Vehicle Stability Analysis under Extreme Operating Conditions Based on LQR Control

Liping Wu, Ran Zhou, Junshan Bao, Guang Yang, Feng Sun, Fangchao Xu, Junjie Jin, Qi Zhang, Jiang Wei-kang, Xiaoyou ZhangSensors 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the effectiveness of an electromagnetic active suspension system controlled by a Linear Quadratic Regulator (LQR) for enhancing vehicle stability under extreme driving conditions. By simulating scenarios like high-speed driving on rough roads, low-adhesion surfaces, and emergency maneuvers, the study demonstrates significant improvements in ride comfort and stability compared to passive suspension systems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Modern vehicles are increasingly expected to perform reliably and comfortably under a wide range of conditions. While extensive research exists on active suspension systems for normal driving, their performance under extreme operating conditions—such as high-speed driving on uneven surfaces, sudden braking, or navigating low-traction roads—remains less explored. These extreme scenarios can lead to a sharp deterioration in vehicle stability, reduced ride comfort, and increased driving risk. This paper aims to bridge this gap by analyzing and quantifying the benefits of an electromagnetic active suspension system, controlled by an LQR, specifically for these challenging situations.

Methods

The authors developed a comprehensive approach involving several key steps:

  • 7-DOF Vehicle Dynamics Model: A detailed seven degrees-of-freedom (7-DOF) dynamic model of the vehicle was created, incorporating the complexities of an electromagnetic active suspension. This model captures various motions like vertical, pitch, and roll, along with the dynamics of the four suspension systems.
  • LQR Controller Design: A Linear Quadratic Regulator (LQR) controller was designed for the electromagnetic active suspension. LQR is a well-established optimal control technique that aims to minimize a quadratic cost function, balancing control effort with system performance.
  • Joint Simulation Platform: A simulation environment was established by integrating MATLAB/Simulink with the CarSim vehicle dynamics software. This platform allows for realistic simulation of vehicle behavior under various conditions.
  • Model Verification: The accuracy of the CarSim vehicle model was validated against real-world vehicle test data, ensuring the reliability of the simulation results.
  • Extreme Condition Simulation: Four distinct extreme operating conditions were simulated:
  • High-speed driving on a Class C road (poor surface quality).
  • A "double-shift" (lane change) maneuver on a low-adhesion surface.
  • Emergency acceleration.
  • Emergency braking.

Datasets

The paper does not explicitly mention the use of pre-existing datasets for training. However, it utilizes real-world vehicle test data for the verification of the CarSim vehicle model. This involved conducting road tests with a Toyota RAV4 on a test track with speed bumps, collecting vibration and acceleration data using piezoelectric sensors and a dynamic signal collector. This experimental data was used to compare the CarSim model's output against actual vehicle responses.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • LQR for Extreme Stability: The study highlights that LQR control, when applied to electromagnetic active suspensions, can significantly enhance vehicle stability and ride comfort even under severe driving conditions that typically challenge passive systems.
  • Holistic Improvement: The benefits aren't limited to just one aspect; the LQR-controlled active suspension shows improvements across multiple metrics, including body acceleration (vertical and pitch), suspension deflection, and tire dynamic load, depending on the specific extreme condition.
  • Trade-offs and Robustness: While the active suspension generally improves performance, the paper notes some instances where specific metrics (like front suspension dynamic deflection in certain scenarios) might show slight deterioration. However, the overall improvement in ride comfort and stability metrics outweighs these minor trade-offs, demonstrating the system's robustness.
  • Simulation as a Powerful Tool: The successful integration of CarSim and MATLAB/Simulink, coupled with real-world validation, underscores the utility of such simulation platforms for designing and evaluating advanced vehicle control systems before physical implementation.

Key Results

The simulations revealed significant improvements when comparing the LQR-controlled electromagnetic active suspension to a passive system across various extreme conditions:

  • High-Speed Driving (Class C Road): RMS values for body droop acceleration and pitch angle acceleration were improved by 57.48% and 28.81%, respectively.
  • Double-Shift (Low Adhesion): RMS values for body droop acceleration, pitch acceleration, and roll angle acceleration saw improvements of 58.25%, 55.41%, and 31.39%, respectively.
  • Emergency Acceleration: Body droop and pitch angle acceleration RMS values improved by 58.54% and 54.13%, respectively.
  • Emergency Braking: Body vertical acceleration and pitch angle acceleration RMS values showed substantial improvements of 76.39% and 64.44%, respectively.

While some specific metrics like front suspension dynamic deflection showed minor deteriorations in certain scenarios, the overall impact on ride comfort and stability was positive.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that this study primarily relies on simulation. While the CarSim model was verified against real-world data, a full-scale experimental validation of the LQR-controlled electromagnetic active suspension under these extreme conditions would be the next logical step.

Future work suggested includes:

  • Designing and implementing the electromagnetic active suspension system based on the findings of this paper.
  • Investigating the coupling and control between lateral and longitudinal vehicle stability.
  • Utilizing advanced sensors (e.g., laser displacement sensors) for more precise measurements.
  • Conducting comprehensive whole-vehicle test verifications.
  • Further in-depth discussions on control strategy managerial points.

Summary updated

Abstract

Under extreme working conditions such as high-speed driving on roads with a large road surface unevenness coefficient, turning on a road with a low road surface adhesion coefficient, and emergency acceleration and braking, a vehicle's stability deteriorates sharply and reduces ride comfort. There is extensive existing research on vehicle active suspension control, trajectory tracking, and control methods. However, most of these studies focus on conventional operating conditions, while vehicle stability analysis under extreme operating conditions is much less studied. In order to improve the stability of the whole vehicle under extreme operating conditions, this paper investigates the stability of a vehicle under extreme operating conditions based on linear quadratic regulator (LQR) control. First, a seven degrees of freedom (7-DOF) dynamics model of the whole vehicle is established based on the use of electromagnetic active suspension, and then an LQR controller of the electromagnetic active suspension is designed. A joint simulation platform incorporating MATLAB and CarSim was built, and the CarSim model is verified by real vehicle tests. Finally, the stability of the vehicle under four different ultimate operating conditions was analyzed. The simulation results show that the root mean square (RMS) values of body droop acceleration and pitch angle acceleration are improved by 57.48% and 28.81%, respectively, under high-speed driving conditions on Class C roads. Under the double-shift condition with a low adhesion coefficient, the RMS values of body droop acceleration, pitch acceleration, and roll angle acceleration are improved by 58.25%, 55.41%, and 31.39%, respectively. These results indicate that electromagnetic active suspension can significantly improve vehicle stability and reduce driving risk under extreme working conditions when combined with an LQR controller.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wu2022vehicle,
  author = {Liping Wu and Ran Zhou and Junshan Bao and Guang Yang and Feng Sun and Fangchao Xu and Junjie Jin and Qi Zhang and Jiang Wei-kang and Xiaoyou Zhang},
  title = {{Vehicle Stability Analysis under Extreme Operating Conditions Based on LQR Control}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22249791},
}
Figure