Vertical Transistors Based on Stacked Dirac Materials

Yangyang Wang, Zeyuan Ni, Qihang Liu, Ruge Quhe, Jiaxin Zheng, Meng Ye, Dapeng Yu, Junjie Shi, Jinbo Yang, Jing Lu2014

TL;DR

Researchers have demonstrated a novel all-metallic transistor design using stacked Dirac materials (like graphene and silicene) that achieves a significant on/off current ratio (over 10⁴) and a substantial transport gap (over 0.4 eV). This breakthrough overcomes the inherent zero band gap limitation of these materials, paving the way for high-performance electronic devices without compromising their excellent carrier mobility.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The semiconductor industry is constantly seeking ways to improve transistor performance, including scaling down size, reducing energy consumption, and increasing operating frequency. While materials like graphene, silicene, and germanene boast exceptionally high carrier mobilities, their zero band gaps make them unsuitable for traditional field-effect transistors (FETs) that rely on a tunable band gap to switch current on and off. Existing methods to open a band gap in these materials often lead to a significant reduction in mobility or result in a low on/off ratio, falling short of the requirements for complementary MOS-like logic (which needs ratios between 10⁴ and 10⁷). This paper tackles the challenge of creating high-performance FETs from semimetallic Dirac materials without sacrificing their inherent advantages.

Methods

The study employs a combination of density functional theory (DFT) for structural and electronic property calculations and first-principles quantum transport simulations using the non-equilibrium Green's function (NEGF) method.

  • DFT Calculations: Used to determine the stable stacking configurations, interlayer binding energies, and electronic band structures of various graphene/silicene heterostructures. The Tkatchenko-Scheffler (TS) scheme was specifically used to account for van der Waals dispersion interactions, which are crucial for weakly interacting layered materials.
  • Quantum Transport Simulations: A two-probe model was constructed to simulate the behavior of a vertical FET. This involved calculating the transmission probability of electrons through the heterostructure as a function of energy and momentum. The Landauer-Büttiker formula was used to compute the current.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on theoretical calculations rather than experimental datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Momentum Mismatch as a Band Gap Creator: The core insight is that stacking two different Dirac materials (like graphene and silicene) in a vertical heterostructure, even with weak van der Waals interactions, can lead to a significant transport gap. This gap arises not from band hybridization, but from a momentum mismatch between the Dirac cones of the two materials. This prevents electrons from easily transferring between the layers without phonon assistance, effectively creating an "on" and "off" state.
  • Robustness of the Phenomenon: The observed transport gap and high on/off ratio are remarkably robust against the relative rotation between the stacked Dirac layers. This suggests a broad applicability of this design principle.
  • All-Metallic FETs are Possible: The research demonstrates that it's possible to create functional FETs using materials that are intrinsically metallic or semimetallic, challenging the conventional wisdom that a semiconducting channel is a prerequisite.
  • Extension to Twisted Bilayer Graphene: The principle of momentum mismatch to open a transport gap is shown to be applicable to twisted bilayer graphene, a well-studied system with its own unique electronic properties.

Key Results

  • Transport Gap: A transport gap of over 0.4 eV was consistently observed in the simulated vertical Dirac material heterostructures. In specific cases, like the (8x8)SLG/(5x5)silicene heterostructure, a gap of 1.2 eV was found.
  • On/Off Current Ratio: The devices exhibited an impressive on/off current ratio exceeding 10⁴. For a more realistic gate voltage window (-5 to 5 V), a ratio of 7.8x10⁴ was achieved, which is significantly higher than many existing experimental results for similar systems.
  • Weak Interlayer Interaction: DFT calculations confirmed that the van der Waals interaction between the Dirac layers is weak, allowing the Dirac cones to largely survive without significant hybridization.
  • Robustness to Rotation: The transport gap and high on/off ratio were found to be robust against relative rotations between the stacked layers, with a significant gap still observed for a 21.8° twisted SLG/silicene heterostructure.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Phonon Assistance: The study acknowledges that at finite temperatures, phonon assistance could potentially enable electron transport between Dirac cones, which might degrade device performance. The calculations were performed assuming ballistic and elastic transport, i.e., no phonon scattering.
  • Environmental Stability: The authors note that 2D materials are sensitive to their environment. They suggest that sandwiching the stacked Dirac materials with hBN films could be an effective method to improve environmental resistance and device stability.
  • Experimental Realization: While the paper proposes a method for realizing graphene/silicene heterostructure FETs using specific substrates (like GaS/GaSe/GaTe), experimental verification is still needed.
  • Further Exploration: The paper suggests that this concept can be extended to other stacked Dirac materials and twisted bilayer graphene, opening avenues for further research and development. The potential for achieving even higher switching ratios and exploring different stacking configurations remains an active area.

Summary updated

Abstract

Despite of their high carrier mobilities, pristine Dirac materials (such as graphene, silicene, and germanene) are unsuitable for effective field effect transistors due to their zero band gaps. In a vertical heterostructure composed by two Dirac materials, the Dirac cones of the two materials survive the weak interlayer Van der Waals interaction based on density functional theory method, and electron transport from the Dirac cone of one material to the one of the other material is therefore forbidden without assistance of phonon because of momentum mismatch. First-principles quantum transport simulations of the vertical Dirac material heterostructure devices confirm the existence of a transport gap of over 0.4 eV, accompanied by a switching ratio of over 104. Such a striking behavior is robust against the relative rotation between the two Dirac materials and can be extended to twisted bilayer graphene. Therefore, novel avenue is opened up for Dirac material vertical structures in high-performance devices without opening their band gaps.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2014vertical,
  author = {Yangyang Wang and Zeyuan Ni and Qihang Liu and Ruge Quhe and Jiaxin Zheng and Meng Ye and Dapeng Yu and Junjie Shi and Jinbo Yang and Jing Lu},
  title = {{Vertical Transistors Based on Stacked Dirac Materials}},
  year = {2014},
}
Figure