Vacuum geometry and the search for new physics

James Gray, Yang‐Hui He, Vishnu Jejjala, Brent NelsonPhysics 2006 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes "special geometry" in the vacuum space of supersymmetric gauge theories as a guiding principle for phenomenology. They develop algorithmic methods to compute these vacuum geometries and find that certain subsectors of the MSSM exhibit surprisingly simple and fragile geometric structures, suggesting a connection to deeper physics like string theory.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The Standard Model of particle physics, even in its supersymmetric extension (MSSM), contains unexplained structures. While high-energy physics experiments might eventually probe fundamental theories like string theory, current low-energy experiments offer indirect clues. This paper argues that the geometry of the vacuum (or "moduli") space of the MSSM itself can provide such clues. The challenge is that the vacuum structure of the MSSM is complex and not easily understood through traditional field theory methods. The authors propose that if this vacuum geometry exhibits "special" or unexpectedly simple features, it's not a coincidence but a signal of underlying physics, potentially from string theory compactifications. This principle can then guide phenomenological model building by suggesting which extensions to the MSSM are more natural and which higher-dimension operators are likely suppressed.

Methods

The core of the paper is the development and application of algorithmic methods to compute the geometry of the vacuum space of supersymmetric gauge theories. This involves:

  • Identifying Gauge Invariant Operators: First, they determine all possible gauge-invariant combinations of matter fields.
  • Imposing F-flatness Constraints: These constraints, derived from the superpotential, define relations among these operators, effectively reducing the space of possibilities.
  • D-flatness and Gauge Fixing: D-flatness conditions are then used to fix gauge redundancies, leading to the defining equations of the vacuum space as an algebraic variety.
  • Gröbner Basis Computation: The authors employ computational algebraic geometry techniques, specifically Gröbner basis computations (using the Macaulay 2 package), to handle the complexity of these equations and find the structure of the vacuum space.

This approach is novel in its systematic application to finding vacuum geometries for arbitrary N=1 supersymmetric gauge theories.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The "datasets" here are theoretical constructs: the gauge invariant operators and the superpotential of the MSSM and its subsectors.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • "Special Geometry" as a Phenomenological Principle: The central idea is that unexpectedly simple or "special" geometric structures in the vacuum space are not accidental but point to fundamental physics. This is analogous to the concept of "naturalness" in physics, where fine-tuning is disfavored and symmetries or underlying principles are sought.
  • Fragility of Geometric Structure: The paper highlights that the special geometric structures they find are often fragile. They disappear when certain R-parity violating terms are introduced, but persist or are even sharpened by other, more "natural" extensions (like right-handed neutrinos or higher-dimension operators). This suggests that the vacuum geometry is sensitive to the specific interactions present.
  • Connection to String Theory: The authors strongly suggest that these special geometries, which are difficult to explain within standard quantum field theory, are natural inheritances from higher-dimensional string theory compactifications.
  • Algorithmic Approach to Moduli Spaces: The development of an algorithmic method to compute these complex geometries is a significant technical contribution, opening the door to studying more intricate theories.

Key Results

  • Electroweak Sector Analysis: Focusing on the electroweak sector of the MSSM, they found that the vacuum space, initially five-dimensional, becomes three-dimensional when certain natural, R-parity conserving, dimension-four terms are added to the superpotential.
  • Veronese Surface Identification: The base of this three-dimensional vacuum space is identified as the Veronese surface, a mathematically well-understood object with a remarkably simple topological structure (specifically, its Hodge diamond is very simple, with only 0s and 1s). This simplicity is unexpected from a purely field-theoretic perspective.
  • Sensitivity to R-parity Violation: The special geometric structure is lost when R-parity violating terms are introduced, but is preserved or enhanced by R-parity conserving extensions. This provides a criterion for selecting "phenomenologically interesting" deformations.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Computational Scale: The full MSSM calculation is computationally intensive and is planned for future supercomputer analysis. The current work focuses on subsectors.
  • Generalization: While the methods are applicable to any N=1 supersymmetric gauge theory, the specific results are for the MSSM electroweak sector and related toy models.
  • Future Work: The authors propose continuing this program to study the full MSSM and related extensions. They aim to explore the relationship between the MSSM moduli space geometry and string compactification geometries, particularly in D-brane and heterotic models. They also suggest this approach can help find manifestly symmetric Lagrangians and serve as a new tool for model building, guiding the search for new physics by looking for special geometric structures.

Summary updated

Abstract

8 pages, LaTeX; v2: revised title, minor changes in wording, reference added
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gray2006vacuum,
  author = {James Gray and Yang‐Hui He and Vishnu Jejjala and Brent Nelson},
  title = {{Vacuum geometry and the search for new physics}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physletb.2006.05.026},
}
Figure