Utility of endoscopic anatomical optical coherence tomography in functional rhinoplasty

Santosh Balakrishnan, Ruofei Bu, Candace M. Waters, Bryan M. Brandon, Julia S. Kimbell, Wesley H. Stepp, W. Shockley, Madison Clark, Amy L. OldenburgJournal of Biomedical Optics 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper explores the utility of anatomical optical coherence tomography (aOCT) for objectively assessing the nasal valve region before and after functional rhinoplasty. The study demonstrates that aOCT provides accurate, quantitative, and volumetric scans comparable to CT, making it a promising tool for surgical planning and outcome evaluation without the need for ionizing radiation.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Nasal airway obstruction, particularly due to nasal valve compromise (NVC), is a common and significant issue. While physical exams and patient-reported outcomes are standard for diagnosis and treatment evaluation, there's a growing need for objective, quantitative measurements. Current imaging methods like CT and MRI provide static anatomical data but don't capture dynamic airflow or nasal congestion. Acoustic rhinometry offers physiological measures but lacks detailed anatomical insight. The authors aim to bridge this gap by evaluating aOCT, a real-time, high-resolution imaging technique, as a tool for precise, volumetric assessment of the nasal valve region, crucial for functional rhinoplasty.

Methods

The researchers utilized a cart-based swept-source aOCT system with a center wavelength of 1300 nm and an axial resolution of approximately 13 µm. The aOCT probe, integrated into an endoscopic setup, was guided into the nasal airway. Helical scans were performed by rotating and translating the probe, capturing volumetric data.

For comparison and validation, computed tomography (CT) scans were also acquired. The CT data underwent resampling to align with the airflow direction, and both CT and aOCT volumes were segmented to isolate the nasal airway. To quantitatively compare the two modalities, the CT volumes were modified to match the aOCT system's limited field of view. The similarity between the segmented volumes was assessed using the Dice similarity coefficient (DSC) and Hausdorff distance (HD).

Datasets

The study used four adult cadaveric heads (2 male, 2 female; aged 65-86 years) obtained from Science Care Inc. These cadavers served as the basis for both CT and aOCT imaging before and after simulated functional rhinoplasty procedures (spreader grafts and butterfly grafts). No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing CT data was used as a gold standard for comparison.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • aOCT as a Radiation-Free Alternative: The study highlights aOCT's potential to replace or supplement CT for nasal airway assessment, thereby avoiding patient exposure to ionizing radiation.
  • Real-time, Volumetric Assessment: Unlike static CT scans, aOCT offers real-time, volumetric imaging, which is crucial for understanding the dynamic nature of nasal airflow and the impact of interventions.
  • Bridging the Gap Between Anatomy and Physiology: By providing detailed 3D volumetric data, aOCT can be used to generate computational fluid dynamics (CFD) models, offering a more physiological understanding of nasal patency.
  • Visualizing Deeper Structures: aOCT's ability to image beneath the tissue surface allowed visualization of cartilaginous structures like the upper and lower lateral cartilages, and the septal cartilage, providing valuable anatomical context.

Key Results

  • High Agreement with CT: The aOCT-derived nasal airway volumes showed a high degree of similarity to CT-derived volumes, with a mean Dice similarity coefficient (DSC) of 0.88 and a mean Hausdorff distance (HD) of 2.3 mm.
  • Accurate Shape Representation: aOCT images accurately represented the shape of the nasal cavity, including the internal nasal valve (INV) region.
  • Qualitative Similarity: Visual comparisons between aOCT and nasal video endoscopy images showed similar morphology of the nasal cavity and INV region, both before and after surgical interventions.
  • Procedure Impact: The study demonstrated that aOCT could visualize the widening of the nasal valve apex after spreader graft (SG) and butterfly graft (BFG) procedures.
  • Imaging Time: The total time for positioning and acquiring 10 aOCT scans per head was approximately 16 ± 13 minutes, with potential for improvement.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Imaging Range and Positioning: The limited imaging range of the aOCT system and the positioning of the probe tip sometimes resulted in portions of the nasal airway being missed. This necessitated modifying CT volumes to match aOCT scan volumes for comparison.
  • Operator Experience: The authors anticipate that increased operator experience would improve the consistency and accuracy of INV imaging.
  • INV Angle Measurement: While aOCT could visualize the INV, measuring a single INV angle for complex nasal valve shapes was deemed unlikely to be robust or accurate.
  • Artifacts: Nonuniform rotational distortion (NURD) was identified as a potential artifact affecting agreement in some cases.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest further studies to validate aOCT's accuracy, optimize the imaging protocol, and explore other potential applications for aOCT in nasal valve assessment. They also propose using aOCT-generated volumes for CFD simulations to gain a more physiological understanding of nasal patency.

Summary updated

Abstract

Objective measurement of the nasal valve region is valuable for the assessment of functional rhinoplasty surgical outcomes. Anatomical optical coherence tomography (aOCT) is an imaging modality that may be used to obtain real-time, quantitative, and volumetric scans of the nasal airway. We aim to evaluate if volumetric aOCT imaging is useful for the examination of the nasal valve region before and after functional rhinoplasty procedures. aOCT scans of the nasal valves were performed on four cadaveric heads before and after spreader graft and butterfly graft procedures. The resulting aOCT images were compared against video endoscopy images, and the segmented volumes of the nasal airway obtained from aOCT scans were compared with computed tomography (CT) derived volumes acquired under the same conditions. The aOCT-derived volumes match the CT volumes closely, with a mean Dice similarity coefficient of 0.88 and a mean Hausdorff distance of 2.3 mm. Furthermore, the aOCT images were found to represent the shape of the nasal cavity accurately. Due to its ability to perform real-time, quantitative, and accurate evaluation of the nasal airway, aOCT imaging is a promising modality for the objective assessment of the nasal valves before and after functional rhinoplasty procedures.
BibTeX
@article{balakrishnan2020utility,
  author = {Santosh Balakrishnan and Ruofei Bu and Candace M. Waters and Bryan M. Brandon and Julia S. Kimbell and Wesley H. Stepp and W. Shockley and Madison Clark and Amy L. Oldenburg},
  title = {{Utility of endoscopic anatomical optical coherence tomography in functional rhinoplasty}},
  journal = {Journal of Biomedical Optics},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.1117/1.jbo.25.1.016001},
}
Figure