VC dimensions of group convolutional neural networks

Philipp Christian Petersen, Anna SepliarskaiaNeural Networks 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper investigates the generalization capabilities of Group Convolutional Neural Networks (G-CNNs) by analyzing their VC dimensions. Counter-intuitively, they show that for infinite groups, even simple G-CNNs with a fixed kernel can have an infinite VC dimension, suggesting that increased symmetry doesn't always guarantee better learnability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Convolutional Neural Networks (CNNs) have achieved remarkable success, largely attributed to their built-in translation equivariance. This has inspired the development of Group Convolutional Neural Networks (G-CNNs) that incorporate other symmetries (like rotation, scale, etc.) to improve generalization. While it's generally assumed that more symmetries lead to better generalization, the theoretical understanding, particularly concerning sample complexity and VC dimensions, is still developing. This paper aims to provide a more nuanced understanding by analyzing the VC dimension of G-CNNs, specifically exploring whether increased group symmetry inherently leads to a lower VC dimension and thus better learnability.

Methods

The authors analyze the VC dimension of a specific class of G-CNNs: two-layer networks with one convolutional layer and one pooling layer, where the convolutional kernel is fixed, and only two bias parameters are learned. They derive upper bounds for the VC dimension for finite groups and establish lower bounds for both finite and infinite groups. The proofs involve intricate mathematical arguments related to set theory, group theory, and measure theory, including the construction of specific kernels and the analysis of "complete sets of orders" to demonstrate shattering.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is theoretical and focuses on mathematical properties rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Symmetry vs. Learnability Paradox: The core insight is that while G-CNNs are designed with more symmetries for better generalization, this doesn't automatically translate to a lower VC dimension. For infinite groups, even simple G-CNNs can exhibit infinite VC dimensions, implying potential learnability issues despite built-in symmetries.
  • Fixed Kernel Complexity: The paper highlights that even with a fixed convolutional kernel, the VC dimension can be surprisingly high, especially for infinite groups. This suggests that the complexity of the learned function class (defined by the G-CNN architecture and the group action) is crucial, not just the number of learnable parameters.
  • Counterpoint to Intuition: This work serves as a counterpoint to the prevailing intuition that increased symmetry always implies better generalization. It suggests a more complex interplay between group structure, kernel choice, and the resulting function class's VC dimension.

Key Results

  • Upper Bound for Finite Groups: For finite groups of size $n$, the VC dimension of the considered G-CNNs is bounded by $m \le \log_2(n) + 9 \log_2(\log_2(n))$ for sufficiently large $n$.
  • Lower Bound for Infinite Groups: For infinite groups, the paper demonstrates that there exists a kernel such that the VC dimension of the G-CNN class is at least $n$ for any $n \in \mathbb{N}$. This implies an infinite VC dimension.
  • Lower Bound for Finite Groups: For finite groups, they establish lower bounds that are roughly $\log_2(n) - 2\log_2(\log_2(n)) - 4$, showing that the VC dimension can grow with the group size.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Specific Architecture: The analysis is limited to a very specific, simple G-CNN architecture (two-layer, fixed kernel). The results might not directly generalize to deeper or more complex G-CNN architectures.
  • Theoretical Focus: The paper is highly theoretical and does not involve empirical validation on datasets. Future work could explore how these theoretical findings translate to practical performance on real-world tasks.
  • Kernel Choice: The lower bounds rely on the existence of "appropriately chosen" kernels. Understanding how to find such kernels in practice and their impact on performance remains an open question.
  • Infinite Groups: The result for infinite groups showing infinite VC dimension is a significant finding, but it raises questions about how to effectively learn with such models and whether specific kernel constructions or regularization techniques can mitigate this issue.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{petersen2024vc,
  author = {Philipp Christian Petersen and Anna Sepliarskaia},
  title = {{VC dimensions of group convolutional neural networks}},
  journal = {Neural Networks},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1016/j.neunet.2023.10.012},
}
Figure