Variable Elimination in Binary CSPs (Extended Abstract)

Martin C. Cooper, Achref El Mouelhi, Cyril TerriouxIJCAI 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces new, efficient rules for "variable elimination" in Constraint Satisfaction Problems (CSPs). These rules allow us to simplify CSP instances by removing variables without losing the ability to find solutions, and importantly, without introducing new, complex constraints. This work leads to more efficient solving of certain types of CSPs and defines new tractable classes of problems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Constraint Satisfaction Problems (CSPs) are fundamental to many areas of AI and computer science, but many are NP-hard, meaning finding solutions can be computationally very expensive. A common technique to tackle this is "variable elimination," where we try to remove variables from the problem to simplify it. However, standard variable elimination can sometimes introduce new, high-arity constraints, which can be counterproductive. This paper addresses the challenge of developing variable elimination rules that don't introduce new constraints and guarantee that if a solution exists in the original problem, it can still be found (and even reconstructed) in the simplified problem. This is crucial for both practical problem-solving and theoretical understanding of CSP tractability.

Methods

The core of this paper is the proposal and analysis of novel "satisfiability-conserving variable-elimination" (sol-var-elim) conditions. These are properties of a variable that, if met, allow its removal while preserving satisfiability and enabling the reconstruction of a solution. The authors introduce several such conditions:

  • DE-snake property: A condition based on the compatibility of values between variables, ensuring that incompatible values can be "fixed" by changing them to compatible ones.
  • Triangle property: A condition that ensures a certain local structure (an "open-triangle pattern") doesn't occur, simplifying relationships between variables.
  • Broken Polyhedron properties (including Broken Triangle and Broken Tetrahedron): These are generalizations of the triangle property, extending the concept to higher dimensions. The paper specifically defines the "broken k-dimensional polyhedron property" and the "∀∃ broken k-dimensional polyhedron property."

For each proposed rule, the authors provide theoretical guarantees (sol-var-elim conditions) and analyze their computational complexity for detection and application. They also compare the rules to each other, showing they are largely incomparable, meaning each rule can identify simplifications that others might miss.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical properties and algorithms rather than empirical evaluation on specific datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Elimination without new constraints is key: The most significant insight is the focus on variable elimination rules that do not introduce new, potentially complex constraints. This is a critical practical consideration for CSP solvers.
  • Tractable classes from elimination: The paper demonstrates that these variable elimination rules can be used to define new "tractable classes" of CSPs. This means that if a CSP instance belongs to one of these classes, it can be solved in polynomial time.
  • Reconstructing solutions is guaranteed: A crucial aspect is that these rules are "sol-var-elim," meaning not only is satisfiability preserved, but a solution to the original problem can be reconstructed from a solution to the simplified problem.
  • Generalizing geometric patterns: The extension from "broken triangles" to "broken polyhedra" is a neat theoretical generalization, showing how geometric intuitions can inform CSP algorithms.
  • Surprising tractability for triangle property: The authors note it was surprising to find that finding the optimal elimination order for the triangle property could be done in polynomial time.

Key Results

  • New sol-var-elim conditions: The paper formally defines and proves that the DE-snake, triangle, and broken k-dimensional polyhedron properties are sol-var-elim conditions.
  • Polynomial-time detection and application: Algorithms are provided for detecting and applying these rules, with complexities like O(ed³) for DE-snake and O(end³) for the triangle property.
  • Incomparable rules: The DE-snake, triangle, and ∀∃BTP rules are shown to be pairwise incomparable, highlighting their distinct strengths.
  • Hybrid tractable classes: Each rule defines a hybrid tractable class that can be detected and solved in polynomial time.
  • Maximizing eliminations is tractable: Maximizing the number of variables eliminated using these rules (or combinations with other techniques) is also shown to be achievable in polynomial time.
  • Practical impact: Experimental results (mentioned as being in a full paper) confirm that applying these rules during preprocessing helps solve more benchmark instances.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational cost: While the rules are theoretically efficient, the paper acknowledges that the time complexity of detecting and applying them can still be prohibitive for very large or complex instances, suggesting they are best used in preprocessing.
  • Number of solutions: The DE-snake rule, like its predecessor "snake," can potentially increase the number of solutions after elimination, which might be undesirable in some applications.
  • Theoretical interest of broken polyhedra: The authors note that while the broken k-dimensional polyhedron property is theoretically interesting, its practical application might be limited by its high computational cost.
  • Future work: The paper suggests exploring further experimental validation and potentially combining these rules with other CSP techniques to achieve even greater efficiency.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{cooper2020variable,
  author = {Martin C. Cooper and Achref El Mouelhi and Cyril Terrioux},
  title = {{Variable Elimination in Binary CSPs (Extended Abstract)}},
  booktitle = {International Joint Conference on Artificial Intelligence},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.24963/ijcai.2020/702},
}
Figure