Venn-diaNet : venn diagram based network propagation analysis framework for comparing multiple biological experiments

Benjamin Hur, Dongwon Kang, Sangseon Lee, Ji Hwan Moon, Gung Lee, Sun KimBMC Bioinformatics 2019 · DOI · OpenReview

Introduction

In modern genomics, researchers frequently compare multiple transcriptome (RNA-seq) experiments to understand how different tissues respond to the same stimulus or how treatment combinations create synergistic effects. While Venn diagrams are the standard for visualizing the overlap of Differentially Expressed Genes (DEGs) between these experiments, they suffer from two major limitations: a lack of gene prioritization and a disregard for the functional context of gene interactions.

Venn-diaNet is a web-based framework designed to bridge this gap. By utilizing specific regions of a Venn diagram as "seeds" for network propagation, it allows researchers to prioritize and rank genes based on their functional context within protein-protein interaction (PPI) networks.

Methodology

The Venn-diaNet framework follows a systematic four-step workflow to transform simple gene lists into prioritized biological insights:

  1. Input: Users upload multiple DEG lists from different experimental conditions.
  2. Venn Generation: The system generates a Venn diagram. For complex comparisons involving more than four sets, it utilizes a specialized layout to maintain readability.
  3. Seed Selection: This core innovation allows users to select genes from specific Venn segments (e.g., genes unique to a specific treatment or shared across conditions) to act as "seeds."
  4. Network Propagation: The system maps these seeds onto a high-confidence PPI network from the STRING database. It then performs a Markov Random Walk (MRW) to spread the influence of seed genes to their neighbors, ranking all genes based on their final "influence" score.
The Venn-diaNet four-step workflow: from DEG list upload to network-based gene ranking.

Key Innovations and Insights

Venn-diaNet introduces several novel concepts to comparative genomics:

  • Experimental Logic as Prior Knowledge: Traditional network propagation often requires a "gold standard" list of known disease genes. Venn-diaNet recognizes that the logical structure of the experiment itself (the Venn regions) can serve as the basis for selecting seeds.
  • Rescuing "Hidden" Genes: Standard analysis often overlooks genes with low fold-changes. Because Venn-diaNet evaluates network proximity, it can highlight genes that are centrally located in a functional pathway even if their individual expression changes were modest.
  • Managing Complexity: The tool can handle up to eight overlapping experiments, automating the filtering and expert-knowledge-driven analysis that researchers usually perform manually.

Validation and Results

The authors validated the framework using three distinct case studies: circadian rhythm protein (Per2) knockout data, Human papillomavirus (HPV) oncogene studies, and Narciclasine treatment effects. Key results include:

  • Functional Accuracy: In the Per2 study, the top 10% of genes ranked by Venn-diaNet showed a significantly higher hit rate for relevant biological pathways, such as lipid metabolism, compared to genes ranked solely by fold-change.
  • Improved Prioritization: In the HPV case study, the gene Tlr2 (critical in HPV-associated cancer) was ranked 332nd by standard fold-change but rose to 33rd via Venn-diaNet. Similarly, Icam1 jumped from 76th to 3rd place.
  • Reproducibility: The tool successfully reproduced core findings from complex, high-impact papers, demonstrating its utility in automating sophisticated biological analysis.

Limitations and Future Directions

While powerful, the framework's efficacy is tied to the completeness of the STRING PPI database. Future iterations could benefit from integrating tissue-specific networks and automating Gene Ontology (GO) analysis to help users identify the most functionally relevant Venn regions for seed selection. Currently, Venn-diaNet is freely available for public use at the authors' web portal.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background The main research topic in this paper is how to compare multiple biological experiments using transcriptome data, where each experiment is measured and designed to compare control and treated samples. Comparison of multiple biological experiments is usually performed in terms of the number of DEGs in an arbitrary combination of biological experiments. This process is usually facilitated with Venn diagram but there are several issues when Venn diagram is used to compare and analyze multiple experiments in terms of DEGs. First, current Venn diagram tools do not provide systematic analysis to prioritize genes. Because that current tools generally do not fully focus to prioritize genes, genes that are located in the segments in the Venn diagram (especially, intersection) is usually difficult to rank. Second, elucidating the phenotypic difference only with the lists of DEGs and expression values is challenging when the experimental designs have the combination of treatments. Experiment designs that aim to find the synergistic effect of the combination of treatments are very difficult to find without an informative system. Results We introduce Venn-diaNet, a Venn diagram based analysis framework that uses network propagation upon protein-protein interaction network to prioritizes genes from experiments that have multiple DEG lists. We suggest that the two issues can be effectively handled by ranking or prioritizing genes with segments of a Venn diagram. The user can easily compare multiple DEG lists with gene rankings, which is easy to understand and also can be coupled with additional analysis for their purposes. Our system provides a web-based interface to select seed genes in any of areas in a Venn diagram and then perform network propagation analysis to measure the influence of the selected seed genes in terms of ranked list of DEGs. Conclusions We suggest that our system can logically guide to select seed genes without additional prior knowledge that makes us free from the seed selection of network propagation issues. We showed that Venn-diaNet can reproduce the research findings reported in the original papers that have experiments that compare two, three and eight experiments. Venn-diaNet is freely available at: http://biohealth.snu.ac.kr/software/venndianet
BibTeX
@article{hur2019venn,
  author = {Benjamin Hur and Dongwon Kang and Sangseon Lee and Ji Hwan Moon and Gung Lee and Sun Kim},
  title = {{Venn-diaNet : venn diagram based network propagation analysis framework for comparing multiple biological experiments}},
  journal = {BMC Bioinformatics},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1186/s12859-019-3302-7},
}
Figure