Variational Cumulant Expansions for Intractable Distributions

David Barber, Piërre van de LaararXiv 2011 · DOI · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "variational cumulant expansion" method to better approximate intractable probability distributions, a common challenge in probabilistic modeling. By extending standard variational methods with higher-order corrections, they achieve improved accuracy in tasks like learning and inference, particularly for Boltzmann machines, without a significant increase in computational cost.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Probabilistic models are powerful for representing uncertainty, but many real-world problems involve complex probability distributions that are computationally intractable to work with directly. This intractability arises from the difficulty in calculating essential quantities like normalizing constants, which are needed for inference and learning. While variational methods offer a popular approximation technique, their accuracy is often limited by the flexibility of the chosen approximating distribution, and increasing this flexibility can lead to even greater computational burdens. This paper aims to bridge this gap by providing a way to improve the accuracy of variational approximations without drastically increasing computational complexity.

Methods

The core contribution is a variational cumulant expansion. This method starts with a family of probability distributions that smoothly interpolate between an intractable target distribution ($Q_1$) and a tractable approximating distribution ($Q_0$). The normalizing constant of this interpolating distribution is then expanded as a Taylor series around the tractable limit. This expansion naturally leads to a cumulant expansion, where each term involves higher-order statistics (cumulants) of the difference between the potentials of the target and approximating distributions, calculated with respect to the tractable distribution.

  • Standard Variational Method: The paper first reviews the standard approach, which minimizes the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence between $Q_1$ and $Q_0$ to obtain a lower bound on the log-normalizing constant of $Q_1$.
  • Cumulant Expansion: The novel part is extending this by treating the interpolating distribution's log-normalizing constant as a function of a parameter $\alpha$ (ranging from 0 to 1). A Taylor expansion of this function around $\alpha=0$ (the tractable case) yields the cumulant expansion.
  • Higher-Order Corrections: The first-order term of this expansion recovers the standard variational bound. Higher-order terms introduce corrections based on the cumulants of the potential difference, aiming to improve accuracy.
  • Criteria for Parameter Selection: The paper discusses two criteria for setting the parameters of the tractable distribution $Q_0$: the "bound criterion" (maximizing the lower bound) and the "independence criterion" (related to statistical physics methods like TAP).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical development and simulation results using synthetic models (Boltzmann machines with randomly drawn parameters).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging Variational and Perturbational Methods: The cumulant expansion provides a principled way to extend variational methods, connecting them to perturbational approaches from statistical physics (like TAP).
  • Accuracy vs. Tractability Trade-off: The method offers a way to gain accuracy beyond the standard variational bound without incurring the full computational cost of more complex approximating distributions.
  • Cumulants as Information Sources: Higher-order cumulants of the potential difference capture information about the target distribution that is missed by simpler approximations, leading to improved estimates.
  • Loss of Strict Bound: A key trade-off is that while the first-order term provides a strict lower bound, higher-order terms, by improving accuracy, can violate this bound. This means the approximation is no longer guaranteed to be a lower bound.
  • Stability and Applicability: The method is shown to be applicable to Boltzmann machines and is suggested to be transparent and readily applicable to other variational methods and model types.

Key Results

  • Improved Normalizing Constant Approximation: Simulations on Boltzmann machines demonstrated that the second-order cumulant expansion significantly improves the approximation of the normalizing constant compared to the standard first-order (variational) approach. For a factorized model, the mean absolute error dropped from 0.036 to 0.0079. Using a more flexible decimatable model further reduced the error.
  • Enhanced Learning Dynamics: In a learning scenario, the higher-order corrections improved the accuracy of monitoring the training set likelihood, leading to more reliable learning dynamics compared to the standard variational approach.
  • Better Correlation Estimates: The method also showed improvements in approximating correlations (e.g., $\langle s_i s_j \rangle$) compared to standard variational methods.
  • Numerical Stability: The paper suggests that the approach might offer more stable solutions compared to some TAP methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Loss of Lower Bound: A significant limitation is that higher-order cumulant expansions do not guarantee a lower bound on the quantity of interest (e.g., the normalizing constant). This means that estimates can, in principle, exceed the true value.
  • Physical Constraints: The paper acknowledges that the perturbational approach might violate known "physical" constraints (e.g., moments being bounded between 0 and 1). Developing methods that ensure physical solutions is an area for future work.
  • Parameter Selection: While criteria for setting variational parameters are discussed, the paper suggests exploring other suitable criteria.
  • Multimodal Distributions: The authors note that for strongly multimodal distributions, a unimodal variational approximation might not be significantly improved by higher-order corrections. Conversely, higher-order corrections to multimodal approximations could be very beneficial.
  • Broader Applicability: Future work includes applying these methods to variational techniques beyond the standard KL bound and exploring other criteria for setting variational parameters.

Summary updated

Abstract

Intractable distributions present a common difficulty in inference within the probabilistic knowledge representation framework and variational methods have recently been popular in providing an approximate solution. In this article, we describe a perturbational approach in the form of a cumulant expansion which, to lowest order, recovers the standard Kullback-Leibler variational bound. Higher-order terms describe corrections on the variational approach without incurring much further computational cost. The relationship to other perturbational approaches such as TAP is also elucidated. We demonstrate the method on a particular class of undirected graphical models, Boltzmann machines, for which our simulation results confirm improved accuracy and enhanced stability during learning.
BibTeX
@misc{barber2011variational,
  author = {David Barber and Piërre van de Laar},
  title = {{Variational Cumulant Expansions for Intractable Distributions}},
  year = {2011},
  eprint = {1105.5455},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1105.5455},
}
Figure