Vascular Deformation Mapping of Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm

Drew J. Braet, Jonathan L. Eliason, Yunus Ahmed, Pieter A. J. van Bakel, Jiayang Zhong, Zhangxing Bian, C. Alberto Figueroa, Nicholas S. BurrisTomography 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces Vascular Deformation Mapping (VDM) as a novel 3D imaging technique to precisely track the growth of abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAAs). VDM offers a more detailed and sensitive assessment of AAA growth compared to traditional maximum diameter measurements, potentially improving surgical planning and risk prediction.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAAs) are dangerous bulges in the aorta that can rupture, leading to high mortality. Current monitoring relies heavily on measuring the maximum diameter of the AAA using CT angiography (CTA). However, this method has significant limitations: measurements can be variable, it doesn't reliably predict rupture risk or future growth, and it oversimplifies the complex 3D geometry of AAAs. This leaves a gap in accurately assessing AAA stability and predicting when intervention is necessary.

Methods

The core of this research is the application of Vascular Deformation Mapping (VDM) to AAAs. VDM is a technique that uses deformable image registration to create a detailed 3D map of how the aortic wall changes over time. Here's a breakdown of their approach:

  • Image Segmentation: The AAA lumen and intraluminal thrombus (ILT) were segmented from CTA scans to create an "aortic mask" representing the entire AAA.
  • Deformable Image Registration: This is the key VDM step. It involves aligning two CTA scans taken at different times (baseline and follow-up). The process uses a multi-step approach:
  • Rigid Registration: An initial alignment to roughly position the scans.
  • Deformable Registration (B-spline): A more sophisticated registration that allows the aortic shape to deform, creating a "deformation field." This field quantifies how points in the aorta have moved between scans.
  • 3D Growth Mapping: The deformation field is used to translate a mesh of the baseline aortic surface to the follow-up position. The change in surface area at each point on this mesh is calculated and represented as an "Area Ratio."
    • Area Ratio > 1: Indicates growth.
  • Area Ratio ≈ 1: Indicates stability.
  • Visualization: The Area Ratio values are color-coded and mapped onto the 3D surface of the aorta, creating a visual representation of where and how much growth has occurred.
  • Quality Assurance (QA): A rigorous QA protocol was implemented to ensure the accuracy of the VDM results, including checking segmentation, registration steps, and image alignment.

Datasets

The study utilized retrospective CTA data from seven patients with infra-renal AAAs who had at least two good-quality abdominal aortic CTAs. These were routine clinical scans obtained for surveillance purposes. No new datasets were created or introduced.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Beyond Diameter: The most significant insight is that maximum diameter is a crude measure for AAA growth. VDM reveals localized growth patterns that are completely missed by diameter measurements, especially in cases of minimal or moderate growth.
  • 3D Complexity Matters: AAAs are not simple tubes. Their complex, non-uniform shape means growth can be highly localized and eccentric, which VDM captures effectively.
  • Post-EVAR Potential: VDM shows promise in monitoring the excluded aneurysm sac after endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR), potentially helping to identify issues like endoleaks.
  • Sensitivity Advantage: VDM appears to be a more sensitive tool for detecting subtle changes in AAA geometry, which could lead to earlier detection of concerning growth.

Key Results

  • VDM successfully identified and quantified 3D growth (or lack thereof) in AAAs, even when maximum diameter measurements showed stability.
  • In one case (AAA3), VDM showed mild growth localized anteriorly, despite stable maximum diameter.
  • VDM could quantify growth in the excluded aneurysm sac after EVAR (demonstrated in patient AAA19).
  • While overall growth assessments by diameter and volume were often concordant for significant growth, VDM highlighted significant variability in the distribution and local intensity of growth, even when the overall growth magnitude was similar.
  • VDM analysis had a failure rate of 45.5% in this study, with common reasons including segmentation challenges with intraluminal thrombus (ILT) and registration errors.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Segmentation Challenges: Accurately segmenting the AAA wall and intraluminal thrombus (ILT) is crucial but difficult due to low contrast gradients, requiring extensive manual effort. This was a major contributor to VDM analysis failures.
  • Technical Expertise: The VDM method currently requires significant technical expertise and is not yet suited for routine clinical practice.
  • Small Sample Size: The study involved a small, heterogeneous cohort, and patient outcomes were not explicitly assessed.
  • Reproducibility: The reproducibility of the VDM technique was not assessed.

Future work should focus on:

  • Improving Technical Aspects: Enhancing segmentation accuracy (potentially with deep learning) and refining registration procedures, especially for cases with ILT.
  • Expanding Clinical Scenarios: Evaluating VDM in other AAA types (juxta-renal, thoracoabdominal), pre-rupture states, and post-intervention settings.
  • Validation: Systematically validating VDM's accuracy and consistency against established methods and clinical outcomes.
  • Biomarker Potential: Exploring VDM as a potential imaging biomarker for assessing longitudinal growth and the effectiveness of surgical or pharmacological treatments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abdominal aortic aneurysm (AAA) is a complex disease that requires regular imaging surveillance to monitor for aneurysm stability. Current imaging surveillance techniques use maximum diameter, often assessed by computed tomography angiography (CTA), to assess risk of rupture and determine candidacy for operative repair. However, maximum diameter measurements can be variable, do not reliably predict rupture risk and future AAA growth, and may be an oversimplification of complex AAA anatomy. Vascular deformation mapping (VDM) is a recently described technique that uses deformable image registration to quantify three-dimensional changes in aortic wall geometry, which has been previously used to quantify three-dimensional (3D) growth in thoracic aortic aneurysms, but the feasibility of the VDM technique for measuring 3D growth in AAA has not yet been studied. Seven patients with infra-renal AAAs were identified and VDM was used to identify three-dimensional maps of AAA growth. In the present study, we demonstrate that VDM is able to successfully identify and quantify 3D growth (and the lack thereof) in AAAs that is not apparent from maximum diameter. Furthermore, VDM can be used to quantify growth of the excluded aneurysm sac after endovascular aneurysm repair (EVAR). VDM may be a useful adjunct for surgical planning and appears to be a sensitive modality for detecting regional growth of AAAs.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{braet2021vascular,
  author = {Drew J. Braet and Jonathan L. Eliason and Yunus Ahmed and Pieter A. J. van Bakel and Jiayang Zhong and Zhangxing Bian and C. Alberto Figueroa and Nicholas S. Burris},
  title = {{Vascular Deformation Mapping of Abdominal Aortic Aneurysm}},
  booktitle = {Tomography},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/tomography7020017},
}
Figure