Vegetation Dynamic Assessment by NDVI and Field Observations for Sustainability of China’s Wulagai River Basin

Panpan Chen, Hua‐Min Liu, Zongming Wang, Dehua Mao, Cunzhu Liang, Lu Wen, Zhiyong Li, Jinghui Zhang, Dongwei Liu, Yi Zhuo, Lixin WangInternational Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study integrates satellite data (NDVI) with field observations to assess vegetation changes in China's Wulagai River Basin from 1997-2018. While NDVI shows an overall increasing trend, field data reveals that this doesn't always equate to ecosystem improvement, highlighting the need for nuanced indicators to guide sustainable grassland management.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Grasslands are vital for both ecological balance and human livelihoods, but their dynamics are complex and influenced by a multitude of factors. Accurately monitoring these changes is crucial for effective ecosystem restoration and management policies. However, a significant challenge exists in understanding whether broad-scale vegetation indices like NDVI truly reflect the health and diversity of plant communities, especially in regions undergoing development and policy shifts. The Wulagai River Basin, a key grassland area, lacked this detailed information, hindering regional development and sustainable practices. This paper aims to bridge this gap by combining remote sensing with ground-truth data to disentangle the drivers of vegetation change and assess the true state of different grassland ecosystems.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • NDVI Data Fusion: To create a continuous, high-resolution NDVI time-series, they fused data from the older, lower-resolution GIMMS AVHRR (1997-2006) and the higher-resolution MODIS (2000-2018) datasets. This was achieved using the Enhanced Spatial and Temporal Adaptive Reflectance Fusion Model (ESTARFM), a sophisticated algorithm designed to combine the strengths of different satellite sensors for improved spatial and temporal accuracy.
  • Residual Trend Analysis (RESTREND): This statistical method was key to differentiating between climate-driven and human-induced vegetation changes. It involves building a regression model between NDVI and climatic factors (precipitation and temperature) and then analyzing the residuals (the difference between observed and predicted NDVI). A significant downward trend in residuals suggests human impact (like overgrazing), while an upward trend indicates improvement. No trend implies climate as the primary driver.
  • Field Observations: To validate remote sensing findings, extensive field surveys were conducted in 1997 and 2018. These surveys meticulously documented plant species composition, diversity, average plant height, and aboveground biomass across different ecosystem types (meadow steppe, typical steppe, and riparian wet meadow).

Datasets

  • GIMMS AVHRR NDVI Data: Provided by the Cold and Arid Regions Scientific Data Center of China, with an 8 km spatial resolution and 15-day intervals from 1997 to 2006.
  • MODIS NDVI Data (MOD13Q1): Obtained from the USGS Land Processes Distributed Active Archive Center, offering a 250 m spatial resolution and 16-day intervals from 2000 to 2018.
  • Meteorological Data: Monthly precipitation and temperature data from January 1997 to December 2018, sourced from the China Meteorological Data Network.
  • Livestock and Crop Yield Statistics: Acquired from the Statistics Bureau of the Wulagai management district, used as proxies for anthropogenic drivers.
  • Field Plant Community Survey Data: Collected in 1997 and 2018 at 55 sampling sites, detailing species composition, height, and biomass.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NDVI is Not Always a Direct Indicator of Health: The most striking insight is that an increasing NDVI trend, often interpreted as improving vegetation, can mask underlying degradation. This occurs when annual plants or less diverse species replace dominant, more productive ones, leading to higher NDVI values without true ecosystem improvement.
  • Human Factors Dominate Vegetation Dynamics: The RESTREND analysis strongly suggests that anthropogenic activities, rather than climate alone, are the primary drivers of vegetation change in the Wulagai River Basin. This underscores the critical role of land-use policies.
  • Policy Shifts Matter: The study period coincided with significant changes in grassland management policies in Inner Mongolia. The analysis of residual trends across different sub-periods reveals how these policy shifts (from free grazing to contracted management and restoration efforts) influenced vegetation dynamics.
  • Ecosystem Heterogeneity is Crucial: Different ecosystem types within the basin responded differently. While meadow steppes showed signs of improvement in diversity and biomass, typical steppes and riparian wet meadows exhibited degradation, despite potentially increasing NDVI.

Key Results

  • Overall NDVI Trend: The NDVI across all examined ecosystem types showed a general increasing trend from 1997 to 2018.
  • RESTREND Findings:
    • The period 1997-2003 showed a declining trend in residuals for most ecosystem types, indicating degradation primarily driven by human activities (likely overgrazing).
  • The period 2003-2007 saw a shift, with an upward trend in residuals, suggesting vegetation improvement.
  • The period 2008-2018 showed a significant increase in residuals, indicating substantial vegetation improvement, likely linked to the implementation of new pasture management and restoration policies.
  • Field Observation Discrepancies:
    • Meadow Steppe: Field data confirmed an increase in species diversity and aboveground biomass, aligning with a positive succession trend.
  • Typical Steppe & Riparian Wet Meadow: Field observations indicated degradation in species diversity and biomass, contradicting the increasing NDVI trend.
  • Correlation with Human Factors: From 2001-2018, the NDVI residual trend was significantly negatively correlated with the rate of change in livestock density and positively correlated with the rate of change in total crop yield.

Limitations and Future Work

  • NDVI Limitations: The study explicitly acknowledges that NDVI alone cannot fully characterize the improvement or deterioration of all grassland types and may not reflect changes in dominant species. This highlights the need for integrated monitoring systems.
  • Data Availability: While the paper mentions data availability, it's important to note that the specific datasets used (e.g., detailed livestock data, precise meteorological station data) might have limitations in spatial or temporal coverage that could influence the analysis.
  • Future Work: The authors emphasize the necessity of selecting optimal indicators or indicator systems for formulating effective grassland management policies. Future research could focus on developing and validating such comprehensive indicator frameworks that integrate remote sensing, field data, and socio-economic factors to ensure the sustainability of grassland ecosystems. The study also suggests that further investigation into the specific mechanisms driving the observed discrepancies between NDVI and field observations is warranted.

Summary updated

Abstract

Accurate monitoring of grassland vegetation dynamics is essential for ecosystem restoration and the implementation of integrated management policies. A lack of information on vegetation changes in the Wulagai River Basin restricts regional development. Therefore, in this study, we integrated remote sensing, meteorological, and field plant community survey data in order to characterize vegetation and ecosystem changes from 1997 to 2018. The residual trend (RESTREND) method was utilized to detect vegetation changes caused by human factors, as well as to evaluate the impact of the management of pastures. Our results reveal that the normalized difference vegetation index (NDVI) of each examined ecosystem type showed an increasing trend, in which anthropogenic impact was the primary driving force of vegetation change. Our field survey confirmed that the meadow steppe ecosystem increased in species diversity and aboveground biomass; however, the typical steppe and riparian wet meadow ecosystems experienced species diversity and biomass degradation, therefore suggesting that an increase in NDVI may not directly reflect ecosystem improvement. Selecting an optimal indicator or indicator system is necessary in order to formulate reasonable grassland management policies for increasing the sustainability of grassland ecosystems.
BibTeX
@article{chen2021vegetation,
  author = {Panpan Chen and Hua‐Min Liu and Zongming Wang and Dehua Mao and Cunzhu Liang and Lu Wen and Zhiyong Li and Jinghui Zhang and Dongwei Liu and Yi Zhuo and Lixin Wang},
  title = {{Vegetation Dynamic Assessment by NDVI and Field Observations for Sustainability of China’s Wulagai River Basin}},
  journal = {International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/ijerph18052528},
}
Figure