Value of intraoperative frozen section analysis in re-excision margin evaluation in breast-conserving surgery for cancer: a single institution experience

Jian Shen, Lin Bo Wang, Zi Nong Jiang, Xiao Ming Yuan, Wen Zhao, Jun ShenResearch 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Background: Previous studies have demonstrated that in women with breast cancer treated with breast-conserving surgery (BCS), intraoperative frozen section analysis of lumpectomy margins results in a decrease in reoperation rates for margin control. However, the value of intraoperative frozen margin evaluation (FME) in re-excision margin analysis is not fully understood. We analyzed our breast cancer database to identify the value of intraoperative frozen section examination of specimens additionally resected prior to BCS.

Methods: We conducted a retrospective review of patients who underwent attempted BCS for breast cancer with routine intraoperative FME at our institution between January 1998 and May 2016. The number of FMEs was analyzed. We additionally analyzed factors associated with positive re-excised margins to identify correlations with patient characteristics.

Results: Of the 760 patients who underwent attempted BCS with routinely conducted intraoperative FME, frozen sections were obtained from the initial margin only in 82.5% (n=627), the initial margin as well as a one-time re-excision analysis in 15.8% (n=120), or the initial margin and two or more re-excision analyses in 1.7% (n=13). Based on the results of FME, 727 (95.6%) of the patients underwent BCS, while the remaining 33 (4.4%) converted to mastectomy. Among the patients who underwent BCS, 112 (15.4%) had an initial positive margin on a FME, underwent one-time margin re-excision and achieved a margin-free status, while 1.6% underwent a second margin resection due to a positive result on the first re-excised margin. In total, 72.7% of the conversions to mastectomy were due to a positive initial margin. Univariate and multivariate analyses showed that patients with the ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) histological type were more likely to have repeatedly positive re-excised margins during BCS.

Conclusion: While routine intraoperative FME of re-excised margins provided only limited value in patients who underwent attempted BCS, this method may be beneficial in the subgroup of patients with the DCIS histological type.

Introduction

Breast-conserving surgery (BCS) aims to achieve oncological safety by removing the tumor with clear margins while preserving the aesthetic appearance of the breast. Achieving "negative margins"—the absence of cancer cells at the surgical edge—is critical, as positive margins significantly increase the risk of local recurrence. Intraoperative Frozen Margin Evaluation (FME) has become a standard tool to reduce the need for secondary surgeries by allowing surgeons to immediately re-excise positive margins while the patient is still in the operating room.

However, the clinical utility of performing FME on these secondary "re-excised" margins remains a subject of debate. This study evaluates whether the routine use of FME for re-excision specimens provides significant clinical value or if it represents an inefficient use of resources.

Methods and Patient Population

This retrospective study analyzed a cohort of 760 patients who underwent attempted BCS at Sir Run Run Shaw Hospital (Zhejiang University) between January 1998 and May 2016. The surgical protocol involved routine intraoperative FME. If an initial margin was positive or suspicious, a "cavity shaving" was performed to remove additional tissue.

Table 1: Baseline clinical and pathological characteristics of the 760 patients included in the study.

The researchers tracked the number of FMEs per patient and analyzed the correlation between margin status and various clinical factors, including age, tumor size, and histology.

Results

The study found that 95.6% of patients successfully completed BCS, with only 4.4% requiring conversion to mastectomy. The majority of patients (82.5%) achieved clear margins after the initial FME.

The Diminishing Returns of Re-excision FME

For the 15.8% of patients who required a re-excision, most achieved clear margins after a single additional snip. Only 1.7% of the total cohort required two or more re-excision analyses. Crucially, 72.7% of the conversions to mastectomy were triggered by the results of the initial margin evaluation rather than subsequent re-excisions, suggesting that the initial assessment is the primary driver of major surgical shifts.

Histology as a Key Predictor

A significant finding was the impact of tumor histology on margin status. Patients with Ductal Carcinoma In Situ (DCIS) were significantly more likely to require multiple re-excisions compared to those with invasive breast carcinoma (IBC).

Table 2: Comparison of clinical factors across patients requiring different numbers of frozen margin evaluations, highlighting the significance of histology.

As shown in the data, the P-value for histology was 0.003, indicating that DCIS is a strong independent predictor of persistently positive margins. This is likely due to the "skip" growth pattern characteristic of DCIS, which makes it harder to clear in a single surgical pass.

Discussion and Conclusion

The findings suggest that while FME is invaluable for the initial surgical margin, its routine application to re-excised margins offers limited benefit for the majority of patients, particularly those with invasive carcinoma. For these patients, thorough cavity shaving without additional FME might be a viable, more efficient approach.

However, the study underscores that FME remains a critical safeguard for patients with DCIS. Given the higher likelihood of multiple positive margins in this subgroup, intraoperative evaluation of re-excised tissue is essential to ensure complete tumor removal and minimize the risk of recurrence.

Limitations

The study is limited by its retrospective design and the long duration of data collection (18 years), during which surgical and pathological standards evolved. Additionally, as a single-institution study, the results may reflect specific local practices that are not universal. Future prospective trials are recommended to determine if omitting re-excision FME in invasive cancer cases impacts long-term local control.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background. Previous studies have demonstrated that in women with breast cancer treated with breast-conserving surgery (BCS), intraoperative frozen section analysis of lumpectomy margins results in a decrease in reoperation rates for margin control. However, the value of intraoperative frozen margin evaluation (FME) in re-excision margin analysis is not fully understood. We analyzed our breast cancer database to identify the value of intraoperative frozen section examination of specimens additionally resected prior to BCS. Methods. We conducted a retrospective review of patients who underwent attempted BCS for breast cancer with routine intraoperative FME at our institution between January 1998 and May 2016. The number of FMEs was analyzed. We additionally analyzed factors associated with positive re-excised margins to identify correlations with patient characteristics. Results. Of the 760 patients who underwent attempted BCS with routinely conducted intraoperative FME, frozen sections were obtained from the initial margin only in 82.5% (n=627), the initial margin as well as a one-time re-excision analysis in 15.8% (n=120), or the initial margin and two or more re-excision analyses in 1.7% (n-13). Based on the results of FME, 727 (95.6%) of the patients underwent BCS, while the remaining 33 (4.4%) converted to mastectomy. Among the patients who underwent BCS, 112 (15.4%) had an initial positive margin on a FME, underwent one-time margin re-excision and achieved a margin-free status, while 1.6% underwent a second margin resection due to a positive result on the first re-excised margin. In total, 72.7% of the conversions to mastectomy were due to a positive initial margin. Univariate and multivariate analyses showed that patients with the ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) histological type were more likely to have repeatedly positive re-excised margins during BCS. Conclusion. While routine intraoperative FME of re-excised margins provided only limited value in patients who underwent attempted BCS, this method may be beneficial in the subgroup of patients with the DCIS histological type.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{shen2020value,
  author = {Jian Shen and Lin Bo Wang and Zi Nong Jiang and Xiao Ming Yuan and Wen Zhao and Jun Shen and Jun Shen and Jun Shen},
  title = {{Value of intraoperative frozen section analysis in re-excision margin evaluation in breast-conserving surgery for cancer: a single institution experience}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-21408/v1},
}
Figure