Vertical and Smooth Single-Step Reactive Ion Etching Process for InP Membrane Waveguides

Yuqing Jiao, T. de Vries, Ralph-Stephan Unger, Longfei Shen, H.p.m.m. Ambrosius, Calin Radu, Michael Arens, M.k. Smit, Jos van der TolJournal of The Electrochemical Society 2015 · DOI

Abstract

In this paper, we present a novel single-step Reactive Ion Etching (RIE) process for Indium Phosphide (InP) membrane optical waveguide etching. The optimization of the process focuses on achieving high sidewall verticality and minimizing surface roughness. Significant improvements in the etched profile are achieved for the first time using a single-step RIE approach. Loss measurements on fabricated membrane waveguides result in a record-low propagation loss of 2.5 dB/cm.

Introduction: The Challenge of InP-on-Silicon Photonics

The Indium Phosphide-on-Silicon (IMOS) platform is a critical technology for integrated photonics, enabling the co-integration of active components like lasers with passive waveguides on a single chip. However, as device dimensions shrink, performance becomes increasingly sensitive to fabrication imperfections. Two primary obstacles hinder performance: surface roughness, which causes light scattering and optical loss, and sidewall tilt, which leads to polarization crosstalk.

Traditional etching methods often rely on complex cyclic processes—alternating between etching and cleaning—to maintain profile control. Previous attempts at single-step etching frequently suffered from sloped walls (typically 84–85°) and "undercutting," where chemical etching beneath the hard mask compromises device precision.

Methods: Optimizing the RIE Process

The research team utilized a SENTECH SI500 ICP machine operating in RIE mode, employing a gas chemistry of Methane ($CH_4$), Hydrogen ($H_2$), and Argon ($Ar$). The core of this study involved a systematic optimization of RF power, scanning a range from 75W to 250W to find the ideal balance between physical ion bombardment (sputtering) and chemical passivation (polymer layer protection).

Waveguide patterns were defined using Electron Beam Lithography (EBL) with a Silicon Nitride ($SiN_x$) hard mask. The study evaluated four distinct test recipes, varying gas ratios and pressures, and characterized the results using Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) for profile analysis and Atomic Force Microscopy (AFM) for sub-nanometer surface roughness measurements.

Key Insights: Balancing Chemistry and Physics

The researchers identified an RF power "sweet spot" at 100W. At this level, the rate of polymer formation on the sidewalls perfectly balances the rate of ion erosion, creating a protective shield that prevents undercutting while maintaining verticality. Furthermore, increasing process pressure was found to decrease the mean free path of ions, shifting the process from aggressive physical sputtering toward smoother chemical etching. This optimization resulted in a floor roughness of only 0.6–0.7 nm.

Results: Record-Breaking Performance

The optimized single-step process yielded several state-of-the-art results:

  • Record Low Loss: Waveguides achieved a propagation loss of 2.5 dB/cm for the fundamental TE mode at 1550 nm, outperforming the previous state-of-the-art of 3.3 dB/cm.
  • Near-Perfect Verticality: Sidewall angles were improved to 88°, which is essential for maintaining signal integrity in complex photonic circuits.
  • Zero Undercut: At 100W RF power, undercutting beneath the $SiN_x$ mask was eliminated, ensuring the final device matched the intended design.
  • High Selectivity: The process demonstrated a selectivity of over 100, allowing for deep etches with relatively thin protective mask layers.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This work proves that a finely tuned single-step RIE process can outperform complex cyclic methods, significantly simplifying the manufacturing workflow for InP photonics. While the "floor" roughness was successfully measured, future work will focus on direct measurement of vertical sidewall roughness and applying this optimized etch to active components like lasers and amplifiers, which involve more complex material stacks such as InGaAs layers.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper we present a novel single-step RIE process for InP membrane optical waveguide etching. The optimization of the process is focused on the sidewall verticality and surface roughness of the etched profile. Significant improvement on the etched profile is achieved for the first time in a single-step RIE process. Loss measurement on fabricated membrane waveguides etched with the proposed RIE process results in a record low waveguide propagation loss (2.5 dB/cm).
BibTeX
@article{jiao2015vertical,
  author = {Yuqing Jiao and T. de Vries and Ralph-Stephan Unger and Longfei Shen and H.P.M.M. Ambrosius and Calin Radu and Michael Arens and M.K. Smit and Jos van der Tol},
  title = {{Vertical and Smooth Single-Step Reactive Ion Etching Process for InP Membrane Waveguides}},
  journal = {Journal of The Electrochemical Society},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1149/2.0371508jes},
}
Figure