Value incoherence precedes value change: Evidence from value development in childhood and adolescence across cultures

Ella Daniel, Anat Bardi, Julie Lee, Ricarda Scholz-Kuhn, Einat Elizarov, Jan Cieciuch, Ariel Knafo‐Noam, Alice Ramos, Michele Vecchione, René Algesheimer, Evelia Murcia Álvarez, Avital Ben Dror Lankry, Maya Benish‐Weisman, Ricardo Borges Rodrigues, Anat Chomsky, Patricia R. Collins, Eldad Davidov, Anna K. Döring, Stefanie Habermann, Dana Katsoty, Martin Kindschi, Elena Makarova, Gilda Marsicano, Kinneret Misgav, Thomas P. Oeschger, Leonor Pereira da Costa, Joanne Sneddon, Iva Tendais, Louise Twito -WeingartenEuropean 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study provides the first empirical evidence that a lack of internal consistency in personal values (value incoherence) predicts subsequent changes in those values among children and adolescents. This suggests that psychological "messiness" in our core goals can be a catalyst for personal development and change.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The paper tackles a fundamental question in developmental psychology: how does personality change, particularly during the formative years of childhood and adolescence? While theories suggest that internal coherence is a marker of maturity and that incoherence can drive change, empirical testing of this idea, especially within a specific personality system like values, has been limited. Values are deeply personal goals that guide our behavior and shape our identity. Understanding how the organization (or disorganization) of these values influences their evolution is crucial for understanding personality development. Previous research has shown that adult values are quite stable, but children and adolescents are in a period of significant value development. This study aims to bridge this gap by investigating whether a lack of internal consistency in a young person's value system at one point in time predicts how much their values will shift later.

Methods

The researchers employed a multi-faceted approach to assess value incoherence and value change across a large, diverse sample.

  • Value Incoherence Measurement: They used unfolding analysis, a technique rooted in Coombs' theory of preferential choice, to model the internal structure of each participant's values. This analysis essentially maps individuals and values onto a psychological space. The "fit" of an individual's value profile to this map, specifically their alienation coefficient (K), served as the measure of incoherence. A higher K indicates a greater divergence from the expected value structure. They compared this fit to two reference structures:
  • Normative Model: Based on the value structure observed within each specific cultural sample.
  • Theoretical Model: Based on Schwartz's well-established universal theoretical structure of values.
  • Value Change Estimation:
    • For participants with at least three measurement points, Latent Growth Curve Modeling was used to estimate individual change trajectories (slopes) for each of the 10 basic values.
  • For all participants with at least two measurement points, value change was calculated as the simple difference between Time 1 and Time 2 scores.
  • Two primary indicators of value change were derived: the variance of change across all values (reflecting shifts in multiple directions) and the absolute maximal change (reflecting the largest shift in any single value).
  • Association and Meta-Analysis:
    • Pearson correlations were used within each sample to link individual incoherence (K) with value change measures.
  • A random-effects meta-analysis was then conducted to synthesize these findings across all 13 samples, providing an overall estimate of the association between value incoherence and value change. This also allowed for the investigation of potential moderating effects, such as age.

Datasets

The study utilized data from 13 longitudinal samples collected across seven cultures: Australia, Israel (Palestinian citizens and Jewish majority), Italy, Poland, Portugal, and Switzerland. The total sample size was N = 7,126 children and adolescents, with ages at Time 1 ranging from 6 to 18 years. Participants were measured between two and six times over the course of the study.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Incoherence as a Driver of Change: The most significant insight is that a lack of internal consistency in one's value system isn't just a sign of disorganization; it actively predicts future change in those values. This supports the idea that psychological tension arising from conflicting goals can motivate individuals to resolve that tension through change.
  • Normative vs. Theoretical Structure: The association between incoherence and value change was stronger when comparing an individual's values to their sample-specific (normative) structure rather than the universal theoretical structure. This suggests that cultural and age-specific norms play a significant role in how value coherence is perceived and how its disruption leads to change.
  • Age is Not the Primary Moderator: Interestingly, the study found that the relationship between value incoherence and value change was largely consistent across different age groups (middle childhood, late childhood, and adolescence). This implies that the underlying process of change driven by incoherence is a fundamental aspect of development throughout youth, not just a phenomenon specific to adolescence.
  • Value Coherence as a Marker of Maturity: The findings align with theories positing that increased personality coherence, including in values, is a marker of maturation and successful integration of experiences.

Key Results

  • The meta-analysis revealed a robust and significant positive association between value incoherence and value change across all samples.
  • Specifically, 91% of the calculated effect sizes were positive and significant, indicating that individuals with less coherent value systems were more likely to experience value change.
  • The pooled correlation coefficients for the association between misfit (incoherence) and value change indicators ranged from r = .15 to r = .40.
  • The association was stronger when using the normative value structure (pooled r between .29 and .40) compared to the theoretical structure (pooled r between .15 and .20).
  • A meta-regression analysis indicated that age group did not significantly moderate the relationship between value incoherence and value change, with only one significant comparison out of sixteen.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Self-Report Bias: The study relied on self-report measures for values, which can be subject to social desirability bias. However, the authors note that social desirability is a trait that is meaningfully associated with value importance and that self-report remains the most effective measure for values.
  • Measure Variability: Different measures were used to assess values across age groups (visual/verbal for children, verbal for adolescents). While the robustness of findings across samples suggests this did not invalidate the results, it's a point of consideration.
  • Attrition: As with most longitudinal studies, attrition was present. While statistical methods were used to account for missing data in some analyses, the unfolding analysis (for incoherence) and the delta index for change only included participants with complete data at specific time points, potentially introducing bias.
  • Cultural Representation: The study's cultural samples, while diverse, had a bias towards Western cultures. The authors suggest that future research should expand to include a wider range of cultures, particularly those with different thinking styles (e.g., dialectical thinking), to explore how cultural context might influence the conceptualization and impact of personality coherence.
  • Mechanisms of Change: The study demonstrates that incoherence predicts change but doesn't fully explain how. Future research could explore potential mechanisms, such as the drive for self-coherence, the difficulty in pursuing conflicting goals, or the influence of social group norms.
  • Broader Personality Constructs: The authors suggest that the methodology developed here could be applied to other personality aspects, like narrative identity and traits, to investigate coherence and its role in development, though operationalizing internal conflict for these constructs is more challenging.
  • Well-being Link: While the study focuses on value change, the authors note that personality incoherence has been theoretically linked to lower well-being. Future research could explore this connection using their measure of value incoherence.

Summary updated

Abstract

We test the theory that personality incoherence may instigate personality change in the context of personal values. Values’ near-universal organization makes value incoherence assessment straightforward. The study included 13 longitudinal samples from seven cultures (Australia, Israel Palestinian citizens, Israel Jewish majority, Italy, Poland, Portugal, and Switzerland), total N = 7,126, and T1 M age ranging between 6 and 18. Each participant reported values between two- and six-times. Using unfolding analysis, we calculated the fit of the internal value structure of each participant at the first time point to the value structure in their sample (normative structure) and to the theoretical structure of values. We estimated value change using Growth Curve Modeling (when at least three measurement times were available) and the difference between T1 and T2 in each sample. We correlated value incoherence with value change and estimated the effect across samples using a meta-analysis. Incoherence with the structure of values predicted greater value change. The associations were stronger when participant’s value structures were compared to the normative value structure at T1 than when they were compared to the theoretical structure. A meta-regression analysis indicated that effects were not moderated by age. We discuss possible underlying processes and implications for personality development.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{daniel2024value,
  author = {Ella Daniel and Anat Bardi and Julie Lee and Ricarda Scholz-Kuhn and Einat Elizarov and Jan Cieciuch and Ariel Knafo‐Noam and Alice Ramos and Michele Vecchione and René Algesheimer and Evelia Murcia Álvarez and Avital Ben Dror Lankry and Maya Benish‐Weisman and Ricardo Borges Rodrigues and Anat Chomsky and Patricia R. Collins and Eldad Davidov and Anna K. Döring and Stefanie Habermann and Dana Katsoty and Martin Kindschi and Elena Makarova and Gilda Marsicano and Kinneret Misgav and Thomas P. Oeschger and Leonor Pereira da Costa and Joanne Sneddon and Iva Tendais and Louise Twito -Weingarten},
  title = {{Value incoherence precedes value change: Evidence from value development in childhood and adolescence across cultures}},
  booktitle = {European},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1177/08902070241289969},
}
Figure