Valve Transform Fuzzy Tuning Algorithm for Open-centre Electro-hydraulic Systems

Qin Zhang, Dave R. Meinhold, John J. KroneJournal of Agricultural Engineering Research 1999 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a generic fuzzy tuning algorithm to automatically adjust valve control parameters in open-centre electro-hydraulic systems. This approach enables accurate velocity control by mimicking closed-centre system behavior, overcoming the inherent non-linearities and load variations that plague traditional control methods.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Electro-hydraulic actuator systems are widely used in mobile equipment due to their cost-effectiveness and robustness. However, open-centre valve systems, while cheaper, suffer from significant non-linearities. These include variations in system deadband and velocity gain, especially when the load on the actuator changes. Traditional PID controllers struggle to compensate for these dynamic shifts, leading to poor control performance. While adaptive control offers a solution, tuning these systems to handle the complex interplay of valve characteristics, system load, and actuator dynamics has been a major challenge. This paper aims to bridge this gap by developing a systematic and generic method for tuning valve transforms in feedforward controllers for these systems.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution is a "Valve Transform Fuzzy Tuning Algorithm." This algorithm operates on a "common sense model" of system calibration, aiming for generality and ease of application across different systems. The approach involves:

  • Actuator Operation Identification: The system first identifies the current operating conditions, classifying the load's magnitude and direction, as well as the actuator's motion direction (extension or retraction). This classification is crucial for selecting appropriate control strategies.
  • Fuzzy Load Quantization: Real-valued system load data is converted into fuzzy-valued linguistic terms (e.g., "light," "medium," "heavy"). This fuzzy mapping allows the controller to reason about load conditions in a more human-like, intuitive way.
  • Valve Transform Database: A database stores pre-defined "baseline valve transforms" for various operating conditions. These transforms represent different control strategies tailored to specific load and motion scenarios.
  • Executive Valve Transform Tuning: Based on the identified operating conditions, the algorithm selects relevant baseline valve transforms. A defuzzification process then combines these selected transforms, weighted by their confidence factors, to generate a single "executive valve transform." This executive transform is the actual control signal sent to the valve.
  • Generality: The algorithm is designed to be generic, meaning it can be applied to different hydraulic systems without significant modification, provided their operations are similar.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on dynamic simulation and laboratory tests using a specific hydraulic actuator setup.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Common Sense" Control: The paper champions a "common sense" approach to control, translating intuitive operational rules (like "open the valve quickly to avoid deadband" or "partly close the valve to avoid overrun") into a fuzzy logic framework. This makes the control logic more understandable and potentially easier to adapt.
  • Generality is Key: The algorithm's ability to be applied to different hydraulic systems with minimal modification is a significant advantage. This reduces development time and effort for new applications.
  • Fuzzy Logic for Non-linearity: Fuzzy logic proves to be an effective tool for handling the inherent non-linearities of open-centre hydraulic systems, which are notoriously difficult to model and control with traditional methods.
  • Bridging Open-Centre and Closed-Centre Performance: The fuzzy tuning algorithm allows open-centre systems to achieve performance characteristics typically associated with more expensive closed-centre systems, offering a cost-effective path to improved control.

Key Results

  • Simulation: Dynamic simulations of a large-scale 1-DOF hydraulic linear actuator demonstrated that the fuzzy tuning algorithm could promptly and accurately tune valve transforms for identified operating conditions. It achieved effective compensation for accurate velocity control.
  • Reduced Deadband: The fuzzy tuning algorithm reduced system deadband by up to 90% under heavy load conditions compared to baseline open-loop feedforward control.
  • High Velocity Control Accuracy: The algorithm achieved high velocity control accuracy of ±5% at maximum commanded velocity.
  • Laboratory Tests: Tests on a laboratory-scale 1-DOF actuator confirmed the simulation results. The algorithm adapted well to a smaller system with no modification. Velocity error was less than 5% for over 95% of the testing period.
  • Overcoming Non-linearity: The fuzzy tuning algorithm successfully overcame the high non-linearity of the actuator, enabling reasonable and smooth control even with components exhibiting significant hysteresis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Pump Capacity Limit: The paper notes that when the commanded velocity exceeds the pump's capacity, control performance may be limited.
  • Fixed Load in Lab Tests: Laboratory tests were conducted with a fixed load, and the paper suggests further investigation into dynamic load conditions.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that with the development of fuzzy tuning control technologies, open-centre systems can achieve closed-centre control characteristics, making them more attractive for mobile machinery. Further exploration of this potential is implied.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhang1999valve,
  author = {Qin Zhang and Dave R. Meinhold and John J. Krone},
  title = {{Valve Transform Fuzzy Tuning Algorithm for Open-centre Electro-hydraulic Systems}},
  journal = {Journal of Agricultural Engineering Research},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1006/jaer.1998.0413},
}
Figure