TL;DR
In 2015, a year marked by extreme global warming and a strong El Niño event, researchers found that while northern vegetation experienced unprecedented greenness during the growing season, this didn't translate into a significant annual increase in carbon sequestration. Instead, enhanced carbon release in the autumn offset the summer uptake, and a dramatic shift to a carbon source occurred in the tropics, highlighting the complex and sometimes counteracting effects of climate variations on the land carbon sink.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
The Earth's land ecosystems act as a crucial carbon sink, absorbing a significant portion of human-emitted CO2. Understanding how this sink responds to climate variations, particularly extreme events like El Niño and long-term trends like global warming and vegetation greening, is vital for predicting future climate change. While satellite observations show a consistent global greening trend, leading to increased carbon uptake during growing seasons, interannual variations in land carbon uptake are strongly influenced by climate phenomena like El Niño, which can cause droughts and reduce uptake. This paper investigates the year 2015, a unique "natural experiment" combining record-breaking global temperatures, a strong El Niño, and unprecedented vegetation greenness, to disentangle these competing influences on the land carbon sink.
Methods
The study utilizes two primary atmospheric inversion systems (CAMS and Jena CarboScope) to estimate global and regional land-atmosphere carbon fluxes from 1981 to 2015. These systems use atmospheric CO2 concentration measurements and transport models to infer carbon sources and sinks. The researchers analyzed seasonal patterns of land carbon uptake anomalies in 2015 relative to the long-term trend. They also examined the relationship between these anomalies and climate variations (temperature, precipitation, soil water content) and vegetation greenness (NDVI) using partial correlation coefficients and linear regression. To understand the extreme nature of the 2015 events, they compared seasonal transitions in land carbon uptake anomalies with historical data, particularly focusing on the Q3-Q4 transition.
Datasets
- Atmospheric CO2 Growth Rates (AGR): Retrieved from NOAA/ESRL (Earth System Research Laboratory).
- Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI): Data from MODIS Terra Collection 6 (2000-2015) at 0.05° resolution.
- Climate Data: ERA-Interim reanalysis data (monthly, 0.5° resolution) for air temperature, precipitation, and volumetric soil water content.
- El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO) Indices: Multivariate ENSO Index (MEI).
- Fire Emission Data: Global Fire Emissions Database version 4s (GFED4s) at daily time step and 0.25° spatial resolution.
- Land and Ocean Carbon Uptake Estimates: Global Carbon Project (GCP) data for comparison.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Greening Doesn't Always Mean More Annual Sequestration: The unprecedented vegetation greenness in the Northern Hemisphere during the 2015 growing season was largely offset by increased carbon release in the autumn and winter. This suggests that while greening can boost uptake during the growing season, it doesn't necessarily lead to a greater annual carbon sequestration.
- Seasonal Decoupling is Crucial: The study highlights a significant decoupling between vegetation greenness and land carbon uptake outside the main growing season. High NDVI in autumn, for instance, doesn't automatically translate to a strong carbon sink.
- Extreme Seasonal Transitions: The year 2015 witnessed the largest ever recorded seasonal transition in terrestrial tropical CO2 fluxes, shifting from a carbon sink to a significant carbon source in the last quarter. This dramatic shift underscores the vulnerability of tropical ecosystems to extreme climate events.
- Temperature vs. Precipitation Dominance: In northern latitudes, temperature appears to be a more dominant driver of carbon uptake anomalies during the growing season, while precipitation plays a more significant role in autumn carbon loss in some regions. In the tropics, temperature's influence on evaporative demand and soil moisture seems to be a key factor in driving carbon flux anomalies.
- El Niño's Complex Impact: While El Niño events are historically linked to reduced land carbon uptake, the 2015 event, combined with record warming, resulted in a particularly strong and rapid transition to a carbon source in the tropics, even with lower fire emissions compared to the 1997-1998 El Niño.
Key Results
- 2015 as the Greenest Year: Satellite observations indicated 2015 was the greenest year for vegetation since 2000, with 16% of vegetated land showing record seasonal NDVI.
- Record Atmospheric CO2 Growth Rate: The year 2015 saw a record atmospheric CO2 growth rate (AGR) of 2.96 ppm yr⁻¹, exceeding that of the strong 1997-1998 El Niño event, despite higher annual emissions in 2015.
- Northern Hemisphere Uptake: Both inversion systems indicated higher-than-usual northern land carbon uptake in boreal spring and summer 2015, consistent with greening and warming.
- Autumn Carbon Release: This enhanced summer uptake was significantly offset by a larger CO2 source in the autumn (Q4) for the Northern Hemisphere.
- Tropical Transition: A strong transition to a large carbon source in the tropics and Southern Hemisphere occurred in the last three months of 2015, representing the largest such transition found in inversion records.
- Annual Balance: For the globe, the CAMS inversion showed a negative annual land carbon anomaly of -1.2 Pg C, while the Jena04 inversion indicated a smaller anomaly of -0.3 Pg C, both pointing to a reduced net carbon sink in 2015.
Limitations and Future Work
- Data Uncertainty: The sparse distribution of atmospheric CO2 measurement sites, particularly in boreal Eurasia and the tropics, limits the precise spatial resolution of carbon flux estimates and can introduce uncertainties in attributing seasonal transitions to specific climate drivers.
- Inversion System Differences: Minor discrepancies exist between the CAMS and Jena04 inversion systems, potentially due to differences in input data, land prior fluxes, or spatial error correlation lengths.
- Early 2016 Data: The lack of complete early 2016 data for some inversions may weaken the constraints on the last season of 2015, potentially affecting the magnitude of the Q4 anomaly.
- Future Work: The authors emphasize the need for further research to:
- Elucidate the detailed mechanisms behind the extreme seasonal transitions in tropical CO2 fluxes.
- Investigate the coupling between seasonal carbon dynamics (spring/summer uptake vs. autumn release) in northern ecosystems and its frequency.
- Understand how future changes in autumn temperature and precipitation might impact annual carbon balances.
- Better reconcile findings from large-scale atmospheric inversions with site-level observations regarding drought impacts on tropical forests.
- Explore the drivers of carbon dynamics on seasonal or shorter timescales, particularly the link between these dynamics and climate extremes, using a combination of observations and dynamic vegetation models.
Summary updated