Varianten antiker Kapitelltypen in Piero della Francescas Bildarchitektur

Peter SeilerheiDOK 2015 · DOI

Introduction

Piero della Francesca is celebrated for the mathematical precision of his perspective, yet his architectural "competence" extends far beyond geometry. This paper examines the "micro-architecture" of column capitals in his work to determine how he acquired and adapted ancient forms. It argues that Piero was not a mere follower of contemporary theorists like Alberti, but a "creative adapter" who synthesized rare ancient models with established pictorial traditions.

The Quest for Sources

Art historians have long debated whether Piero’s knowledge came from direct observation of Roman ruins, the theoretical treatises of Leon Battista Alberti, or his time in Brunelleschian Florence. By performing a granular formal analysis of capitals in works like the Flagellation of Christ and the Arezzo Frescoes, this study identifies a more complex path of influence that relies heavily on intermediate visual sources.

Methodology

The research employs a two-pronged approach: comparative formal analysis and database-driven research using the Census of Antique Works of Art and Architecture Known in the Renaissance. This allows for the identification of specific morphological features—such as "volutes with rosettes" or "lanceolate leaves"—that link Piero’s painted architecture to known ancient prototypes documented during the 15th century.

Piero as a Creative Adapter

A key finding is that Piero was not a literal copyist. Instead, he acted as a "creative adapter," modifying the "apparatus of forms" to suit his pictorial concepts. He prioritized stylistic consistency and abstract shapes over archaeological precision. For instance, his capitals often diverge from Alberti’s strict rules in De re aedificatoria, incorporating decorative elements like blossom stalks and tendrils that the theorist specifically omitted or described differently.

The Role of Intermediate Drawings

The study suggests that Piero likely accessed ancient models through intermediate workshop drawings rather than direct site visits alone. His composite capitals often share specific modifications or "errors" found in contemporary sketchbooks, indicating that architectural knowledge was "traded" between painters and architects through these pattern books.

Renaissance workshop drawing documenting ancient capital forms, providing a repertoire for artists like Piero.

Architectural Innovation

Piero’s most innovative designs, such as the 16-volute capital in the Flagellation of Christ, represent a "corinthianizing" of the composite type. This innovation aligns with the "principle of variety" prevalent in 15th-century Florentine painting rather than strict Roman practice. These designs show a sophisticated interest in rare ancient types, such as Ionic capitals with decorated necks, which were not yet part of the standard Renaissance architectural repertoire.

Composite capitals in Piero's work, showcasing the 'corinthianizing' of the type with intricate volute pairs.

Conclusion

Piero della Francesca’s architectural vocabulary was a sophisticated synthesis of rare ancient models, workshop traditions, and creative invention. His work demonstrates that for the Renaissance master, architecture was not merely a backdrop but a primary site for artistic and intellectual exploration, bridging the gap between archaeological study and pictorial innovation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{seiler2015varianten,
  author = {Peter Seiler},
  title = {{Varianten antiker Kapitelltypen in Piero della Francescas Bildarchitektur}},
  booktitle = {heiDOK},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.11588/artdok.00003184},
}
Figure