and R. J. Garcı́a López and M. Garczarczyk and D. Garrido Terrats and M. Gaug and P. Giammaria and N. Godinović and Alfonso Muñoz and D. Guberman and Y. Hanabata and M. Hayashida and Juan Manuel Herrera and J. Hose and D. Hrupec and G. Hughes and W. Idec and H. Kellermann and K. Kodani and Y. Konno and H. Kubo and J. Kushida and A. La Barbera and A. La Barbera and N. Lewandowska and E. Lindfors and S. Lombardi and F. Longo and Marcos López and R. López-Coto and A. López-Oramas and E. Lorenz and P. Majumdar and M. Makariev and K. Mallot and G. Maneva and M. Manganaro and K. Mannheim and L. Maraschi and B. Marcote and M. Mariotti and M. Martı́nez and D. Mazin and U. Menzel and J. M. Miranda and R. Mirzoyan and A. Moralejo and D. Nakajima and V. Neustroev and A. Niedźwiecki and M. Nievas Rosillo and K. Nilsson and K. Nishijima},
  title = {{Very high-energy $gamma$-ray observations of novae and dwarf novae with the MAGIC telescopes}},
  booktitle = {Desy},
  year = {2015},
}
Figure