VARIABILITY OF THE ACCRETION DISK OF V926 Sco INFERRED FROM TOMOGRAPHIC ANALYSIS

Stephen Connolly, Charith Peris, S. D. VrtilekThe Astrophysical Journal 2013 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses advanced spectroscopic analysis (Doppler and modulation tomography) of the low-mass X-ray binary V926 Sco to reveal changes in its accretion disk. The findings suggest the system is currently in a lower accretion state, leading to reduced velocities and less emission from the secondary star, compared to previous observations.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Low-mass X-ray binaries (LMXBs) are systems where a compact object (like a neutron star) accretes matter from a companion star. Understanding the dynamics of the accretion disk and how it changes over time is crucial for comprehending accretion processes and the evolution of these systems. V926 Sco, an "atoll" type LMXB, has a known orbital period and has been studied previously, with earlier work suggesting an asymmetric "bulge" in its accretion disk. However, direct tomographic analysis of its emission lines, particularly H$\alpha$, and a comparison of its state over time were lacking. This paper aims to provide a more detailed picture of V926 Sco's accretion disk by using advanced tomographic techniques and comparing new observations with older data to identify changes in the system's behavior.

Methods

The researchers employed phase-resolved spectroscopy, collecting light from V926 Sco at different points in its orbital cycle. They used the IMACS spectrograph on the Walter Baade 6.5m Magellan telescope. The core of their analysis involved two powerful techniques:

  • Doppler Tomography: This method reconstructs a 2D velocity-space map of the emitting regions within the system by analyzing how spectral lines shift at different orbital phases. It assumes the emission is a projection of the system's velocity distribution.
  • Modulation Tomography: This technique builds upon Doppler tomography by also accounting for variations in the brightness of different components within the system over the orbit. This allows for a more accurate interpretation of the velocity maps, especially when dealing with systems where emission is not constant.

They specifically analyzed the H$\alpha$, He II $\lambda$4686, and Bowen fluorescence lines. By fitting Gaussian profiles to these lines, they extracted parameters like FWHM (line width, related to velocity) and equivalent width (a measure of emission strength).

Datasets

The primary dataset consists of spectroscopic observations of V926 Sco obtained in June 2010 and June 2011 using the Walter Baade 6.5m Magellan telescope. These observations were phase-resolved, covering approximately 1.5 orbital periods in total.

For comparison and context, the paper references:

  • Previous spectroscopic observations of V926 Sco from June 2003 (Casares et al. 2006).
  • X-ray light curves from the RXTE/ASM ( Rossi X-ray Timing Explorer All Sky Monitor), spanning a period of 15 years, to correlate with the optical observations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Lower Accretion State: The most significant finding is the evidence that V926 Sco is currently in a lower accretion state compared to its 2003 observations. This is supported by lower X-ray fluxes and reduced velocities observed in the optical emission lines.
  • Reduced Secondary Star Emission: The lower equivalent widths of the Bowen fluorescence lines (which are thought to originate from the secondary star being irradiated by the primary's X-rays) suggest reduced irradiation. This is a direct consequence of the lower accretion rate and thus lower UV flux from the compact object.
  • Persistent Disk Bulge: Despite the change in accretion state, the tomographic analysis still indicates the presence of an asymmetric bulge in the accretion disk, consistent with earlier findings. This suggests that the disk structure itself might be more persistent than the overall accretion rate.
  • Velocity Changes: The observed decrease in the FWHM of emission lines implies lower velocities within the accretion disk. This is a key indicator of the system's lower activity level.

Key Results

  • A derived systemic velocity of -109 $\pm$ 4 km s$^{-1}$ from H$\alpha$ radial velocities.
  • Significantly lower FWHM for emission lines (H$\alpha$, He II $\lambda$4686, Bowen blend) compared to previous observations, indicating reduced velocities.
  • Equivalent widths of Bowen fluorescence lines are factors of two or more lower than reported in 2003, suggesting reduced irradiation of the secondary star.
  • Doppler and modulation tomography of H$\alpha$ and He II $\lambda$4686 confirm an asymmetric emission bulge in the accretion disk.
  • Concurrent X-ray fluxes are significantly lower during the 2010-2011 observations compared to 2003, supporting the lower accretion state hypothesis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited 2010 Phase Coverage: The 2010 observations had insufficient phase coverage for detailed analysis of some features, particularly for the Bowen blend, necessitating the use of 2011 data for tomographic analysis of this line.
  • Instrumental Counts for EW: While equivalent widths were measured, they were in instrumental counts, not absolute fluxes, preventing direct comparison of overall brightness changes without additional calibration.
  • Eccentric Disk Possibility: The paper notes that the observed crescent-shaped emission in the H$\alpha$ tomogram could suggest an eccentric disk, a phenomenon seen in systems with mass ratios below ~0.33. However, superhumps, which are typically associated with eccentric disks, have not been detected in V926 Sco.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that higher resolution observations at different epochs are needed to confirm or refute the possibility of an eccentric disk. Further studies could also investigate the transport of angular momentum by density waves in the disk, as hinted at by the tomographic results.

Summary updated

Abstract

We present phase-resolved spectroscopic observations of the low-mass X-ray binary V926 Sco (4U 1735-44), covering the orbital period of 0.23d, obtained with the Walter Baade 6.5m Magellan Telescope at the Las Campanas Observatory in June 2010 and June 2011. We use H$\alpha$ radial velocities to derive a systemic velocity of -109 $\pm$ 4 km s$^{-1}$. The FWHM of the lines observed in common with previous authors are significantly lower during our observations suggesting much reduced velocities in the system. The equivalent width of the Bowen fluorescence lines with respect to He II $\lambda$4686 are factors of two or more lower during our observations in comparison to those previously reported for the system, suggesting reduced irradiation of the secondary. Doppler and modulation tomography of H$\alpha$ and He II $\lambda$4686 show assymmetric emission that can be attributed to a bulge in the accretion disk, as inferred from He II observations by previous authors. The X-ray fluxes from the source at times concurrent with the optical observations are significantly lower during our observations than during optical observations taken in 2003. We suggest that the system is in a lower accretion state compared to earlier observations; this explains both the lower velocities observed from the disk and the reduction of emission due to Bowen fluorescence detected from the secondary.
BibTeX
@article{connolly2013variability,
  author = {Stephen Connolly and Charith Peris and S. D. Vrtilek},
  title = {{VARIABILITY OF THE ACCRETION DISK OF V926 Sco INFERRED FROM TOMOGRAPHIC ANALYSIS}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1088/0004-637x/777/2/171},
}

Loading related content...

Figure