Utilization of Cobalt and its Oxide/Hydroxide Mediated by Ionic Liquids/Deep Eutectic Solvents as Catalysts in Water Splitting

Chenyun Zhang, J.z. Wang, Jianjiao Jin, Jiahao Wang, Te Bai, Jiacheng Xu, Shun Wang, Lihua Xu, Jing ZhangChemistryOpen 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This review highlights the significant role of ionic liquids (ILs) and deep eutectic solvents (DESs) in the development of advanced cobalt-based catalysts for efficient water splitting. By leveraging the unique properties of ILs and DESs as solvents and templates, researchers can precisely control the structure and composition of cobalt catalysts, leading to enhanced activity and stability for hydrogen and oxygen production.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The global demand for sustainable energy solutions has intensified the search for efficient and cost-effective methods of producing clean fuels like hydrogen. Water splitting, the process of using electricity to break water into hydrogen and oxygen, is a promising avenue, but it requires highly efficient electrocatalysts to overcome energy losses and electrode polarization. While precious metals like platinum are effective, their high cost and limited availability necessitate the exploration of alternative transition metal catalysts. Cobalt and its oxides/hydroxides are attractive candidates due to their abundance and favorable electrochemical properties. However, achieving optimal performance and stability with these materials often requires sophisticated synthesis strategies. This paper addresses the challenge of designing and synthesizing high-performance cobalt-based electrocatalysts for water splitting by exploring the use of ILs and DESs as innovative reaction media.

Methods

This paper is a review, so it doesn't present new experimental methods. Instead, it synthesizes and discusses existing research on the preparation of cobalt, cobalt oxide, and cobalt hydroxide catalysts for water splitting, with a specific focus on the role of ILs and DESs. The review categorizes the preparation methods into:

  • Electrodeposition: Used for creating cobalt metal films and alloys.
  • Calcination: A common method for preparing metal oxides and composites, where ILs/DESs can act as templates or carbon sources.
  • Solvothermal methods: Employed for synthesizing metal alloys and oxides.
  • Co-precipitation: Used in conjunction with DESs for preparing mixed metal oxides.
  • Water injection method: A novel approach for synthesizing layered double hydroxides (LDHs).

The review emphasizes how ILs and DESs influence these methods by:

  • Enhancing solubility: Dissolving precursors and dispersing active species uniformly.
  • Regulating reaction mechanisms: Controlling nucleation, growth, crystal structure, and electronic properties.
  • Stabilizing intermediates: Forming stable complexes with metal ions and reducing side reactions.
  • Acting as templates: Directing the formation of specific morphologies and porous structures.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • ILs and DESs as "Green" and Functional Media: These solvents are not just inert reaction environments; they actively participate in catalyst synthesis, offering tunable properties and enabling more sustainable and efficient processes compared to traditional organic solvents.
  • Precise Control Over Catalyst Morphology and Composition: The ability of ILs and DESs to precisely control nucleation, growth, and aggregation is crucial for tailoring the surface area, porosity, and crystal structure of cobalt catalysts, directly impacting their catalytic performance.
  • Synergistic Effects in Alloys and Composites: The review highlights how ILs and DESs facilitate the creation of sophisticated cobalt alloys and composites (e.g., N,S-NiCoFe alloy, Co@NPC) where the combination of different elements or materials leads to significantly enhanced activity and stability beyond individual components.
  • Overcoming Limitations of Traditional Methods: ILs and DESs enable simpler, one-step synthesis routes, reduce reaction times and temperatures, and avoid harsh reaction conditions, making catalyst preparation more accessible and environmentally friendly.
  • DESs as a Cost-Effective Alternative to ILs: While ILs offer remarkable control, their high cost can be a barrier. DESs, often composed of cheaper and more readily available components, provide a compelling alternative with similar advantages in catalyst synthesis.

Key Results

The review showcases numerous examples of cobalt-based catalysts prepared using ILs and DESs that demonstrate excellent performance in water splitting (both HER and OER):

  • Cobalt Metal: Renjith et al. [25] achieved fine deposition of Co metal films using a ChCl/malonic acid DES, resulting in an overpotential of 350 mV at 10 mA/cm² for OER.
  • Cobalt Composites: Li et al. [26] prepared Co@NPC using a ChCl/urea/glucose acid DES, achieving an overpotential of 215 mV for HER in acidic conditions and 274 mV in alkaline conditions.
  • Cobalt Alloys: The N,S-NiCoFe alloy prepared using a novel DES exhibited excellent OER performance with an overpotential of 251 mV and a Tafel slope of 58 mV/dec.
  • Cobalt Oxides: Ordered CoO nanosheets synthesized using [BMIM]Tf2N showed an overpotential of 320 mV and a Tafel slope of 70 mV/dec for OER. NiCo₂O₄ prepared using ChCl/glycerol DES demonstrated an overpotential of 320 mV and a Tafel slope of 67 mV/dec for OER, with remarkable stability over 2000 cycles.
  • Cobalt Hydroxides: CoFe hydroxide and CoNi hydroxide prepared using [BMIM]BF4 IL showed overpotentials of 350 mV and 420 mV, respectively, for OER.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Cost and Scalability of ILs: While ILs offer superior control, their high cost and complex synthesis methods can hinder large-scale industrial applications. Future work should focus on developing more cost-effective ILs or optimizing their recycling.
  • Further Optimization of IL/DES Systems: Continued research is needed to fine-tune the composition and properties of ILs and DESs to achieve even more efficient and selective catalyst preparation. This includes exploring new cation-anion combinations and hydrogen bond donor-acceptor pairs.
  • Deeper Mechanistic Understanding: A more profound understanding of the solvent-metal interactions, solvent-solvent interactions, and reaction mechanisms within ILs and DESs is crucial for rational catalyst design and process control.
  • Practical Application and Durability: While promising results are presented, further investigation into the long-term durability, stability under various operating conditions, and practical implementation of these catalysts in real-world water splitting devices is necessary.
  • Exploration of New Combinations: The review suggests exploring a wider range of DES and metal combinations to discover novel cobalt alloys with exceptional performance, pushing the boundaries of clean energy technologies.

Summary updated

Abstract

With the ever-growing global demand for sustainable energy solutions, hydrogen has garnered significant attention as a clean, efficient, and renewable energy source. In the field of hydrogen production, catalyst research stands out as one of the foremost areas of focus. In recent years, the preparation of electrocatalysts using ionic liquids (ILs) and deep eutectic solvents (DESs) has attracted widespread attention. ILs and DESs possess unique physicochemical properties and are recognized as green media as well as functional materials. Cobalt-based catalysts have proven to be efficient electrocatalysts for water splitting. Incorporating ILs or DESs into the preparation of cobalt-based catalysts offers a remarkable advantage by allowing precise control over their structural design and composition. This control directly influences the adsorption properties of the catalyst's surface and the stability of reaction intermediates, thereby enabling enhanced control over reaction pathways and product selectivity. Consequently, the catalytic activity and stability of cobalt-based catalysts can be effectively improved. In the process of preparing cobalt-based catalysts, ILs and DESs can serve as solvents and templates. Owing to the good solubility of ILs and DESs, they can efficiently dissolve raw materials and provide a special nucleation and growth environment, obtaining catalysts with novel-structures. The main focus of this review is to provide a detailed introduction to metal cobalt and its oxide/hydroxide derivatives in the field of water splitting, with a particular emphasis on the research progress achieved through the utilization of IL and DES. The aim is to assist readers in designing and synthesizing novel and high-performance electrochemical catalysts.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024utilization,
  author = {Chenyun Zhang and J.Z. Wang and Jianjiao Jin and Jiahao Wang and Te Bai and Jiacheng Xu and Shun Wang and Lihua Xu and Jing Zhang and Lihua Xu and Jing Zhang},
  title = {{Utilization of Cobalt and its Oxide/Hydroxide Mediated by Ionic Liquids/Deep Eutectic Solvents as Catalysts in Water Splitting}},
  booktitle = {ChemistryOpen},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1002/open.202400136},
}
Figure